Talk:Gary Mauer

Latest comment: 15 years ago by Rurp in topic "Best Phantom"

"Best Phantom" edit

I have deleted the comment about "Gary is widely regarded as the greatest Phantom of all time." This is 1) totally unsubstiantiated, and 2) far-fetched. On a poll, which has unfortunately now been removed, on Phantom's official site, Gary received 6% of the vote on a "Who's your favorite Phantom" poll, compared to Michael Crawford's 75%. Also, I have never seen a newspaper article comparing Mauer to Crawford, whereas I've seen several comparing, say, Anthony Warlow to Crawford. I'm not saying such articles do not exist, I just haven't seen any. As such, please do not re-insert the claim unless you can supply a source for it, per WP:NPOV, WP:V, and WP:OR. By the way, I do think Mauer's interpretation is excellent, but that's just an opinion. Rurp (talk) 09:44, 18 June 2008 (UTC)Reply