Category talk:Arthurian legend

Latest comment: 12 years ago by Dbachmann in topic Category overkill

Arthurian English and Scottish?

edit

I propose that this category be removed from the English and Scottish folklore sections as A) They are not 'native' folklore of those countries, B) if English and Scottish why not French and Dutch, both countries of France and the Netherlands, have poems and tales set in the 'Arthurian' world, and in the case of France various locations have been associated with him. If it's the fact that many places now in England are associated with England then I should remind everyone that 'Beowulf' is set in Geatland, now in Sweden, but is not considered a Swedish poem.

I think the folkloric categories should be for folklore that is native to the region rather than attributed to the region (i.e. 'The Laidly Worm' being in English folklore but not in Scandinavian folklore just because the hero is said to be in Norway at the beginning of the story in many versions). Sigurd Dragon Slayer (talk) 20:21, 25 January 2008 (UTC)Reply

Yes, but wikipedians that edit articles related to England and Britain have a ridiculous pro-Celtic bias and thus want to make England as Celtic (or British) as possible. Scholars know that Arthurian tales are British tales that were adopted by Normans as a new way to insult the English (they thought tales about an old enemy of the English to be rather humorous when forced down the collective throat populace).

Yes, France, the Nederlands and even Germany have many, many tales about Arthur (infact, most of the famous Arthurian romances were written by French authors and Germany has him as the leader of the wild hunt). However, the Nederlanders are seen as Germanic whereas the English are not, despite the fact that the closest language to English, Frisian, is within the borders of the Nederlands and the Frisian have close genetical links (which seems to be the only thing most wikipedians care about; I don't) with England and also has a connection to the Celts as Britain does. Deutschland is seen as 'more Germanic' than England because of the English name for the country, despite the fact that the Halstatt culture and the Lá Tene are Celtic and within its borders and it has Celtic traditions aswell. The Germans are connected with Nazism and thus the British wikipedians don't want to be connected to them.

Like 'Holland' and 'Germany', the French are continental and thus the wikipedians that follow the stupid Britishist plague don't want to be connected to them. They want Britain to be all one culture and ethnicity when infact it is many. They want to be seen as special and different from the continent and thus support the much discreditted Sykes and Oppenheimer because they make it seem as if the British more 'indiginous' to Europe than most of the other Europeans. It is a form of nationalism; anti-Germanicism is a hidious byproduct of the otherwise acceptable anti-Nazism and the new age pro-Celtic rubbish (not that Celtic culture is rubbish but the new age take on it is) that has grown in popularity.

Due to all these reasons these wikipedians are not content with listing Athurian myths as Welsh and Cornish like most academics but instead want to force it into the English folklore section.

I have no idea why people want King Arthur to be part of the folkloric tradition of Scotland, either, as it (like England) doesn't have much to do with the Arthurian tradition.

I am all for either Arthurian myths being put into the Nederlandic, German and French categories or being taken from the English and Scottish categories and left in the Welsh and Cornish categories. - Mr Roland Spounge. —Preceding unsigned comment added by 81.129.51.113 (talk) 22:49, 25 January 2008 (UTC)Reply

Arthur and the Arthurian legend do relate to English and Scottish folklore, meaning that modern (or past) English and Scottish people incorporated them into their own folklore. The clearest example is in the folklore of places, I believe I mentioned Glastonbury and the many places called Arthur's Seat or Arthur's Cave that are present throughout Britain - these places are important folkloric items to the modern English and Scottish people. In contrast Beowulf and the Laidly Worm are not important to the Scandinavians, but only to the English. This is the reason the categories are appropriate.--Cúchullain t/c 23:04, 25 January 2008 (UTC)Reply
Agreed. English culture hasn't been exclusively Anglo-Saxon for oh, quite a while now. —Mhari* 00:07, 26 January 2008 (UTC)Reply

So if what you say is true, it then also be put into Dutch, French and German, folklore categories? They incorporated the Arthurian mythos into their own, also. And Beowulf is somewhat important to the Scandinavians, firstly there are places associated with him (associated by the English but then again the English and Scots did not associate Arthur with the locations in their respective countries, but some Welsh poets) and there is a debate in Scandinavia to where Beowulf is from (Gotland or Geatland) and many think he is from a Scandinavian story. And obviously the English have not been exclusively 'Anglo-Saxon' as that was a period not the culture (they called themselves English...well Engla, Englisc...etc...).

