| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Voting system related pages WikiProject |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 3#Voting system related pages WikiProject
|
| want to add a section for how the absentee ballot is handled in various states |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 1#want to add a section for how the absentee ballot is handled in various states
|
| classification scheme |
3 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 1#classification scheme
|
| orphaned article: Simple Majority Voting |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 1#orphaned article: Simple Majority Voting
|
| classification scheme - take 2 |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 1#classification scheme - take 2
|
| Single Winner Variations SECTION |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 1#Single Winner Variations SECTION
|
| theory vs. practice/history |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 1#theory vs. practice/history
|
| "... is not guaranteed..." |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 1#"... is not guaranteed..."
|
| dispute about external link |
12 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#dispute about external link
|
| electowiki link |
13 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 1#electowiki link
|
| Remove University of Texas tutorial |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 1#Remove University of Texas tutorial
|
| Challenge to validity of Independence of Clones criteria |
19 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 1#Challenge to validity of Independence of Clones criteria
|
| NPOV notice |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 1#NPOV notice
|
| Inconsistent use of voting method criteria |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 1#Inconsistent use of voting method criteria
|
| approval/range and ICC |
13 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 1#approval/range and ICC
|
| Table is Biased POV towards Condorcet methods |
19 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 1#Table is Biased POV towards Condorcet methods
|
| doubling of page content: be on the lookout for possible deletion |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 1#doubling of page content: be on the lookout for possible deletion
|
| Voting theory articles |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 3#Voting theory articles
|
| STV and IRV point of information |
4 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 1#STV and IRV point of information
|
| The path toward a featured article |
5 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#The path toward a featured article
|
| Restructuring Voting System Articles |
4 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Restructuring Voting System Articles
|
| Voter Satisfaction |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Voter Satisfaction
|
| Finally |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Finally
|
| Link purge |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Link purge
|
| Peer review |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Peer review
|
| Tie-breaking votes |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Tie-breaking votes
|
| Voting Power |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Voting Power
|
| German election (2005) |
3 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#German election (2005)
|
| Image Names |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Image Names
|
| Nice job |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Nice job
|
| (single-winner) president, governing majority (or minority), representation, coalitions |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#(single-winner) president, governing majority (or minority), representation, coalitions
|
| Voting system criteria |
12 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Voting system criteria
|
| It's a great article, but it only begins to explain why any of these alternate voting systems should even be considered for use. |
14 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#It's a great article, but it only begins to explain why any of these alternate voting systems should even be considered for use.
|
| No mention of the Web |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#No mention of the Web
|
| Without time no morality |
6 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Without time no morality
|
| Request for comment |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Request for comment
|
| Autobiographical edits |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Autobiographical edits
|
| disambig |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#disambig
|
| Talk:Social Choice and Individual Values |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Talk:Social Choice and Individual Values
|
| Criteria merge |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Criteria merge
|
| Range voting research paper |
5 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Range voting research paper
|
| A wikipedia voting system |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#A wikipedia voting system
|
| Requested move |
23 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Requested move
|
| Organizing articles about elections and voting |
12 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Organizing articles about elections and voting
|
| Two infoboxes? |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Two infoboxes?
|
| Voting criteria compliance boxes |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Voting criteria compliance boxes
|
| Majority criterion |
3 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Majority criterion
|
| Universality criteria |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Universality criteria
|
| Have all the voting systems been validated? |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Have all the voting systems been validated?
|
| Vote-sizing? |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Vote-sizing?
|
| Computing power |
7 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Computing power
|
| Why is the table so poor? |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Why is the table so poor?
|
| Impossible |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Impossible
|
| "Voting system" vs. "Voting method" |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#"Voting system" vs. "Voting method"
|
| Comment about Bucklin removed from article. |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Comment about Bucklin removed from article.
|
| Electoral fairness with respect to geography, regionalism and multi-ethnic federations and confederations |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Electoral fairness with respect to geography, regionalism and multi-ethnic federations and confederations
|
| Range voting satisfies IIA? |
19 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Range voting satisfies IIA?
|
| Own method |
3 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 2#Own method
|
| Later no harm criteria? |
15 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 4#Later no harm criteria?
|
| IRV runtime (was: Added "summability" column) |
10 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 3#IRV runtime (was: Added "summability" column)
|
| Yet another proposed column: "Equal rankings" Done |
4 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 4#Yet another proposed column: "Equal rankings" Done
|
| Proxy voting |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 3#Proxy voting
|
| Yay/Nay System |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 3#Yay/Nay System
|
| Bucklin criteria |
21 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 3#Bucklin criteria
|
| LNH colors dispute (subsection) |
13 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 3#LNH colors dispute (subsection)
|
| "Proportional Voting Rights" or "Adjusted Voting Rights" or "Proportional Voting Power"(?) |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 3#"Proportional Voting Rights" or "Adjusted Voting Rights" or "Proportional Voting Power"(?)
