Draft:Soloveva Ekaterina

Soloveva Ekaterina
סולוביובה יקטרינה Соловьева Екатерина
4Fi1b4 zO4k
Born (1989-05-17) 17 May 1989 (age 35)
Russian Federation
Alma materRussian Academy of Public Administration under the President of the Russian Federation
Occupation(s)goalkeeper,scientist,public and political figure
EmployerIsrael football Assotiation Israel

Ekaterina Solovyova is a Russian football player[1], scientist, public and political figure, lawyer-auto expert and humanright [2] [3].

According to some sources – Ekaterina, according to others - Katerina[4]. Born in Russia [5])). According to one source – May 17, 1989 [6], according to others – 1987, 1990[7].

Sports career

edit

From 2015 to 2023, she played in the Russian Football Championship – I League among women's teams for FC Academy of Football (Tambov). In 2024, the Russian Football Union approved Solovyova's transfer to the European championship – the Israeli championship. [8]. He plays for the football club Hapoel N.I.R. Ramat Hasharon (Ramat Hasharon, disktrikt Tel Aviv), Ligat AL (Premier League of the Israeli Championship among girls) at the goalkeeper position[9], in which she won the silver medal of the Israel Cup, thus becoming the first among Russian goalkeepers who won medals at the championships of two countries in less than a year[10]. An important role in this was played by the uncle[11]. She dedicated the victory in 2023 to her uncle[12] . The international name of the player is Soloveva Ekaterina Name in the Israeli championship סולוביובה יקאטרינה


Sports awards

edit

2019 – silver medalist of the Russian Football Championship "I League" [13].

2021 – bronze medalist of the international AFL Sochi Club championship in 7X7 mini-football as part of the Ryazan region [14].

2022 - silver medalist of the Russian Football Championship "First League". Received the title of "Best Goalkeeper" of the 2022 season[15]

Champion of the Russian First League 2023 . Candidate for the Master of Sports in football[16].

In February 2024, the Ministry of Sports officially announced that The Russian Football Union has approved the international transfer transfer of Ekaterina Solovyova to the Israeli Football Championship. It was the first direct international transfer of a player abroad in the history of the region [17]. Also, there have been no such transfers in the entire history of the First League of the Russian Championship.

2024 – won the silver medals of the Israel Cup [18]. He has sports titles – the category in the sports discipline "Rifle shooting"[19]. She became the champion of the interregional open-track karting tournament among girls [20].

Scientific activities and achievements

edit

She has a number of awards and victories at international scientific forums, All-Russian competitions, and law Olympiads:

winner of the All-Russian competition "Legal Russia" in the nomination "Administrative law" [21]. "In the main round of the competition, she successfully coped with tasks on taxation of special economic zones and bringing to administrative responsibility the "wronged" media. The twelfth "Legal Russia" was attended by a record number of participants – over 11 thousand[22].

The winner of the international forum of young scientists, postgraduates and students "Lomonosov" Moscow State University Moscow[23]

winner of the AVTOVAZ Professional Skills competition, Tolyatti[24];

winner of the competition of youth legislative initiatives, Orenburg, work in the field of developing a methodology for assessing the information openness of Internet resources of state and regional authorities[25].

As a student, she practiced in the executive and legislative authorities, taking part in projects of administrative reform, the introduction of information technologies into the activities of government agencies, projects to assess the information openness of government authorities, and more[26].


He has a number of studies and publications on the following topics: ensuring the security of the state and the constitutional system, the work of state security agencies [27];

information technologies in public administration, public information databases, information protection[28];

media technologies of communication between the state and society, ensuring the information openness of authorities, the problems of distinguishing information related to restricted access information, state secrets, official secrets[29]; administrative law, economic security[30][31], road safety [32], transport safety, autosphere, auto insurance[33] ; urbanism, urban planning, organization of parking space[34]; she has been researching youth organizations and their role in the "color revolutions" [35].

"'Education'"

She graduated from the Russian Academy of National Economy and Public Administration under the President of the Russian Federation with a degree in Finance and Credit, as well as Tambov State University named after G.R. Derzhavin, with a degree in Jurisprudence.

She has additional education in the field of ensuring interdepartmental electronic interaction of authorities; organization of the electoral process; political analysis and forecasting; as well as in the course "law enforcement agencies of foreign countries". She studied geopolitics (Balkanistics, the Middle East, etc. geopolitical conflicts). Speaks English, Serbian, Hebrew[36].


Family and early years

edit

In an interview with journalists, Solovyova said that her parents were military. She spent her childhood abroad in the Middle East and Asia. [37].

Expert, analytical and legal activities

edit

Ekaterina Solovyova is an analyst of the federal project "NF.Analytics" [38]. She is also a humanright lawyer [39][40] [41] [42] [43] [44][45]. [46].

