Talk:Cowboy Style/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: Calvin999 (talk · contribs) 18:20, 27 August 2015 (UTC)

Hi. I'm Calvin999 and I am reviewing this nomination.  — Calvin999

• one dead link
• single from Impossible Princess → single the album (repetition of the album title)
• Minogue had written the track → Minogue co-wrote the track
• A music video is a form of promotion, so this should go in the next para.
• You introduced and explain what Intimate and Live is after you've already mentioned and linked it in passing.
• To promote "Cowboy Style", Minogue promoted → Repetition of promote/promoted
• in June–August 1998. → from June to August of 1998.
• Put the years of the subsequent tours in brackets
• albums Confide in Me (2002), Ultimate Kylie (2004), and Confide in Me: The Irresistible Kylie. → Why no year of release for the latter album?
• songs written for → songs composed for (repetition of written)
• with another meaning towards it → with different lyrical context
• but Minogue, Anderson and Seaman completed the writing process of it while she was dating → but it was completed while she was dating
• Minogue commented about the song, stating that → Of the song, Minogue said
• met him in person → met Sednaoui in person
• After the poor chart success with the previous single → Following the weak commercial performance of her previous single
• Minogue confirmed her leave from → Minogue left
• The single cover was → The single's artwork
• Why is Intimate and Live mentioned twice, but one in italics. Was the artwork shot afterwards during the release of it on DVD? If so, then it's currently unclear as to when.
• was mixed by → Link mixed
• is a Celtic pop song → Link Celtic pop
• seconds on the album. → Remove 'on the album'
• for only a sole week → Remove, it's not necessary
• debut single that → Remove 'single'
• lowest charting single from the Impossible Princess album, surpassing → The idea of surpassing a single by performing worse is confusing.
• months after the song, → Remove 'the song'
• charted at reach number → This doesn't make sense
• and was taped → Remove 'was'. Taped is already indicative of the past tense
• Ref 1 has a double " " at the end of "Cowboy Style"". Always use ' not " in the title of formatting refs.
• External links to the music video?

Outcome

On hold  — Calvin999 20:31, 27 August 2015 (UTC)

@Calvin999: Finished at adjustments that are noted above. CaliforniaDreamsFan (talk · contribs} 03:20, 28 August 2015 (UTC)

Great. Passing.  — Calvin999 07:36, 28 August 2015 (UTC)