Talk:Counts of Andechs

Latest comment: 7 years ago by Collision-Shift in topic Untitled

Untitled

edit

Needs revisit and better sourcing I happened to land on this page looking for some clarity or insight to Bethold II von Dießen's wife. This Wiki page sources a run-of-the-mill geneaology site with no sources listed, and it's German Wikipedia counterpart, likewise refers to a different, yet similar unsourced personal genealogy site. I came across it after some critical analysis by the Medieval Lands site, which source Moritz (1833), Vol. II, Zweite Beilage, Deutsche Reimchronik des Klosters Kastel, p. 136, line 293, cited in Wegener (1965/67), p. 151., and indicates that Berthold's wife was possibly Sophie von Schweinfurt, Daughter of Markgraf Otto von Schweinfurt (later Duke Otto Von Schwaben). Personally, I am inclined to take FMG/Medlands analysis over 2 different 'personal' genealogies. If there is a better source, please feel free to disclose and-or share.

[1]

Still not looking to get into an edit war, so I leave the changes to the community. Look up the sources, and make the better judgement.

thanks Collision-Shift (talk) 05:10, 9 May 2017 (UTC)Reply

References