Human rights and socio-political activities

edit

Monitoring of the automated system of photo and video recording of traffic violations and government information processing services

edit

Solovyova carries out public control of the automated system of photo-video recording of traffic violations and traffic flow on the roads [47][48]. She conducted a number of studies on the operation of the automated photo-video recording system on the country's roads, the operation of information databases. After that, the supervisory authorities revealed a large number of violations, which led to its large-scale reform[49].

In 2014, resonant stories related to the operation of photo-video cameras occurred simultaneously in two cities - Tambov and Krasnodar[50]. In Krasnodar, drivers complained about fines from cameras for violations that they did not commit[51]. In Tambov, drivers complained about fines for violations that, in their opinion, could not be recorded by cameras[52][53]. The human rights defenders of Moscow and St. Petersburg joined the topic - "Blue Buckets" (Peter Shkumatov) [54]. The Ministry of Internal Affairs published an appeal to an indefinite circle of people, in which it refuted the violation of the law and pointed out that some Internet users artificially escalate the situation in order to create a negative image of the work of the State Traffic Inspectorate[55] [56] Legal literacy of motorists. Explanations of the Ministry of Internal Affairs. In 2014, Solovyova initiated appeals from drivers to the State Duma of the Russian Federation with a request to verify the security of communication channels for transmitting data from cameras to public systems and database security. Deputy of the State Duma of Russia V.Lysakov sent complaints to the Prosecutor General's Office of Russia[57]. According to the results of the audit, violations and insecurity of data transmission channels to state information systems were revealed. Criminal proceedings have been initiated [58][59][60][61]. The Main Directorate of the State Traffic Inspectorate of Russia has sent instructions to the regions to stop the practice of sending fines for a belt, light, phone, which, in fact, are not recorded by cameras, as originally claimed [62] [63] [64]. After the situation in Tambov and Krasnodar, a large-scale reform of the automated fixation system followed, which continues to this day[65][66][67][68] Внесены поправки в законодательство, созданы новые информационные системы («Паутина»)[69].

Electronic government system for appealing fines

edit
 
OP RF Solovyeva speaker

Together with other human rights activists and deputies of the State Duma of the Russian Federation, Solovyova sent a request to the Prosecutor General's Office of Russia to verify the legality of the requirements for signing driver complaints with a digital signature[70]. "Such a simple procedure as the availability of a website for filing complaints demonstrates the degree of openness of both the authority and the communication channel between the state and society, demanding money from people for this, of course, is unacceptable." The Prosecutor General's Office of Russia issued an order to the Ministry of Internal Affairs to eliminate gaps related to the procedure for using a digital signature for citizens[71]. In an interview with NTV, she stated that it is necessary to consider the option of giving Interior Ministry employees the authority to cancel erroneous fines from cameras on their own, so as not to burden the prosecutor's office, the state system and citizens if they received erroneous fines from cameras[72].


In 2017, the Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation assigns Solovyova the status of an independent expert authorized to conduct an anti-corruption examination of regulatory legal acts. In 2019, she was awarded a diploma of the regional administration for winning the independent competition экспертов[73]. Solovyova organizes and participates in monitoring the legality of places where traffic cameras, signs and разметки[74].

At the initiative of Solovyova, a working group has been established in Tambov, which monitors the legality of the operation of the photo and video fixation system in Tambov[75]. At the end of 2019, a number of media outlets, with reference to Solovyova's post on social networks, published information that the Main Directorate of the State Traffic Inspectorate of Russia sent a letter to all regions explaining the cases "in which auto-fixing cameras need to be turned off" [76].At the same time, the Russian Interior Ministry itself, as well as Solovyov, did not publish the document itself. Solovyova referred to the absence of the need to publish the letter, since its content and number are reflected in the post. The Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation officially confirmed the existence of the letter and its sending to all subjects. [77].

The Moscow Assistant program, tablets and gadgets

edit

By 2019, tablets and other gadgets are gaining popularity with the authorities as a tool for automated fixation of parking violations. Solovyova considers this practice illegal, and takes the position that the use of tablets, gadgets and the Moscow Assistant software as a tool for automated recording of traffic violations is unacceptable and should be legally abolished. In an interview with the capital's edition, Solovyova explained her position as follows: "Historically, when auto-fixation was introduced, it was done to exclude the human factor so that it was impossible to negotiate with the inspector on the spot… Because automation separates all cars from the flow, fixing all violators impartially, and a person with a tablet or phone already acts selectively. I didn't take a picture of my friend, but I took a picture of someone else." The majority of human rights defenders adhere to the same position. This position is reflected in the decision of the courts. This practice was banned by the Supreme Court of Russia in 2019[78][79][80].


In 2023, Solovyova opposed this bill on the legalization of software and gadgets as tools for automatically fixing violations with cameras. "When using a stationary or mobile camera, the computer itself detects violators in the flow of the car, and the person directs the smartphone wherever he wants." As a result, the Russian State Duma rejected the bill[81].

