Talk:Elie (disambiguation)

Latest comment: 17 years ago by Crazyscot

I live in Elie and holiday in France. I can safely say these crossaints aren't worthy of special praise. Is the author the owner of this deli?

--81.1.72.35, 23 April 2006

The sentences discussing the Israelite name Elie don't belong in this article so I've removed them. (That's not to say that they're without merit; I'm unqualified to comment. If an article or section of an article is worthwhile, a disambiguation page would appear to be the way to go.)

It's not clear what benefit a mention of a single business with disputed merits brings to an encyclopedia, so I've removed the mention of Elie Deli for the sake of having a clean article.

I'm still unconvinced that this article really needs to exist on its own; given the intertwined nature of the two villages, a combined Elie and Earlsferry article seems to me to be a better solution.

Crazyscot 23:29, 31 August 2006 (UTC)Reply

Um, there are other people named Elie. Such as the one from Groove Adventure Rave.