Talk:Cultural impact of the Guitar Hero series/GA1
Latest comment: 14 years ago by Bridies in topic GA Review
GA Review edit
Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch
Prose
- Lead: "vernacular" isn't the appropriate word here. It suggests the games have had a literal effect on colloquial speech which isn't really true, or at least isn't very representative of the various effects they have had.
- Replace these phrasal verbs if at all possible, as they're not really appropriate for formal prose: turning many people onto; taken up; get hooked on; end up; Same with in the works.
- Pink Floyd is also in active discussions to include their music in either Guitar Hero or Rock Band; If Pink Floyd is being described as a singular unit (i.e. "is" as opposed to "are") the determiner should be "its", I think.
- This bit is messed up: Activision CEO Robert Kotick has stated, in response to the record company's claims, that the impact that the Guitar Hero games have cause them to question...
- Citations 25, 27, 70, 75 and 76 lack access dates.
- Layout: The lead needs to be significantly longer, at least another paragraph, providing at least some detail of the various effects.
Verifiability
- However, Activision, the publisher of the series, did not approve the idea of a film adaptation. is lacking a citation.
I will double check all the sources tomorrow but everything else looks fine at first glance.
Coverage
Good.
Neutrality
Good.
Stability
Stable.
Images
Images are good; mostly free; one non-free image with adequate FUR.
I'm placing the article on hold for now. bridies (talk) 17:08, 17 June 2009 (UTC)
- I've tried to address all the points above - the lead is now an extra para longer, I've fixed the sourcing and text issues, and added a reference for the above point. --MASEM (t) 21:05, 17 June 2009 (UTC)
Verifiability contd.
Some sourcing issues:
- Other games based on Guitar Hero include Battle of the Bands and Ultimate Band. This doesn't seem to have a citation. The next citation, a couple of sentences on, is to a print source so it may come from there but it seems to cover different subject matter.
- The episode of Metalocalypse entitled "Dethvengance" featured a black Guitar Hero controller on the bed of a boy attempting to download music from the band Dethklok illegally. The song playing on his computer is "Thunderhorse," which is playable on Guitar Hero II. This doesn't seem to have a citation.
- In the Metalocalypse episode "Dethkids," a sick child composes a song for Dethklok rhythm guitarist Toki Wartooth using a Guitar Hero controller. This has a citation to TV.com, but the trivia section it's taken from seems to be user-generated content.
- Mariah Carey's music video for her song "Touch My Body" features a compu-nerd strumming on a Guitar Hero controller This doesn't have a citation.
- The music video for San Diego rock band Switchfoot's song "Awakening" featured two men going home and competing separately on Guitar Hero. The video is unique because all of the Guitar Hero footage featured Switchfoot playing, and all the animation was made by using cut-out style animation. It also tied with Farrah's "Fear of Flying" from early 2007 as one of the first music videos to use this type of animation. None of this really seems to be mentioned in the source.
- The name "Guitar Hero" is often juxtapositioned with other instruments or other tools for humorous effects. There are T-shirts available from at least one vendor, parodying the Guitar Hero logo with a number of different instruments, from violin to bagpipes. This doesn't seem to have a citation. It could be covered in the long independent article (the next citation) but as far as I can see it's not.
- One other small thing: a few of the citations have dates linked, while most of the others don't. bridies (talk) 16:43, 18 June 2009 (UTC)