Automatic detection of violations of the "average speed"

edit

Solovyova opposes the automatic recording of violations of the "average speed" by cameras. He believes that "there is no problem of punishing the innocent, there is a problem of not punishing the guilty." The media claims that "The driver enters the area where the speed limit is 90 km/h, Driving at 95 km / h. Then he stops for some business. And then it accelerates to the next camera and goes 130 km/h in places. Then it slows down. And the average speed will be 100 or 110 km/h. And he won't get a fine. But isn't there a danger on the road at those moments? Such fixation does not protect against riders in any way. Yes, there are exits and alternative routes at such sites, but the system does not punish those responsible. There are loopholes"''[82] [83]. [84].

Return of the powers of the Ministry of Internal Affairs

edit

In 2023, there are a number of high-profile accidents at the sites of road works[85]. Solovyova officially made a statement that it is necessary to raise the issue of amending legislation and returning the powers of the Ministry of Internal Affairs to control the maintenance of roads. Because, as amended earlier, the Ministry of Internal Affairs has actually lost this function[86]. In an interview with the federal edition, Solovyova said that because of this, not only the accident rate will increase, but also public figures will not be able to control the progress of national projects "Safe and high-quality roads" [87][88]. "Limiting the powers of the traffic police was a hasty and unweighted decision. Road safety and road quality are a strategic area of public administration. In fact, in less than a year, all this has led to the loss of operational control of the state over the strategic sphere. The current legal framework for attracting road organizations under Article 12.24 of the Administrative Code of the Russian Federation does not meet the principles of administrative legislation and the realities of life. It is necessary to immediately amend the legislation and return control to the Ministry of Internal Affairs" Ekaterina Solovyova[89]. The initiative was supported by automotive human rights activists[90] [91] At the end of 2023, changes were made to the legislation, the powers of the traffic police were returned[92].

Participation in national projects

edit

Road safety

edit
 
Road Safety Meeting

Solovyova organizes public monitoring of the legality of the installation of road signs, "camera traps" [93][94]. It was possible to achieve the arrangement of pedestrian crossings in the most popular places, marking after several ДТП[95] [96]. Being a motorcyclist, Solovyova, together with government agencies, conducts measures to prevent accidents involving motor vehicles and motor vehicles'"Despite the fact that legally it is always, as a rule, the fault of cars, in fact, the fault, I believe, of both the motorcycle and the car. Because in order to ride safely, a motorcyclist must get into the head of a motorist. He must think like a motorist. Accordingly, you drive through the intersection, slow down, maneuver, look, the car understands you, sees what you want to do, and so on, be sure to turn on the turn signals"[97].

Safe high-quality roads, road quality control

edit

Since 2018, from the very start of the national project "Safe high-quality Roads", Ekaterina Solovyova has been included in the design committee of the national office project. Together with the ONF, they actively exercise its public control[98]. В 2023 году Тамбовская область получила награду, как регион, успешно реализующий проект[99].

Parking

edit

Соловьева выступила против того, чтобы наказывать водителей за парковку под углом к дороге и на тротуаре с использованием планшета в качестве автоматизированной фиксации также и в Тамбове. Призвала построить дополнительные парковочные места [100]. Фиксация была прекращена, спустя парковочные места построены[101][102]. Летом 2023 Соловьева, Народный фронт и контрольно-надзорные органы провели мониторинг качественной организации движения на парковках у торговых центров и больниц. После чего, они привели их в порядок[103]. Большинство из которых, удалось облагородить в очень короткие сроки[104].

Средства индивидуальной мобильности

edit

Соловьёва предложила одним из путей решения для администрирования нарушений водителями средств индивидуальной мобильности передачу таких полномочий муниципальным административным органам[105] . Считает, что использование средств индивидуальной мобильности должно быть максимально урегулировано и безопасно[106].

compulsory driver insurance

edit

Занималась научными исследованиями законодательства об обязательном автостраховании[107]. Принимала участие в реформировании ОСАГО. Отстаивала права водителей, пострадавших от некачественного ремонта в суде, добилась привлечения Страховщика к ответственности[108][109]. Поддержав законопроект Ярослава Нилова, выступила с инициативой ввести аналог обязательного страхования для курьеров доставки [110].

edit

Solovyova began practicing law in courts and traffic police in automotive cases while still a student. In 2013, the Supreme Court of Russia, following Solovyova's complaint, canceled a traffic police fine issued using automatic photo and video recording tools due to the lack of a digital signature. This was the first precedent in the Supreme Court of Russia [111]. The activity has developed into public control over the legality of the work of the state traffic inspectorate and the police. In her early years, Solovyova was actively involved in road quality control. So, in 2015, a massive accident occurred on one of the most "leaky" roads in Tambov due to pits. For several hours, accidents were registered and the identified pits were circled with paint. Information spread on social networks and local journalists dubbed the mass accident "pits on the road circled in red." "We help road workers to determine the priority in road repairs," the Tambov activists of the People's Control of ROSYAMA (The Russian pit) explained their actions[112]. The action was successfully adopted by human rights defenders from other regions[113]. In 2013, lawyers Solovyov, Gorovenko and Filippov appealed to the Supreme Court of Russia against paragraphs of the first administrative regulations of the traffic police[114]. Despite the fact that the complaint was not satisfied, after some time the regulations became invalid, another one was adopted instead[115].

