Wikipedia

Murders of Dean and Tina Clouse

Harold Dean Clouse Jr. and Tina Linn Clouse, formerly known as the Harris County Does, were a pair of formerly unidentified murder victims found outside of Houston, Texas in January, 1981.[1] After moving in the summer of 1980 with their infant daughter, Holly Marie, from Volusia County, Florida to Lewisville, Texas,[2] the Clouses stopped contacting their families in October, 1980.[3] Their remains were found in a wooded area north of Houston on January 12, 1981.[1] The bodies were found within feet of each other, both significantly decomposed, with a post-mortem interval of approximately two months.[4] Dean Clouse had been bound and beaten to death, and Tina Clouse was strangled.[5] Holly Marie’s remains were not found with or near her parents' remains. After the two bodies were not identified and the case grew cold, they were buried in anonymous graves,[6] where they remained unidentified for 41 years. In 2011, the Clouses’ bodies were exhumed for genetic testing.[5] In 2021, forensic genealogists positively identified the Harris County Does as Dean and Tina Clouse, however, Holly Marie’s whereabouts remained unaccounted for.[1] In 2022, Holly Marie was located alive in Oklahoma, with no memory of the traumatic events of her infancy.[7]

Dean Clouse
Home photo of Tina, Holly Marie, and Dean Clouse
Born
Harold Dean Clouse Jr.

(1959-06-07)June 7, 1959
DisappearedCirca December 1980
Lewisville, Texas
DiedDecember 1980 (1981-01) (aged 21)
Cause of deathHomicide (blunt trauma)
Body discoveredJanuary 12, 1981
Houston, Texas
Resting placeHarris County Cemetery #2
Other names"Harris County John Doe"
SpouseTina Linn Clouse (married 1979)
ChildrenHolly Marie Clouse (b.1980)
RelativesDonna Casasanta (mother), Chris Casasanta (brother), Debbie Brooks (sister), Cheryl Clouse (sister), Tess Welch (sister)
Tina Clouse
Born
Tina Gail Linn

(1963-09-21)September 21, 1963
DisappearedCirca December 1980
Lewisville, Texas
DiedDecember 1980 (1981-01) (aged 17)
Cause of deathHomicide (strangulation)
Body discoveredJanuary 12, 1981
Houston, Texas
Resting placeHarris County Cemetery #2
Other names"Harris County Jane Doe"
SpouseHarold Dean Clouse Jr. (married 1979)
ChildrenHolly Marie Clouse (b.1980)
RelativesSherry Linn Green (sister), Les Linn (brother)

Background

edit

Harold Dean Clouse Jr. and Tina Gail Linn were both living with their families in New Smyrna Beach, Florida, when they met in 1978.[8] Tina Linn was 15 years old and Dean Clouse Jr. was 19. Dean’s sister was already dating Tina’s brother, who also later married.[2] Dean and Tina had what was described by those around them as a “whirlwind romance”, and married a short time later at the Volusia County Courthouse on June 25, 1979.[2] The couple’s daughter, Holly Marie, was born on January 24, 1980.[2] Both were described as devoted parents by those around them.[9] Before their move to Texas, the young family lived with Tina’s sister, Sherry Linn.[citation needed]

In the summer of 1980, the Clouses moved with baby Holly to the suburb of Lewisville, Texas, in the Dallas metropolitan area.[5][7] In the early 1980s, the Dallas-Fort Worth area was rapidly developing, creating a construction boom. Dean was an adept cabinet maker, and moved his family to Texas in hopes of finding a good job in the trade.[10] Dean found work with D.R. Horton homebuilders, and the young family lived with Dean's cousin to save for their own home.[2] Holly was one year old at the time of the move.[5] Although work at the time was not stable, no one who knew them reported any tensions between the two.[2]

Death and discovery

edit

Dean and Tina fell out of contact with their families around late October 1980, only a few months after their relocation to Texas.[3] It is now believed their murders occurred between October 1980 and January 1981, several weeks before their decaying bodies were found on January 12, 1981.[1] The Clouses were last seen alive in Lewisville, Texas. It is still unknown how they came to be where they were found, in undeveloped and swampy woodlands north of Houston, 250 miles from their last confirmed address.[2] After several months had passed without contact from them, in 1981 Dean’s mother, Donna Casasanta, reported the couple as missing.[11] However, there was little effort put into the investigation by the police who strongly believed that the young family had deliberately cut off contact, citing the mysterious return of their car to Florida by members of an unidentified nomadic religious group.[2] Their families made grassroots efforts to locate the missing pair, but none led to concrete developments.[12] One of such efforts taken by the Linn family was to report the Clouses as missing to the Salvation Army, who sometimes keep track of disappearances, but nothing on the Clouses from the Salvation Army’s database entered federal databases of missing people.[2]