Why not just put it in the British Folklore if it is in the folklore of all the nations in Britain rather than repeat it in all the subcategories?

If it is decided then that it shall have to stay in categories it (in my opinion) shouldn't belong, then I shall go about the tedious task of placing it in all the countries with Arthurian tales (as it should be in them by the definition used here). Sigurd Dragon Slayer (talk)

Firstly, there is a difference between literary and folklore traditions. Dutch, French, German, etc. use of the Arthurian legend has always been primarily literary, they have not incorporated it into their folklore extensively. England and Scotland have a strong literature of Arthur, but they've also incorporated the legend into their folklore, one instance being the place lore I mentioned (and no, Glastonbury and the Arthur's caves have nothing to do with Welsh poets). As for Beowulf, I don't know nearly as much about that, but my understanding was that he was not very important to the Scandanavians, if he were obviously this would be a poor example. And as for just placing it in the generic category British folklore, it's generally considered poor form to place something in both a category and a subcat, per WP:CAT. I don't mind it being in the national category on top of the subcats, but it should be in all the appropriate subcats if it's in any of them.--Cúchullain t/c 19:50, 30 January 2008 (UTC)Reply

Yes, but Arthurian 'folklore' is predominately a literary tradition at least in England and Scotland. You are correct that the legends that surround Glastonbury Tor have nothing to do with Welsh poets (other than the fact Arthur started predominately as a character in Welsh/Brythonic poetry, I presume..see Aneirin, Nennius and Geoffrey of Monmouth) it is mainly the work of a French poet named Robert de Boron (unless you are in the minority that believe monks 'found' Arthur's grave before his writings). As for 'Arthur's Caves' I take you mean caves like Merlin's Cave at Tintagel (which would make it Cornish not English as they are generally accepted as separate strands though they do share many motifs via borrowings into Cornish and vice versa). Besides the French and Dutch have some folktales associated with the Arthurian mythos, for instance Paimpont forest has a local legend concerning Merlin and the Lady of the Lake. The majority of Arthurian folklore is literary and not true folklore, so if we are going to be picky and separate folklore and literature then we should remove much of the pages in the Arthurian category and only place genuine folk tales (of which there are few). I do agree that the Arthurian Mythos is part of English and Scottish literature but not genuine folklore. at least not anymore than it is French. Sigurd Dragon Slayer (talk) 19:34, 1 February 2008 (UTC)Reply

It's not a matter of being picky, it's a matter of being accurate. There is a difference between literature and folklore. England and Scotland have a strong literary tradition of Arthur, but they also have incorporated Arthurian lore into their own genuine folklore, to a much greater extent than on the continent, where the Arthurian legend was primarily a literary concern. I don't know where you get the idea that this is not the case. By Arthur's Caves, I mean the folk belief that certain caves around Britain are where Arthur sleeps until his return. I quote The New Arthurian Encyclopedia, under "Cave Legend":"But a folk belief... took hold among the Welsh and in parts of England and Scotland: that [Arthur] was asleep in a cave until his messianic return". The "Folklore" entry in that same encyclopedia discusses many folk beliefs about Arthur from Wales, England, Scotland, and Brittany, but virtually nothing about such beliefs in other European nations. Some of your other assertions are wrong, for instance Nennius and Geoffrey of Monmouth did not compose "Welsh/Brythonic" poetry, but Latin prose, and say nothing about Glastonbury. Also remember that Cornwall is in England, and that Brittany, where Paimpont is, is now represented here with a folklore category.
The folklore categories that are here are appropriate. It's time to let this go.--Cúchullain t/c 23:11, 1 February 2008 (UTC)Reply