Death of Deputy head of the regional government, Vice Governor Gleb Chulkov

edit

In October 2019, the vice-governor of the Tambov region, G.I. Chulkov, who was considered a political centenarian and had been in office for more than 10 years, was detained and placed under house arrest лет[116]. On November 9, 2019, information appears in Tambov telegram channels and social networks that Chulkov is found with open veins in an infectious diseases hospital, where he was taken by ambulance the day before with acute poisoning. The investigation has tried several times to place Chulkov in jail, to no avail. The court refuses. The investigation insists on his transfer from the house to the 5th floor of the apartment to his mother.

On December 8, 2019, Chulkov dies after falling from the 5th floor of the house, apartment, where he was under arrest. In his suicide note, Chulkov addresses his children, wife, mother, sister and Ekaterina [117]. In official reports, the information appears as "found dead" and "fell out of the window" [118] . The funeral was held according to a state ceremony. Thousands of people came to say goodbye to Chulkov [119]. On December 9, 2019, Solovyova stated in an interview with the media that their family, including herself, were under strong pressure by the security forces, although they are not related to the criminal case, that she "fears for her health and life"[120][121].

Within a day after Chulkov's death, the State Duma of the Russian Federation, the Investigative Committee of Russia, took control of the case[122].

The Investigative Committee of Russia has opened a criminal case under the article "Incitement to suicide" [123] . Within 1.5 years after the death of Chulkov, the governor of the Tambov region A.Nikityn prematurely resigns. Nikitin's deputy Oleg Ivanov prematurely resigns [124].

Relationship with city authorities

edit

In 2018, Solovyova was included in the composition, among other things, of the city commission for road safety and the street and road network under the administration of Tambov. [125]. She opposed fining drivers for parking in the city center in front of one of the shopping malls. The Mayor's office officially issued a refusal to the media[126].The traffic police made an official explanation a short time later that parking at the RIO shopping center is allowed and drivers can park safely from now on without fear of fines[127]. Maxim Kosenkov became the mayor of Tambov in 2020. When forming a new road commission, he included Solovyova in the new composition [128].

Humor

edit

If in Yekaterinburg, to combat road pits, local activists painted portraits of officials on them[129], then in Tambov Solovyova shot a video in which pits and hatches are measured with a soccer ball. Later, this format with Solovyova's participation was repeated by the state media in reports on the quality of roads[130]. Local authorities quickly fill up the holes after such reports [131] [132]. The video of the Popular Front with road workers who beat off the marking with axes, with whom Solovyova talked at night, gained a large number of views on various resources and telegram channels during road monitoring [133][134].


Official biography

edit

Apparently, since school (2001), he has been engaged in the diagnosis of electronic car systems in the structures of AvtoVAZ.

At the age of 17 (2007), he began to actively engage in political technologies, and elections to Our Elections (a special wing of the NASHI movement created for elections. It is considered to be the project of the then deputy head of the Presidential Administration of Russia V. Surkov)[135][136].

In 2009, Solovyova joined the Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration. From where, he almost immediately enters the service of the regional government, in the reception of the head.

The government of the region runs from 2009 to 2019 (In Management on public relations; The Ministry of Health of the region (licensing control, public procurement, combating illegal trafficking of medical equipment); The Department for Interaction with Local Governments (legal support of activities; ensuring the implementation of IT projects in the field of public administration “Electronic government”, digitalization of state and municipal services, ensuring the functioning of the electronic interdepartmental interaction system); the Ministry of Property Relations of the Tambov region.).

From 2018 to 2019, he has been working in private structures. 2019-2021 - Setenergo LLC (nuclear power engineering) From 2011 to the present, he has been an auto expert, a lawyer in cases of administrative offenses, and a human rights defender. From 2008 to the present – professional athlete[137].