Bodies discovered

edit

The then-unidentified bodies of the Clouses were found on January 12, 1981 in northern Harris County, Texas, in a boggy, wooded area just north of the Houston city limits.[1][2] A civilian’s dog let to wander into the woods returned to its owner with a decomposing human arm.[11] Search parties prompted by the dog’s discovery subsequently found two heavily decomposed bodies near Wallisville Road.[13][12] The bodies were found within a few feet of each other, and assumed to have been killed at approximately the same time, leading investigators to believe the two bodies were a double homicide.[14] Both had been dead for anywhere between a week to two months, heavily decayed, with the male body already having been partially skeletonized.[15][16] However, their faces were still recognizable enough for a reconstruction to be drawn of each.[17] Despite significant decomposition, it was determined that both were victims of homicide. The female had been strangled, and the male had been bound and gagged[18] before being beaten to death.[19] It is believed that the female victim had been attacked first, and the male victim attacked for attempting to defend her.[2] It was unclear if they had been killed where they were found, or if they had been taken there afterwards.[14] Also recovered at the scene was a bloodied towel and a pair of gym shorts.[14]

Investigation into the identities of the Harris County Does

edit

Initial investigation

edit

Further investigation turned up very few leads beyond what was gathered from the scene. Initial age estimates placed them as teenagers or young adults.[citation needed] Initial theories speculated that the female victim was attacked first and that the male victim had been killed while defending her. Harris County forensic artist Mary Mize drew the initial facial reconstructions of both victims,[20] but the reconstructions failed to generate any leads, now known to be because the Clouses had not built roots in Texas yet at the time of their deaths.[12][21] As yet unidentified,[citation needed] the "Does" were buried in the Harris County Cemetery.[6] Even after the victims were properly identified, no arrests have ever been made for their murders.[5]

Cold case investigation

edit

The bodies were exhumed in July 2011 to extract DNA, originally to find out if they were related.[5][22] The funding for exhumation was acquired when Harris County received a grant from the National Institute of Justice to exhume several unidentified murder victims, including the Clouses, to extract their DNA and enter it into databases.[2] Jennifer Love, forensic anthropology director of the identification unit in the Harris County medical examiner’s office, was put in charge of the exhumation.[22] Funding for continued genealogical research into the Harris County Does was then secured from the true crime podcast company Audiochuck.[8][22]

Identification

edit

The case of identifying the Does was given to California-based genetic genealogy organization Identifinders International in late 2020.[1][5] Using Gedmatch as the genetic database they searched, forensic genealogists Misty Gillis and Allison Peacock were tasked with identifying them.[12][5] Gillis focused on tracing the man’s genetics, and Peacock focused on tracing the female.[2] The male’s DNA generated multiple distant matches in Kentucky,[23] which led Gillis to a Kentucky family with the surname Clouse who had relocated to Florida.[2] Gillis continued to follow the Clouse family’s genealogy until she found an extremely close match with the male. Peacock, acting as representative for both her and Gillis, called Debbie Brooks, Dean's sister, and asked if there was a member of her family who had disappeared 40 years or more ago.[12] Brooks then provided Peacock and Gillis with information about Dean, leading to Dean Clouse Jr. being identified within 10 days of Peacock and Gillis beginning his case. Tina Clouse was then identified shortly after, leading to both of the Harris County Does to be identified within several weeks of their cases being reopened.[4]

Dean and Tina Clouse were publicly identified by the Texas Attorney General's cold case unit[13] on 12 January 2021, on the 40th anniversary of the discovery of their remains.[1] Until then, Donna Casasanta had reportedly been hopeful that her son was still alive.[5] Following the identifications, Peacock continued to work on the case as the Clouse family’s public relations and advocate.[11]

Families of both decedents traveled to Houston to see the place where the bodies were found, and their gravesites.[6] According to Les Linn, Tina's brother, both families agreed to have the couple buried together.[6]

