Category talk:Geography of Hawaii

CFD Discussion

The request to post more about my nomination of this category for the categories for deletion page is resonable. I did it because it appeared to be a duplicate of Geography of Hawaii but now I understand that its aim is something slightly different. I believe that the name similarities are going to cause continual confusion between the two categories and perhaps this one needs a more distinct name. I am willing to withdraw my nomination if you are able to persuade me that there is a solution to this. I'll keeping watching this page for other comments.

My attention was initially brought to this category because Hawaian geography stubs is both a category and subcategory of this group, causing a category cycle. This should be remedied, but I'll leave it up to someone else.

JonHarder 19:34, 22 January 2006 (UTC)

Clean cat

I've added the clean cat tag due to the current organization of this category. There is massive duplication of categories, random lists, and no clear structure. I would like this category to conform to Wikipedia standards. —Viriditas | Talk 23:09, 8 May 2006 (UTC)