  1. ^ The head of the region met with the leading athletes of the region
  2. ^ /?ysclid=lzl8mimtyf841480436 Magazine "Behind the wheel"
  3. ^ /?ysclid=lzl8kaboi8301959655 People's Front Analytics
  4. ^ Fed press. What changes are waiting for motorists from May 1: list
  5. ^ /?ysclid=lzo8iw9v6r284080290 Regional government. Awarding of the winners
  6. ^ ?ysclid=lyoqp10io6762204946 Russian Football Union, player card
  7. ^ Transfer value of the player
  8. ^ Tambov News. Tambov football player was invited to the Israeli championship
  9. ^ Israel Football Association
  10. ^ Newspaper "Pritambovye". There are only girls on the field
  11. ^ /?ysclid=lzn1r92x9y55750332 Radio of Russia Tambov. Interview
  12. ^ . Tambov News. Difficulties encountered on the way to the championship
  13. ^ Top68. Tambov football players took the 1st League silver for the first time
  14. ^ / Ryazan Press. The women's football team took bronze at the international tournament
  15. ^ Online lambda. The Football Academy won the silver medals of the I division
  16. ^ Online Tumbos. The goalkeeper of the Women's Football Academy was invited to Israel's Hapoel
  17. ^ TVT Tambov. A football player from Tambov joined an Israeli club
  18. ^ /?national_cup_id=617&season_id=24 Israel cup 2023-2024
  19. ^ People's Front Analytics
  20. ^ / The annual Green Dot Rolling Karting Tournament: how it was
  21. ^ / "Legal Russia". Awarding the winners
  22. ^ /?ysclid=lyyrw9gwe6431648352 Radio "Vesti Tambov"
  23. ^ Radio Tambov. It's about time. Interview
  24. ^ /?ysclid=lzl8kaboi8301959655 Popular Front Analytics
  25. ^ /?ysclid=lyrly1o0mn167817797 Awarding of the winners of the regional stage of the contest "my country is my Russia"
  26. ^ /?ysclid=lzl8kaboi8301959655 People's Front Analytics
  27. ^ [Stages of transformation of law enforcement agencies, special services in the context of political transformations. E.A.Solovyova Materials of reports of the XV International Conference of students, postgraduates and young Scientists "Lomonosov" / Ed.A. Aleshkovsky, P.N. Kostylev. [Electronic resource] — Moscow: Publishing House of Moscow State University; SP MYSL, 2008. — 1 electron. optical disc (CD-ROM); 12 cm. - Systems. requirements: PC with 486+ processor; Windows 95; CD-ROM drive; Adobe Acrobat Reader]
  28. ^ how the Web hijacker search system is being tested
  29. ^ [Materials of the reports of the XVI International Conference of Students, Postgraduates and Young Scientists "Lomonosov" / Ed. I.A. Aleshkovsky, P.N. Kostylev, A.I. Andreev. [Electronic resource] — Moscow: Publishing House of Moscow State University, 2009. — 1 electron. optical disc (CD-ROM); 12 cm. - Systems. Requirements: PC with 486+ processor; Windows 95; CD-ROM drive; Adobe Acrobat Reader Legal issues, trends and dynamics of interaction between the state and society in the field of ensuring the quality of information openness of authorities. Regional aspect
  30. ^ [Economic terrorism. Tools and methods of property redistribution. World experience and Russian practice. E.A.Solovyova //Collection of scientific papers. "Actual problems of legal science". Issue 2. Tambov, 2006]
  31. ^ [https://rusneb.ru/catalog/000200_000018_RU_NLR_bibl_1341485 /?ysclid=lvww0xopk0260137887 Seizure of property as a socio-legal phenomenon: specifics and trends. E.A.Solovyova. Legal regulation of economic activity collection of scientific papers (based on the materials of the All-Russian Scientific and practical Conference, Saratov, April 17, 2008) edited by S. N. Tumanov and E. V. Semenova]
  32. ^ [Problems of implementation of new amendments to the traffic rules of the Russian Federation and insurance legislation - Road safety. Scientific Journal of the Scientific Center for Road Safety of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation 2023 No.2 (29) (page 17) (10) ISSN 2782-2850]
  33. ^ [Legal issues of restoration of violated rights in the context of the implementation of OSAGO Materials of the International Youth Scientific Forum "LOMONOSOV-2010" / Ed. I.A. Aleshkovsky, P.N. Kostylev, A.I. Andreev, A.V. Andriyanov. [Electronic resource] — Moscow: MAKS Press, 2010. — 1 electron. optical disc (CD-ROM); 12 cm. - Systems. Requirements: PC with 486+ processor; Windows 95; CD-ROM drive; Adobe Acrobat Reader. ISBN 978-5-317-03197-8