Disappearance of Holly Marie Clouse

edit

After Dean and Tina's bodies were identified, the investigation's primary focus turned to finding their missing daughter.[24] No baby’s body was discovered with or near the couple’s remains, and no baby Doe cases that fit Holly Marie’s circumstances had ever surfaced.[4] It is reported that when Peacock delivered news of the findings to the Clouse family, Debbie Brooks asked if the investigators had found the baby, to which Peacock responded, “What baby?”[12]

Several theories about Holly Marie’s whereabouts were put forward, including theories that her small body had been carried away by scavenging animals, or that investigators missed her at the scene.[2] Another increasingly popular theory was that the baby had been kidnapped by the killers, which became the general consensus after Holly Marie was recovered alive.[2] It is now known that Holly Marie was left at a church in Arizona shortly after her parents’ murders, and that she was left by two white-robed and barefoot women claiming to be a part of a nomadic religious group.[9][13]

Allison Peacock and her organization FHD Forensics, along with the Clouse and Linn families continued to search for Holly Marie.[25] Peacock launched the Hope For Holly DNA Project as part of their efforts.[25] Information on Holly’s case was released to the public, including that her last known whereabouts were Lewisville, Texas.[11] An age progression image made by the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children was also made to be distributed to the press,[17] and several family members submitted DNA samples to genealogy websites such as Ancestry.com in hopes of matching with Holly Marie.[6][11] Several women from across the country wrote to Peacock that they might be Holly, and Peacock tested and ruled out several women who fit the circumstances but were hesitant to work with law enforcement.[2]

Recovery of Holly Marie Clouse

edit

Holly Marie was found alive in Oklahoma at 42 years old on 7 June 2022, which was also coincidentally Dean’s birthday.[8] While the search for Holly Marie was ongoing, it was hypothesized that if she were to be alive, she would not be aware of her identity or past, which ended up being correct.[5] While several different agencies were involved in the investigation into Holly Marie's disappearance, confusion occurred over whether her name was spelled as Hollie or Holly. When investigators asked to see her birth certificate, they found that it had been sealed due to an adoption.[26]

While few details of Holly Marie’s life have been released out of respect for her privacy, it has been reported that she has led a satisfactory life, with a 20-year marriage, five children and two young grandchildren.[7] Details of her childhood are also being kept confidential due to the investigation into her parents' deaths being an active case,[27] but it has been stated that her adoptive family was never considered suspect in her case.[1] The church that took Holly in had adopted her to a family, and both the church and the family were unaware of how Holly had come to be in the possession of the church and nomadic group.[9][25] Holly Marie met with her biological family over Zoom the same day she was found,[28] and NCMEC helped to fund a visit to Florida in November, 2022 so she could meet them in person.[25] In a 2023 interview with ABC, it was revealed that Holly Marie's adoptive father, Philip McGoldrick, was the pastor at the church where Holly Marie was left as a baby.[29] Goldrick has said that the two women who left Holly Marie also gave him Holly Marie's birth certificate, as well as a note reportedly written by Dean Clouse that waived parental rights to Holly Marie.[29]

Family advocacy efforts

edit

After her safe recovery, the Hope for Holly Project was renamed the Dean and Tina Linn Clouse Memorial Fund, shifting the focus to identifying other unidentified decedents.[8] A few months later, in October, 2022 growth of the memorial fund led to the establishment of a 501c3 charitable organization, Genealogy For Justice™ with members of the Clouse and Linn family, as well as genealogist Peacock acting as advisors. In the memorial fund's first sponsored case, Wilkes County, North Carolina native Virginia Higgins Ray was identified as a 1982 Columbia, South Carolina Jane Doe on Mother's Day, 2023.

Ongoing investigation

edit

The investigation into the Clouse murders is still considered an active criminal case,[26] according to Harris County Police Deputy Thomas Gilliland.[2] Due to this news about the case is partially restricted.[9] The focus of the investigation has since turned to finding the parents' killers, while the publicity surrounding Holly’s return generated an increase in new leads to the Texas Attorney General’s cold case unit.[8]

Religious group

edit

In the 1970s, “Jesus freak” movements were common, and the structure of these movements could be favorable conditions for the formation of cults. However, they were decreasing in relevance by the 1980s.[2] According to his family, Dean had a history of interacting with such movements during his teenage years, but drifted away from them after meeting Tina Linn.[2]