It doesn't matter whether Nennius or Geoffrey of Monmouth wrote in Latin or Welsh. He is Welsh. I did not specify which language they wrote in as it does not matter (in this regard). Just as Bede was English and yet wrote in Latin, Nennius and Geoffrey of Monmouth were Welsh (or Brythonic). Let's not skirt around the issue that on the continent they also have 'folktales' featuring Arthur. Maybe you do not think it is quite as much as in England and Scotland (fair enough) but he still features. But I am bored with this subject now. Wikipedia is not renowned for it's common sense so it does not really matter in the long run. Sigurd Dragon Slayer (talk) 09:50, 12 February 2008 (UTC)Reply

There's no need to get testy, we're all civilized people here. But note that I referred you to an encyclopedia that refers to English and Scottish folklore about Arthur but does not mention any on the continent save for Brittany. If you have any similar evidence to back up your notion that countries on the continent have equally strong folklore traditions as the Brits, bring it up. Otherwise it's just assumption.--Cúchullain t/c 21:50, 12 February 2008 (UTC)Reply

PockBot (run by IP:207.160.66.129) - Category articles summary as of 21:7:37, Wed Apr 25, 2007

edit


List of all pages in category Arthurian legend retrieved by Chris G Bot 2.

Chris G Bot 2 is an authorised bot.