  34. ^ [Materials of the International Youth Scientific Forum "LOMONOSOV-2017" / Ed. I.A. Aleshkovsky, A.V. Andriyanov, E.A. Antipov. [Electronic resource] — Moscow: MAKS Press, 2017. — 1 electron. optical disc (DVD-ROM); 12 cm. - Systems. Requirements: PC with 486+ processor; Windows 95; DVD-ROM drive; Adobe Acrobat Reader. — 1186 MB. — 9000 copies. ISBN 978-5-317-05504-2]
  35. ^ [Youth public organizations and globalization\\E.A.Solovyova, I.N.Borzykh.Youth and globalization. A collection of materials from the youth scientific forum. ISBN 5-89773-052-0, ISBN 978-5-89773-052-0(publication on the World Bank grant budget) ]
  36. ^ /?ysclid=lzl8kaboi8301959655 People's Front Analytics
  37. ^ The Middle Ages. The Football Academy managed to become a silver medalist
  38. ^ /?ysclid=lzl8kaboi8301959655 People's Front Analytics.
  39. ^ RBC. Turns. the bill on the introduction of penalties for dangerous driving
  40. ^ ?query=%D1%81%D0%BE%D0%BB%D0%BE%D0%B2%D1%8C%D0%B5%D0%B2%D0%B0 . Kommersant.The Administrative Code is being amended, which will prohibit punishing twice for one offense
  41. ^ [https://pravo.ru/auto/news/247199/ <url> The State Duma approved the law on the procedure for using foreign driver's licenses]
  42. ^ / Za Rulem magazine. The rights will be valid for a year
  43. ^ News. Unequal tank
  44. ^ AutoRambler. Ice fell from the roof and damaged the car – what should I do?
  45. ^ / New Century Tambov.New rules for motorists
  46. ^ Desicion Hight Court
  47. ^ The Prosecutor General's Office has its eye on the cameras. The supervisory authority promised to check road complexes in the regions
  48. ^ [The Prosecutor General's Office of the Russian Federation should put into practice annual inspections of photo and video fixation systems on roads
  49. ^ /?ysclid=lzl8kaboi8301959655 People's Front Analytics
  50. ^ /?ysclid=lzle0akgie345751737 Krasnodar traffic cops: it is impossible to falsify fines!
  51. ^ The drivers filed collective complaints to the prosecutor's office about unjustified fines
  52. ^ /?ysclid=lyzzcfue2p198995398 Tambov traffic police, sleight of hand and no мошенничества
  53. ^ Tambov traffic police, sleight of hand and no fraud
  54. ^ ?ysclid=lyzzco70jt884576987 Tambov traffic police, sleight of hand and no fraud
  55. ^ / Explanations from the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Tambov region, screenshot
  56. ^ Clarifications from the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Tambov region
  57. ^ Automatic fixation in manual mode
  58. ^ Krasnodar traffic police caught falsifying data
  59. ^ ?ysclid=lyrebjdfax824405552 The Prosecutor General's Office of the Russian Federation revealed large-scale falsifications of protocols from traffic cameras in the Krasnodar Territory
  60. ^ ?ysclid=lyre79g5rz175729213 The OS at the Ministry of Internal Affairs controls the situation with the falsification of fines on Kuban
  61. ^ [https://www.gazeta.ru/auto/2016/02/02_a_8053151.shtml ?ysclid=lyre63p6xw762295488&updated Krasnodar traffic cops were left under investigation]
  62. ^ Indistinguishable violations were taken out of the cells. Regional inspections were banned from using automation too freely
  63. ^ The traffic police will stop fining for a number of violations recorded by automatic cameras
  64. ^ The traffic police decided to ban Tambov traffic cops from being fined for an unbuttoned belt taken on camera
  65. ^ The deputy proposed to create a federal center for monitoring radars
  66. ^ ?ysclid=lyre459orb849671732 Vyacheslav Lysakov: "The mess with the cameras undermines the credibility of власти»
  67. ^ «АВТОУРАГАН» : ручная автофиксация (или механизм фальсификаций штрафов на примере Воронежской и Тамбовской областей)
  68. ^ [https://internet-law.ru/gosts/gost/63005/?ysclid=lziehqn0v6444620095 ГОСТ Р 57145-2016 Специальные технические средства, работающие в автоматическом режиме и имеющие функции фото- и киносъемки, видеозаписи, для обеспечения контроля за дорожным движением. Правила применения]
  69. ^ Водителю на заметку: как система ГИБДД “Паутина” ловит угонщиков и выписывает штрафы
  70. ^ ?ysclid=lzmq1uhkt8727931490 Drivers don't like the order of the numbers.The Prosecutor General's Office is asked to change the mechanism for appealing against fines