During December 1980, and what is now known to be close to the time of the murders, a woman who introduced herself as “Sister Susan” reached out to the family of the couple in Florida, claiming to be interested in returning the couple’s car.[1] By that time, Dean and Tina had already been out of contact for more than several weeks.[2] The family agreed to meet Sister Susan and several other members of her religious group at Daytona Racetrack in Florida.[1] Multiple elements about the meeting did not make sense to the attending family members. The religious group arranged for the meeting to be at night.[30] During the meeting, though multiple members of the group were present, only Sister Susan spoke.[2] The attending family members were told that Dean and Tina had joined their religious group and no longer wished to have worldly contact with their families.[1] The group then asked Donna Casasanta to donate $1,000 to them.[2] Police were notified of the meeting in advance, but no formal police report for the incident has been uncovered.[3]

When Donna Casasanta later tried to report Dean as missing to the authorities, her claim was quickly dismissed as him having joined the religious group as Sister Susan had said, with the police citing the return of the car as proof that Dean's disappearance was voluntary.[11][2] The couple's families said that they never found it believable that the couple would join a cult, and it is now believed that the car was intentionally returned to lessen the chances of a formal investigation.[9][2]

It is believed that the religious group that returned the car is also the same group that left Holly at the church in Arizona.[25] This group was observed living nomadically around the Southwest United States.[31] Their beliefs involved male and female separation, as well as vegetarianism and not using leather goods.[25][32] It also claimed to have left another baby before, at a laundromat.[25][33]

In 2023, it was revealed that the religious group in question was the Christ Family, a nomadic group founded by Charles Franklin "Lightning Amen" McHugh.[29]

Holly's Belief

edit

In an November 2023 interview with ABC on 20/20, Holly Clouse revealed that she believes the religious cult her parents were involved with may have murdered them because they wanted to leave the group. She explained that after her parents' deaths, members of the cult left her at a church in Yuma, Arizona, where she was later adopted by the pastor of the church. Holly has suggested that her parents’ desire to distance themselves from the cult could have led to their brutal deaths. [15]

