Talk:Happiness (Red Velvet song)/GA2

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: K. Peake (talk · contribs) 07:06, 9 March 2021 (UTC)

Good Article review progress box Criteria: 1a. prose () 1b. MoS () 2a. ref layout () 2b. cites WP:RS () 2c. no WP:OR () 2d. no WP:CV () 3a. broadness () 3b. focus () 4. neutral () 5. stable () 6a. free or tagged images () 6b. pics relevant () Note: this represents where the article stands relative to the Good Article criteria. Criteria marked are unassessed

It is ideal for me to review the article on this occasion, as I am the one who completed the first review, which will be relevant here. --K. Peake 07:06, 9 March 2021 (UTC)

Infobox and lead

 Done

• Target Euro-pop to Europop  Done
• "as their debut single" → "as the group's debut single" with the target  Done
• "the group's first release under the "Red" concept" → "their first release under the Red Velvet moniker" for accuracy  Removed
• Like in the previous review, the well-known/introduction sentence is not sourced in the body  Removed
• "A vibrant urban Euro-pop track," → "An urban Euro-pop track," because the word "vibrant" is not appropriate for the lead  Done
• Even though you should write about what critics commented on, use summarizing instead of quotes plus add both positive and negative  Done
• "The music video was released on August 3, 2014 but a new version of the music video" → "An accompanying music video was released on August 3, 2014, but a new version" with the wikilink  Done
• Mention that it was due to "references to" the bombings then put "and" followed by mentioning the attacks  Done
• "The debut stage for "Happiness" was performed in" → "Red Velvet's debut stage for the song was a performance on"  Done
• "and further promotions was" → "and further promotion was"  Done

Background and composition

 Done

• The 2013 and 2014 parts are still not sourced  Removed
• "Rumors have since sparked out" → "Rumors soon sparked out"  Done
• Wikilink music video  Done
• "for the "Happiness" was" → "for "Happiness" was" plus this can remain here, as it is about this being their first song when teased  Done
• The first girl group part is still unsourced  Removed
• Audio sample looks good!  Done
• Again, the synth, African music beat and "Red" parts need to be sourced  Done
• 9 offers a mention of electronic sound that you could do with writing in  Done
• "of 121 beat-per-minute." → "of 121 beat-per-minutes."  Done
• Wikilink Yoo Young-jin  Done

Reception

 Done

• "further saying that" → "further noticing how"  Done
• The singles of the year and award should come before the commercial info, being the second para while the latter is the third  Done
• "The song has since sold" → "The song has sold" because "since" is redundant when you have wrote "as of"  Done
• "The song received a nomination" → "It received a nomination"  Done

Music video

  Done

Background

• Wikilink imagery  Done
• Remove the official music video sentence because that is repeating the first sentence of this sub-section  Done
• Wikilink music video on the img text and invoke [27] solely at the end of the sentence after [6]  Done

Synopsis and reception

• "patterns and combination of live action animations." → "patterns, and combination of live action and animation." per the source  Done
• 27 says about a split screen that you have not mentioned here  Done
• "it shows of dynamic camera movements" → "it has dynamic camera movements"  Done
• "from reality overcoming" → "from reality, overcoming"  Done
• There are parts like the roller coaster from 6 that you have not mentioned even though they're notable  Done
• "described the group's" → "noted Red Velvet's"  Done
• "on the music video." → "in the music video."  Done
• "On December 3 2020," → "On December 3, 2020,"  Done
• "YouTube becoming the first" → "YouTube, with them becoming the first" with the wikilink  Done
• "and ninth music video of" → "while it was the ninth music video of"  Done

Controversy

• "When I inquired with the music video director, it was said that there was no intention because it was simply using the image source of the collage technique." is the first statement said by [32], but you have quoted otherwise without using []; is this an error or is my translator just poor?  Done
• Regarding the second statement, the source only says the label removed the content and "I will take care to prevent this from happening in the future."  Done

Live performances

 Done

• "in SM Town Live World Tour IV at" → "for SM Town Live World Tour IV at the"  Done

Track listing

 Done

• Good  Done

Credits and personnel

 Done

• Credits adapted from the liner notes of Happiness. → Credits adapted from the liner notes of "Happiness".  Done
• Shouldn't you mention the recording studios being in Seoul?  Done
• Target Red Velvet to Red Velvet (group)  Done
• Use {{spaced ndash}} so there is the right space between credits and personnel  Done

Charts

 Done

Weekly charts

• Target World Digital Songs to World Digital Song Sales  Done

Monthly charts

• Add on the caption that it is the August 2014 monthly chart performance for "Happiness"  Done

Release history

 Done

• Format → Format(s)  Done
• Label → Label(s)  Done
• Apart from refs, the cols should not be centered  Done

References

 Done

• Copyvio score looks amazing at 10.7%!!!  Done
• Make sure all of these are archived by using the tool  Done
• Wikilink Asia Business Daily on ref 3  Done
• Cite Hankook Ilbo as work instead for ref 6 with the wikilink, removing the other one  Done
• Cite Melon as publisher instead for ref 7  Done
• WP:OVERLINK of Hankook Ilbo on ref 12  Done
• Cite Gaon Music Chart as publisher instead for refs 14, 15, 16 and 41  Done
• WP:OVERLINK of Billboard for refs 18 and 26  Done
• Cite JoongAng Ilbo as work instead for ref 20, removing the other one  Done
• Cite Mnet America as publisher instead for ref 22  Done
• Remove work from ref 23  Done
• Remove publisher from ref 24  Done
• Remove work from ref 27  Done
• Ditto for ref 31  Done
• Target Sports Chosun to The Chosun Ilbo on ref 36 and remove the publisher  Done
• Make sure "Happiness" isn't italicized for ref 40 – add ''" "'' to the ends – plus wikilink SM Entertainment  Done
• WP:OVERLINK of Melon on ref 43  Done

The comments for the review have been

Resolved

.

Final comments and verdict

•  On hold until all of the issues are fixed, but this is definitely a lot better than the last time I reviewed! --K. Peake 10:02, 9 March 2021 (UTC)

@Kyle Peake: All comments on the review regarding the article have all been resolved. I'm sorry for the mistakes regarding you saying "Again" when it comes to the previous review. :) I'm working hard in improving myself on nominating and editing articles that could be listed under "GA". Also, thank you so much for the effort! I do always appreciate the effort you're giving in making these reviews! You really are the best! Hope to work with you soon once again! :) --LipaCityPH 00:26, 10 March 2021 (UTC)

@LipaCityPH: Fantastic job; you had made a few mistakes when adding in new info, but since those were not issues that existed at the time of review I thought it would be fine for me to copyedit the fixes in. ✓ Pass now, plus you only missed out on one actual requested change with ref formatting so I copyedited it in. --K. Peake 07:45, 10 March 2021 (UTC)