Talk:¿Quién es quién?

Latest comment: 8 years ago by Philip J Fry in topic Episodes

Introduction edit

Well, I want to ask him to @Cyphoidbomb:, because it is better to do this:

Danna Paola, Eugenio Siller, Laura Flores and Carlos Espejel star opposite Kimberly Dos Ramos and Jonathan Islas.

That doesn't make sense. Since I edit on this Wikipedia always have seen in the introduction of articles of telenovelas, always be has described the villains and protagonist in this way:

Danna Paola, Eugenio Siller, Laura Flores and Carlos Espejel star as the protagonists, while Kimberly Dos Ramos and Jonathan Islas star as the main antagonists.

Since they carry the main credits. I understand what you said (WP:PROTAGONIST/ANTAGONIST). But it does not understand because it avoided describing this, this has always been done in all the wikipedias, including in this. Now if this already is not allowed, I would like to know if there is another way of describing the protagonist and villains?. Because on the way in which it is currently a bit confusing, especially the for those who speak Spanish, since this telenovela is made in Spanish, and I think that the logical would be to make the article a little more understandable for those who live in Latin America and those who live in the United States, but who speak Spanish. Is that there is already a Wikipedia in Spanish, but there are users that also are copied from this wiki, to bring the content to other wikis where Spanish is spoken. Well not, that the idea that I have.--Philip J Fry talk 01:16, 30 October 2015 (UTC)Reply

A couple of things: Our audience is not Latin America, our audience for any article is: the world. If you want to read an article about Indian cinema, how are you going to feel when you read something that says, "Lingaa grossed 157.75 crore and was declared super-hit status." Does any of that mean anything to you? What's a crore? What's Lingaa? What's "super-hit status"? We don't write so that people who know the material understand it, we write so that it's familiar to anyone. But I'm off-topic.
"Antagonist". "Protagonist". They're not labels we need to use. You could say: "Yosemite Sam is the antagonist in cartoons that feature Bugs Bunny, the protagonist." Or you could say, "Bugs is often pursued by Yosemite Sam, an anger-prone, trigger-happy man who hates rabbits." Do you need to say "antagonist" there? No. Do you need to say "villain"? No. It's clear that one person is a victim, and the other is an asshole. Cyphoidbomb (talk) 05:33, 30 October 2015 (UTC)Reply

Episodes edit

Prefer that the list of episodes remain in the lead article for the moment. And then when the telenovela is over, maybe you can create a list separately. Also as principal editor of this article, I find it more comfortable to update episodes daily, taking into account that many episodes and need to be updated daily, is uncomfortable create two pages.--Philip J Fry / talk 22:01, 31 January 2016 (UTC)Reply

if I added the list of episodes you need copy the lead section information, so far that list in the entire article right here WP:LISTCRUFT at least for 40-100s episodes right here. Oripaypaykim (talk) 10:10, 1 February 2016 (UTC)Reply
If you're not going to update the list of episodes, I prefer to leave the article as is currently, because I work better this way. And then when done the best telenovela would create a list of episode. I do not need a list of episode for now, since I will not be entering two articles each time to update information that can fit well in the main article.--Philip J Fry / talk 11:04, 1 February 2016 (UTC)Reply