Category talk:Christianity and antisemitism

Latest comment: 10 years ago by Obiwankenobi in topic Removal of bios from this category

Removal of bios from this category edit

I removed several biographies from this category. This removal was based on a 2011 CFD, which aimed to define the scope for "bias" categories. The consensus at the time was that individuals and groups accused of anti-(whatever), when (whatever) was framed as a bias, such as racism, homophobia, anti-semitism, etc, and this consensus was intended to be applied globally, as elaborated by the closing admin here, and not just to BLPs. At the time of the closing, the head category Category:Antisemitism was tagged with this notice: [1]. Since that CFD, there has not been a global RFC or any other large-scale decision to start to allow biographies of those accused of bias into bias categories. Any categories that suggest bias, such as Category:Racists or Category:Antisemitic people have been deleted. I believe thus we are following existing consensus by not having bios of people accused of anti-semitism, even if they are *indeed* antisemitic (which I'm not disputing here) - it's just the rule seems to be "no bios". (--Obi-Wan Kenobi (talk) 01:19, 29 May 2013 (UTC)Reply