  71. ^ The gap in the electronic signature is removed. The Prosecutor General's Office asks the Interior Ministry to clarify the procedure for using it to appeal driver's fines
  72. ^ /?ysclid=lz765x3zks250133030 Electronic appeal of fines: to whom the new service is available
  73. ^ Results of the "Best Expert" competition for anti-corruption expertise of regulatory legal acts
  74. ^ Fine trap for motorists
  75. ^ / A working group has been assembled to monitor the legality of the operation of the photo-video recording system in Tambov
  76. ^ ?ysclid=lyoj1k0v3r75229927 Fines[bad weather
  77. ^ Cloudy with explanations
  78. ^ /?ysclid=lzjpjoqvpo908626826 Arbitration Court of the city of Moscow. The essence of the dispute: on challenging the decisions of administrative authorities on bringing to administrative responsibility
  79. ^ [https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/4013743 ?ysclid=lzjoydtlk118033107 The Supreme Court is hanging over the "Assistant of Moscow" The legality of the application for catching violators will be challenged after clarification by the Sun]
  80. ^ [https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/4017302 ?from=main_8 The Supreme Court did not pick up the phone The SUN did not consider the phone to be a means of automatically fixing traffic violations]
  81. ^ [ https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/6002097 The State Duma refused to adopt the "law on informers" Application for fixing traffic violators by citizens postponed indefinitely]
  82. ^ The software developers demanded to return the penalty for the average speed
  83. ^ Auto.<url> Fines for average speed have been canceled
  84. ^ Rossiyskaya Gazeta. In Russia, they will not measure the average speed on the roads
  85. ^ /?ysclid=lzjtbgd7as121941697 NTV.Dangerous safety
  86. ^ Return powerful
  87. ^ [ https://rg.ru/2023/06/07/mvd-planiruet-vernut-kontrol-za-deiatelnostiu-dorozhnyh-sluzhb-i-vladelcev-dorog.html?ysclid=luoh8tau8k212943904 Russian newspaper. The Ministry of Internal Affairs plans to return control over the activities of road services]
  88. ^ ?ysclid=lwdx8747w4300460841&from=copy autonews. The traffic police lost part of their powers. How will this affect the quality of roads
  89. ^ /?ysclid=lwdxamylou350908151 ONF Analytics digest. Page 7
  90. ^ ?ysclid=lwdvrzh5xr318052937 Kommersant.The traffic police will do everything according to the raids
  91. ^ The main road. Dangerous intersections. from 4 minutes of recording
  92. ^ [https://base.garant.ru/401435066/?ysclid=lzplyf9wax979047607 Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation dated June 30, 2021 No. 1101 "On approval of the Regulations on Federal State Control (supervision) in the field of road safety and invalidation of Certain Acts of the Government of the Russian Federation and certain Provisions of certain Acts of the Government of the Russian Federation" (with amendments and additions) ]
  93. ^ / Vesti Tambov. The city administration promised to eliminate problems with road signs знаками
  94. ^ Penalty trap. ONF experts on road markings
  95. ^ complaints about the pedestrian crossing
  96. ^ Vesti Tambov. In search of "zebra"
  97. ^ /?ysclid=lzjys9z0tk377070706 News. Tambov summed up the results of the action "Motorcyclist"
  98. ^ [ https://docs.yandex.ru/docs/view?tm=1723041637&tld=ru&lang=ru&name=53-28.04.2022.pdf&text=%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%B5%D0%BA%D1%82%D0%BD%D1%8B%D0%B9%20%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%BC%D0%B8%D1%82%D0%B5%D1%82%20%D0%B1%D0%BA%D0%B4%20%D1%82%D0%B0%D0%BC%D0%B1%D0%BE%D0%B2%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B0%D1%8F%20%D0%BE%D0%B1%D0%BB%D0%B0%D1%81%D1%82%D1%8C%20%D1%81%D0%BE%D0%BB%D0%BE%D0%B2%D1%8C%D0%B5%D0%B2%D0%B0&url=https%3A%2F%2Fdortrans.tmbreg.ru%2Fassets%2Ffiles%2FBKAD%2F53-28.04.2022.pdf&lr=218680&mime=pdf&l10n=ru&sign=0a69177ae3878bd601d3486d9e25f224&keyno=0&nosw=1&serpParams=tm%3D1723041637%26tld%3Dru%26lang%3Dru%26name%3D53-28.04.2022.pdf%26text%3D%25D0%25BF%25D1%2580%25D0%25BE%25D0%25B5%25D0%25BA%25D1%2582%25D0%25BD%25D1%258B%25D0%25B9%2B%25D0%25BA%25D0%25BE%25D0%25BC%25D0%25B8%25D1%2582%25D0%25B5%25D1%2582%2B%25D0%25B1%25D0%25BA%25D0%25B4%2B%25D1%2582%25D0%25B0%25D0%25BC%25D0%25B1%25D0%25BE%25D0%25B2%25D1%2581%25D0%25BA%25D0%25B0%25D1%258F%2B%25D0%25BE%25D0%25B1%25D0%25BB%25D0%25B0%25D1%2581%25D1%2582%25D1%258C%2B%25D1%2581%25D0%25BE%25D0%25BB%25D0%25BE%25D0%25B2%25D1%258C%25D0%25B5%25D0%25B2%25D0%25B0%26url%3Dhttps%253A%2F%2Fdortrans.tmbreg.ru%2Fassets%2Ffiles%2FBKAD%2F53-28.04.2022.pdf%26lr%3D218680%26mime%3Dpdf%26l10n%3Dru%26sign%3D0a69177ae3878bd601d3486d9e25f224%26keyno%3D0%26nosw%3D1 Состав проектного офиса. Протокол Заседания регионального офиса нацпроекта БКД]
