Talk:DC Super Hero Girls (TV series)

Latest comment: 3 years ago by IJBall in topic Voice Cast Section?

RemoteUncontrolled and TheSlowAndTheFurious edit

The two YouTube shorts, RemoteUncontrolled and TheSlowAndTheFurious, appear to have been uploaded to YouTube and then quickly deleted: "#TheSlowAndTheFurious | DC Super Hero Girls: Super Shorts. by DC Super Hero Girls. 3:41", "#RemoteUncontrolled | DC Super Hero Girls: Super Shorts. by DC Super Hero Girls. 3:02". Unfortunately they do not appear in any reliable source. I'm going to undo my edit, but be aware that there probably won't be a citation for these shorts until a few days before they are supposed to be uploaded. Bright☀ 08:20, 29 May 2019 (UTC)Reply

Voice Cast Section? edit

Hi all,

Is there a reason the "Voice Cast" section was removed from the page? Most other animated shows have a cast/voice section and it seems to me that this page should too, instead of listing the cast in prose in the "Premise" section.

Apathyash (talk) 20:04, 31 May 2020 (UTC)Reply

@IJBall: Hi, I wanted to talk about your recent removal of the cast table. I agree it was poorly formatted and the incorrect way to display the information, but I think that the page could use a "voice cast" or "cast" section. I know there is already a "List of DC Super Hero Girls characters" page linked, but I guess I don't understand why this page lists the cast in prose when it seems common practice to have a voice cast/cast section on many other cartoon articles. This isn't a criticism; I'm newer to Wikipedia and just want to understand the reasoning for the future. Apathyash (talk) 00:28, 28 January 2021 (UTC)Reply
@Apathyash: I actually have no objection to a separate 'Characters' or 'Cast' section here (though, strictly, with how this article and its 'Premise' section is set up, it is not "required" that there be a separate section for this). It's just that if a 'Characters' or 'Cast' section is spun-out, it should be in "standard" list-format, not in the pointless and unnecessary format of a table. (This kind of information is not suited to presentation in the form of a table.) Also, because there is a separate 'List of characters' article, only the "main" cast/characters should be listed here – things like "recurring" characters should generally be at the 'List of characters' article only. --IJBall (contribstalk) 00:55, 28 January 2021 (UTC)Reply