Talk:Fantasia X

Latest comment: 2 years ago by Nangears in topic Clash quote

Clash quote edit

@FlareOn0904: The way you are editing the quotation is misrepresenting what is the actual quote in the article. The actual quoted material in the article is:

"At seven tracks, 'Fantasia X' is a distillation of Monsta X’s many parts. Light, breezy pop ('Beautiful Night') nestles beside sensual, bassy funk (“It Ain’t Over”), the record’s middle section reinforced by the commanding brass and EDM of 'Chaotic' and a thumping party track - “On the previous album there was 'Fallin' that makes everyone run around,” says Minhyuk, “but this time there is 'Zone', which I.M wrote, which makes everyone go crazy.” But for Kihyun, “it’s important that “Monbebe pay attention to the lyrics. Especially the message that ‘we don't kneel and move forward’.”
That message is the backbone of 'Stand Up' - a confession of pain experienced but also a rallying cry to prevail. Beneath its bouncy, trop-house beats, is what Shownu calls a “touching song” and, as the album’s closing track, he and Minhyuk admit it reflects the band’s journey through dark places to emerge on the other side."

This has been edited to the relevant info so the only parts of this that are quoted in the actual article are:

'Fantasia X' is a distillation of Monsta X’s many parts. Light, breezy pop ('Beautiful Night') nestles beside sensual, bassy funk (“It Ain’t Over”), the record’s middle section reinforced by the commanding brass and EDM of 'Chaotic' and a thumping party track
a confession of pain experienced but also a rallying cry to prevail
Beneath its bouncy, trop-house beats
reflects the band's journey through dark places to emerge on the other side

so these are the only parts that should be in quotations. The way you have edited the quotation includes the part in the song "Zone" that follows the "thumping party track" quote in the actual article, but that is not part of the quote, that is a clarification of what song is being referred to, as the quote has been shortened to remove the group members' quotes about the album, as this section is meant to be focused on critics reception to the album.

Also, a song should be placed in double quotation marks, as a title, unless it is within a quote, then it should be single quotation marks, so both "Stand Up" and "Zone" should be in double quotations in this section, as neither are inside a quote. Nangears (talk) 17:32, 21 April 2022 (UTC)Reply