|
| How is Approval Voting with an Arbitrary Cutoff not Independent of Clones? |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 3#How is Approval Voting with an Arbitrary Cutoff not Independent of Clones?
|
| Write-in criterion |
6 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 3#Write-in criterion
|
| Thoughts on a new sub-section: ordinality |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 3#Thoughts on a new sub-section: ordinality
|
| Push back to featured? |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 3#Push back to featured?
|
| Criteria |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 3#Criteria
|
| Majority judgment and later-no-harm |
6 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 3#Majority judgment and later-no-harm
|
| approval/LNH |
15 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 4#approval/LNH
|
| Approval "allows equal rankings"? |
5 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 3#Approval "allows equal rankings"?
|
| Split Later-no-help and Later-no-harm into two columns |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 3#Split Later-no-help and Later-no-harm into two columns
|
| Multiple-winner methods and consituencies |
7 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 4#Multiple-winner methods and consituencies
|
| Color of the table for criteria pass/fail |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 4#Color of the table for criteria pass/fail
|
| Consistency/Participation of Random Ballot Done |
4 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 4#Consistency/Participation of Random Ballot Done
|
| Criteria Table: Ballot types column |
23 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 4#Criteria Table: Ballot types column
|
| Article lacks information about the relative importance of criteria. |
8 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 4#Article lacks information about the relative importance of criteria.
|
| IIA/ISDA Done |
21 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 4#IIA/ISDA Done
|
| About Majority Judgment Done |
35 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 5#About Majority Judgment Done
|
| Approval/LNH again Done |
94 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 4#Approval/LNH again Done
|
| RfC: Is later-no-harm applicable to Approval voting? Done |
36 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 5#RfC: Is later-no-harm applicable to Approval voting? Done
|
| International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance handbook |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 5#International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance handbook
|
| IIA and Majority Judgement, Approval, Range Voting |
7 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 5#IIA and Majority Judgement, Approval, Range Voting
|
| Random Winner, Random ballot, resolvability and tie-breaking |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 5#Random Winner, Random ballot, resolvability and tie-breaking
|
| Ranked Pairs vs Schulze method |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 5#Ranked Pairs vs Schulze method
|
| Runtime complexity |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 5#Runtime complexity
|
| Approval/LNH, part 3 |
57 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 5#Approval/LNH, part 3
|
| Updates To Plurality In Compliance Table For LNH |
13 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 5#Updates To Plurality In Compliance Table For LNH
|
| Less pink |
6 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 5#Less pink
|
| Mathematical criteria section looks really ugly. |
3 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 5#Mathematical criteria section looks really ugly.
|
| Rearrange table with Favorite Betrayal as first column |
5 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#Rearrange table with Favorite Betrayal as first column
|
| historical quote |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#historical quote
|
| Strategic Condorcet Criterion Citation Needed - Concern Over Hypothetical Conditions In Table |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#Strategic Condorcet Criterion Citation Needed - Concern Over Hypothetical Conditions In Table
|
| Citation For IIA and Rating Methods Compliance? + Question |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#Citation For IIA and Rating Methods Compliance? + Question
|
| Does IRV Satisfy "Strategic Majority" Condorcet, Participation, Monotonicity, and LIIA? + PROPOSAL BEFORE EDIT |
4 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#Does IRV Satisfy "Strategic Majority" Condorcet, Participation, Monotonicity, and LIIA? + PROPOSAL BEFORE EDIT
|
| Cumulative Voting |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#Cumulative Voting
|
| LNH & Approval – No Citation Needed |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#LNH & Approval – No Citation Needed
|
| IIA Imprecise Stipulation: "Votes for other candidates can not change" - Depends On Voter Cutoff Model Assumed |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#IIA Imprecise Stipulation: "Votes for other candidates can not change" - Depends On Voter Cutoff Model Assumed
|
| Can we get a source other than “Cardinal Voting: The Way to Escape the Social Choice Impossibility”? |
5 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#Can we get a source other than “Cardinal Voting: The Way to Escape the Social Choice Impossibility”?
|
| Add Symmetrical ICT? |
3 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#Add Symmetrical ICT?
|
| Additional Criteria? |
5 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#Additional Criteria?