See also

edit

References

edit
  1. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k "Woman known as 'Baby Holly' found alive 40 years after her parents were killed in Houston". ABC13 Houston. 2022-06-09. Archived from the original on 2022-07-09. Retrieved 2022-07-31.
  2. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y Olsen, Lise (2022-03-02). "Who Killed Texas Couple Dean and Tina Clouse—and Where Is Their Baby?". The Texas Observer. Archived from the original on 2022-07-17. Retrieved 2022-07-31.
  3. ^ a b c "'Baby Holly,' missing child of Florida couple murdered in 1981, found alive at age 42". NBC News. 9 June 2022. Archived from the original on 2022-10-16. Retrieved 2022-10-16.
  4. ^ a b c International, Identifinders. "1981 Murdered Harris County John & Jane Doe Identified After 40 Years Leads to Discovery Their Baby, Now Age 41, is Missing". www.prnewswire.com (Press release). Archived from the original on 2022-10-19. Retrieved 2022-10-19.
  5. ^ a b c d e f g h i j "Couple murdered in Houston in 1981 identified; daughter, now 41, still missing". NBC News. 14 January 2022. Archived from the original on 2022-07-01. Retrieved 2022-07-31.
  6. ^ a b c d e "Families of murdered couple identified after four decades travel to Houston to visit site where remains found". khou.com. March 9, 2022. Archived from the original on 2022-10-06. Retrieved 2022-10-06.
  7. ^ a b c "Search in Texas murder case finds missing child, now age 42". Dallas News. 2022-06-10. Archived from the original on 2022-10-16. Retrieved 2022-10-16.
  8. ^ a b c d e Detectives®, FHD Forensics / Family History. "Families Plea for Help Solving Cold Cases: Baby Holly's Family Honoring Dean and Tina Clouse by Fundraising for Doe Identifications and Helping Other Victims". www.prnewswire.com (Press release). Archived from the original on 2022-08-20. Retrieved 2022-07-31.
  9. ^ a b c d e "Biological family of 'Baby Holly' speaks about finding her four decades later". ABC13 Houston. 2022-06-11. Archived from the original on 2022-08-17. Retrieved 2022-07-31.
  10. ^ "How Holly Marie Clouse Was Found 40 Years After Vanishing". Peoplemag. Archived from the original on 2022-10-16. Retrieved 2022-10-16.
  11. ^ a b c d e f Miranda, Gabriela. "Remains of Houston couple found in 1981 finally identified. But their child, now 41, is still missing". USA TODAY. Archived from the original on 2022-10-06. Retrieved 2022-08-11.
  12. ^ a b c d e f "40-year cold case solved ... partially. Where is 1-year-old Hollie Marie Clouse?". khou.com. January 12, 2022. Archived from the original on 2022-08-10. Retrieved 2022-08-11.
  13. ^ a b c "Search in Texas murder case finds missing child, now age 42". My Suncoast. Associated Press. 10 June 2022. Archived from the original on 2022-10-16. Retrieved 2022-10-16.
  14. ^ a b c Olsen, Lise (2011-11-28). "Investigators hope DNA provides answers in 30-year-old murder". Chron. Archived from the original on 2022-10-19. Retrieved 2022-10-19.
  15. ^ a b "476UFTX". www.doenetwork.org. Archived from the original on 2022-10-18. Retrieved 2022-10-18.
  16. ^ "753UMTX". www.doenetwork.org. Archived from the original on 2022-10-18. Retrieved 2022-10-18.
  17. ^ a b "Holly Clouse: Missing Texas infant found alive more than 40 years after parents' murders". FOX13 News Memphis. 2022-06-09. Archived from the original on 2022-10-19. Retrieved 2022-10-19.
  18. ^ Worley, Debra (9 June 2022). "Missing baby found alive more than 40 years after parents found killed in woods". WDTV. Archived from the original on 2022-10-16. Retrieved 2022-10-16.
  19. ^ "Her parents were murdered in the '80s. She vanished. 42 years later, 'Baby Holly' has been found". Deseret News. 2022-06-14. Archived from the original on 2022-10-16. Retrieved 2022-10-16.
  20. ^ "Who is Hollie Marie? Genealogists search for woman whose parents were killed in 1980". KHOU 11. January 19, 2022. Archived from the original on 2022-10-16. Retrieved 2022-10-16.
  21. ^ "40-year cold case solved ... partially. Where is 1-year-old Hollie Marie Clouse?". KHOU 11. January 12, 2022. Archived from the original on 2022-10-09. Retrieved 2022-10-16.
  22. ^ a b c "1981 Murdered Couple Identified, But Questions Remain about Missing Baby". www.forensicmag.com. January 17, 2022. Archived from the original on 2022-10-09. Retrieved 2022-10-06.
  23. ^ Barned-Smith, St John (2022-01-11). "After 40 years, a murdered Houston couple has finally been identified. Where is their missing baby?". Houston Chronicle. Archived from the original on 2022-10-16. Retrieved 2022-10-16.
  24. ^ KWTX Staff (13 January 2022). "Texas couple murdered in 1981 identified; baby, now 41, is still missing". KWTX. Archived from the original on 2022-10-16. Retrieved 2022-10-16.
  25. ^ a b c d e f g "Religious group linked to disappearance of 'Baby Holly Marie' 40 years ago, Texas AG's Office says". khou.com. June 9, 2022. Archived from the original on 2022-10-06. Retrieved 2022-10-06.
  26. ^ a b Barned-Smith, St John (16 June 2022). "How did investigators find 'Baby Holly'? It all came down to a spelling question". Houston Chronicle. Archived from the original on 16 June 2022.
  27. ^ Olsen, Lise (2022-06-09). "An Astonishing ID: Baby of Couple Murdered in 1981 Finally Found". The Texas Observer. Archived from the original on 2022-10-19. Retrieved 2022-10-19.
  28. ^ Barned-Smith, St John (2022-06-09). "42 years later, a murdered Texas couple's missing baby has finally been found". Houston Chronicle. Archived from the original on 2022-10-16. Retrieved 2022-10-16.
  29. ^ a b c "'Baby Holly' speaks out for the 1st time after being missing for over 40 years". ABC News. Retrieved 2024-01-28.
  30. ^ Mark, Julian (10 June 2022). "A baby vanished after her parents' murder in the '80s. She's been found". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on 16 August 2022.
  31. ^ "Religious group linked to disappearance of 'Baby Holly Marie' 40 years ago, Texas AG's Office says". KHOU 11. June 9, 2022. Archived from the original on 2022-10-09. Retrieved 2022-10-16.
  32. ^ Torchinsky, Rina (2022-06-10). "A baby who went missing after her parents' death over 40 years ago is found alive". NPR. Archived from the original on 2022-10-16. Retrieved 2022-10-16.
  33. ^ "'Baby Holly' speaks out for the 1st time after being missing for over 40 years". ABC news. Archived from the original on 2023-12-29. Retrieved 2023-12-30.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Murders_of_Dean_and_Tina_Clouse&oldid=1250168191"