  99. ^ Тамбов.ру. Тамбовская область награждение за достижение наилучших показателей БКД
  100. ^ Report state government
  101. ^ ВестиТамбов, эксперты Народного фронта нашли изъяны на новой дороге
  102. ^ ОнлайнТамбов. Гибдд разъяснили правила парковки у РИО
  103. ^ Вести. Парковки областного центра требуют перемен
  104. ^ Вести. Народный фронт плотно занялся парковками
  105. ^ Телекомпания РБК. ЧЭЗ. СИМы
  106. ^ Полоса безопасности. Про средства индивидуальной мобильности и цивилизационный конфликт
  107. ^ [Legal issues of restoration of violated rights in the context of the implementation of OSAGO Materials of the International Youth Scientific Forum "LOMONOSOV-2010" / Ed. I.A. Aleshkovsky, P.N. Kostylev, A.I. Andreev, A.V. Andriyanov. [Electronic resource] — Moscow: MAKS Press, 2010. — 1 electron. optical disc (CD-ROM); 12 cm. - Systems. Requirements: PC with 486+ processor; Windows 95; CD-ROM drive; Adobe Acrobat Reader. ISBN 978-5-317-03197-8
  108. ^ Телеканал Россия. Утро Россия. Реформа ОСАГО в действии. С 1 минуты
  109. ^ Программа качество жизни. Соловьева
  110. ^ https://expert.onf.ru/news/jekspert-napravlenija-narodnyj-front-analitika-ekaterina-solovjova-o-predlozhenii-vvesti-analog-osago-dlja-kurerov-na-jelektrosamokatah/?ysclid=lzk0hi09rw97652778 НФ Аналитика. Эксперт Соловьева поддержала законопроект об ОСАГО для курьеров СИМов]
  111. ^ The first channel. The digital signature has a high degree of protection
  112. ^ /?ysclid=lzh3yqunt8362594104 Online tams. Pits on the roads circled in red
  113. ^ Dorinfo.Makhachkala. Pits on the roads circled in red
  114. ^ The Supreme Court. The decision in the CAS case
  115. ^ /?ysclid=lzmzypgbfk207330683 Order of the Ministry of Internal Affairs on approval of Regulation No.644
  116. ^ Online LAMB. Deputy head of the regional administration Chulkov was detained
  117. ^ /?ysclid=lzn0tzd7ka985362812 News.Did Chulkov write a suicide note?
  118. ^ /?ysclid=lzk5467tx498022072 NTV. Vice-Governor Chulkov, who was under investigation, died
  119. ^ /?ysclid=lzk5wrkgva191681694 News.Chulkov was buried at the Vozdvizhenskoye cemetery
  120. ^ The vice governor could not stand the investigation. Relatives of the deceased Tambov official ask to identify those responsible for his death
  121. ^ /?ysclid=lzk59hulvt40876387 Investigation of the NTV week. Death of Chulkov
  122. ^ /?ysclid=lzk5old1ro741205743 Pasmi
  123. ^ ?ysclid=lzk5m08j6o189651548 TFR initiated a case of suicide of the Tambov vice-governor
  124. ^ /?ysclid=lzk6j9p576364098865 News.Oleg Ivanov resigns
  125. ^ Resolution on the composition of the city commission
  126. ^ /?ysclid=lyuiqpwnv9785196733 in Tambov.Do not park your car at the main entrance to Rio: the lane will be used to enter the new parking lot
  127. ^ /?ysclid=lyuipiexkz895583184 Online Lamb.The traffic police explained the parking rules at the RIO shopping center
  128. ^ ?marker=64U0IK Resolution of the city administration On Amendments to the Resolution of the Tambov City Administration of the Tambov region dated 08/26/2022 N 5993 "On approval of the composition of the Commission for Road Safety and Development of the road network under the Tambov City Administration of the Tambov region"
  129. ^ Truth.roo. Pits of Yekaterinburg
  130. ^ Pits the size of a football
  131. ^ / Vesti Tambov. Dangerous storm drains
  132. ^ / Experts of the Popular Front checked the condition of the roads
  133. ^ Tambov reporter.In Tambov, a team of workers cuts the road with axes
  134. ^ /?ysclid=lzmyad498w715386909 Why do they chop down the markings with axes in Tambov
  135. ^ "Ours" with alarm clock
  136. ^ [https://www.gazeta.ru/politics/2011/04/13_a_3583057.shtml?ysclid=lznysesznt57127813 "Our" will intercept bribes Surkov blessed the Nashi movement to intercept the anti-corruption theme from the opposition]
  137. ^ /?ysclid=lzl8kaboi8301959655 SF Analytics