|
| Removal of Condorcet-IRV method |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#Removal of Condorcet-IRV method
|
| Changes made to citations |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#Changes made to citations
|
| Blacklisted Links Found on the Main Page |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#Blacklisted Links Found on the Main Page
|
| Deletion review on Favorite betrayal criterion |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#Deletion review on Favorite betrayal criterion
|
| RFC - favorite betrayal? |
49 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#RFC - favorite betrayal?
|
| Split out criteria and table to separate article and transclude? |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#Split out criteria and table to separate article and transclude?
|
| RE: Edits Qualifying IIA Compliance for Rating Methods |
6 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#RE: Edits Qualifying IIA Compliance for Rating Methods
|
| Counterexample To Qualification Of Majority Judgement Failure Of Later-No-Harm |
3 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#Counterexample To Qualification Of Majority Judgement Failure Of Later-No-Harm
|
| Approval & Majority Judgement Qualified Failure of Majority Criterion |
4 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#Approval & Majority Judgement Qualified Failure of Majority Criterion
|
| What is our standard for qualified failure of Condorcet? |
11 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#What is our standard for qualified failure of Condorcet?
|
| Majority Judgment Qualified Failure Condorcet Loser |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#Majority Judgment Qualified Failure Condorcet Loser
|
| Interesting reference |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#Interesting reference
|
| Majority "Rated" Consistency And Justification WP:OR Problem |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#Majority "Rated" Consistency And Justification WP:OR Problem
|
| Inconsistent Reasons For Majority Judgment (MJ) Qualified Compliance |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#Inconsistent Reasons For Majority Judgment (MJ) Qualified Compliance
|
| Electoral Systems Maps lacking a color code legend, date or source |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#Electoral Systems Maps lacking a color code legend, date or source
|
| Runoff voting and Condorcet loser |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#Runoff voting and Condorcet loser
|
| Compliance table - exhaustive balloting, block voting, preferential block voting, and STV |
9 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 6#Compliance table - exhaustive balloting, block voting, preferential block voting, and STV
|
| Doesn't Random Ballot satisfy those criteria on average? |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 7#Doesn't Random Ballot satisfy those criteria on average?
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 7#External links modified
|
| Voting systems#Compliance of selected systems (table) |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 7#Voting systems#Compliance of selected systems (table)
|
| Requested move 11 February 2017 |
91 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 7#Requested move 11 February 2017
|
| What now? |
58 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 7#What now?
|
| Oh no, not again |
26 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 8#Oh no, not again
|
| "Hidden" draft version of replacement article is being written |
24 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 8#"Hidden" draft version of replacement article is being written
|
| Hello! There is a DR/N request relating to this article. |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 8#Hello! There is a DR/N request relating to this article.
|
| Starting a draft of Voting rule. |
13 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 8#Starting a draft of Voting rule.
|
| Dividing between single- and multi-winner systems |
13 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 8#Dividing between single- and multi-winner systems
|
| Proposed new intro section. |
30 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 8#Proposed new intro section.
|
| "Electoral formula" |
18 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 9#"Electoral formula"
|
| Conclaves should be added |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 9#Conclaves should be added
|
| Topic organization |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 9#Topic organization
|
| EU parliament - national election systems - help wanted! |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 9#EU parliament - national election systems - help wanted!
|
| Meaning of: "how the ballots are counted" |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 9#Meaning of: "how the ballots are counted"
|
| The basic problem |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 9#The basic problem
|
| Source For Plurality Used In Majoritarian Systems? |
5 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 9#Source For Plurality Used In Majoritarian Systems?
|
| Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 9#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment
|
| Why is the US marked as "no direct election"? |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 9#Why is the US marked as "no direct election"?
|
| Head of Government v Head of State |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system/Archive 9#Head of Government v Head of State
|
| Main Article Map: Bad Colors |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system#Main Article Map: Bad Colors
|
| SNTV is not a form of block voting, not all voting in MMD is block voting |
1 |
Talk:Electoral system#SNTV is not a form of block voting, not all voting in MMD is block voting
|
| Define the term electoral system |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system#Define the term electoral system
|
| चुनाव प्रणाली क्या है |
2 |
Talk:Electoral system#चुनाव प्रणाली क्या है
|
| Request: Rewrite categories to follow more standard, four-family classification |
14 |
Talk:Electoral system#Request: Rewrite categories to follow more standard, four-family classification
|
| Suggestion: Split portions off into multiwinner and single-winner systems |
3 |
Talk:Electoral system#Suggestion: Split portions off into multiwinner and single-winner systems
|