ArticleClass / Status
Matter of BritainStart
King Arthur in various medianot yet classified
2597 ArthurStub
2598 MerlinStub
AccolonStub
AddancStub
Aglovalenot yet classified
Agravainnot yet classified
Agrestesnot yet classified
Ambrosius Aurelianusnot yet classified
Amharnot yet classified
AneirinStart
Annales Cambriaenot yet classified
Annwnnot yet classified
King ArthurA
Arthur stonenot yet classified
Arthur's Seat, Edinburghnot yet classified
ArtoriusStub
Lucius Artorius CastusStart
Geoffrey AsheStub
Astolatnot yet classified
Athrwys ap MeurigStub
Avalonnot yet classified
Sir Balannot yet classified
Sir Balinnot yet classified
King BanStub
Battle of Bedegrainenot yet classified
Battle of CamlannStart
Battle of Mons BadonicusB
Bediverenot yet classified
Black Book of CarmarthenStub
Black Knight (Arthurian legend)not yet classified
Black Knight (Marvel Comics)B
BlanchefleurStub
BlancheflorStub
Bodmin Moornot yet classified
The Book of King Arthur and His Noble Knights of the Round Tablenot yet classified
Book of TaliesinStub
Borsnot yet classified
The Boy and the MantleStub
Bran the Blessednot yet classified
Brangainenot yet classified
Bretonnianot yet classified
Sir Breunornot yet classified
Cadair IdrisB
Cadbury Castle, Somersetnot yet classified
CadocStart
CadorStub
CaeliaStub
Caerleonnot yet classified
Calogrenantnot yet classified
Camelotnot yet classified
CanoelStub
Caradocnot yet classified
Carmarthennot yet classified
Castle an Dinas, St. Columb MajorStub
Cat Coit CelidonStub
Cath PalugStub
Celliwignot yet classified
Cerdic of Wessexnot yet classified
ClarentStub
Claudasnot yet classified
Constans II (usurper)Start
Constantine III (usurper)B
Constantine III of Britainnot yet classified
Corbenicnot yet classified
Legendary Dukes of CornwallStub
Culhwchnot yet classified
Cynric of WessexStub
DagonetStub
Daniel von Blumenthalnot yet classified
DinadanStub
Dinas Emrysnot yet classified
Dindranenot yet classified
Dolorous Strokenot yet classified
Dozmary PoolStub
DubriciusStub
Sir Ectornot yet classified
Elaine (legend)not yet classified
Elaine of Astolatnot yet classified
EliwlodStub
Elphinnot yet classified
Elyan the Whitenot yet classified
Enidenot yet classified
ErecStub
EsclaborStub
EscladosStub
EvaineStub
Excaliburnot yet classified
Faerie KnightStub
Feirefiznot yet classified
Felec of CornwallStub
Fisher Kingnot yet classified
Gabhrannot yet classified
Gaherisnot yet classified
Galahadnot yet classified
Galligantusnot yet classified
Garel von Blumenthalnot yet classified
Garethnot yet classified
GawainB
GeraintStart
GildasStart
Gingalainnot yet classified
Glastonburynot yet classified
Glastonbury AbbeyStart
Glastonbury Tornot yet classified
Goleuddyddnot yet classified
Gorloisnot yet classified
GornemantStub
GrifletStub
GringoletStub
Guineverenot yet classified
Gwenhwyfachnot yet classified
HallowStart
Hawkstone Grailnot yet classified
Hector de MarisStub
HengestStart
Historia Britonumnot yet classified
Historical basis for King Arthurnot yet classified
HoelStart
Holy GrailB
HorsaStub
Igrainenot yet classified
IlltudStart
Iseultnot yet classified
Joseph of ArimatheaB
Josephus of Arimatheanot yet classified
Kahedinnot yet classified
Sir KayStub
Saint KeaStub
Kilyddnot yet classified
Knights of PendragonStub
Knights of the Round Tablenot yet classified
Kyotnot yet classified
The Lady of Shalottnot yet classified
Lady of the LakeStart
LailokenStub
LamorakStub
LancelotStart
Laudinenot yet classified
LeodegranceStub
Sir Lionelnot yet classified
List of Arthurian charactersnot yet classified
List of legendary kings of Britainnot yet classified
ListeneiseStub
Battle of Llongborthnot yet classified
Loathly ladynot yet classified
LogresStub
Lohengrinnot yet classified
Roger Sherman Loomisnot yet classified
King Lotnot yet classified
Sir Lucannot yet classified
Lucius TiberiusStub
Lunetenot yet classified
Lynetnot yet classified
Lynette and Lyonessenot yet classified
Lyonessenot yet classified
Lyonesse (person)not yet classified
Mabinogionnot yet classified
Magnus MaximusStart
Maleagantnot yet classified
Walter Mapnot yet classified
Mark of Cornwallnot yet classified
Jean Markalenot yet classified
MeirchionStub
MeliodasStub
MerlinB
Merlin's Oaknot yet classified
Madam MimStub
Mordrednot yet classified
Morfrannot yet classified
Morgaine le Fey (DC Comics)not yet classified
Morgan le FayB
Morgausenot yet classified
Morholtnot yet classified
Morvyddnot yet classified
Mount Killarausnot yet classified
Saint MungoStart
Myrddin Wylltnot yet classified
Nenniusnot yet classified
Olwennot yet classified
Orgelusenot yet classified
Owain Ddantgwynnot yet classified
Owain mab Uriennot yet classified
Paimpont forestnot yet classified
Palamedes (Arthurian legend)not yet classified
Pellamnot yet classified
Pelleasnot yet classified
Pellesnot yet classified
Pellinorenot yet classified
Pendragonnot yet classified
Percivalnot yet classified
List of films based on Arthurian legendnot yet classified
The Adventures of Sir Lancelotnot yet classified
Arthur of the Britonsnot yet classified
Arthur! and the Square Knights of the Round TableStub
Battlefield (Doctor Who)not yet classified
Camelot (film)Start
A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's CourtStart
A Connecticut Yankeenot yet classified
Excalibur (film)B
First KnightStart
The Fisher King (film)Start
The Gathering (film)Start
Kaamelottnot yet classified
A Kid in King Arthur's CourtStart
King Arthur (film)B
King Arthur and the Knights of Justicenot yet classified
King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table (anime)Stub
King Arthur: Prince on White HorseStub
KnightridersStart
Knights of the Round Table (film)Start
Lancelot and GuinevereStart
Lancelot du Lac (film)Stub
A Late Delivery from Avalonnot yet classified
The Legend of Prince ValiantStub
Merlin (film)Start
Merlin's Apprenticenot yet classified
Monty Python and the Holy GrailB
Pardes (film)Start
Perceval le GalloisStub
Pound Puppies and the Legend of Big PawA
Princess Gwenevere and the Jewel Ridersnot yet classified
Quest for CamelotStart
Quest for King Arthurnot yet classified
The Sword in the Stone (film)Start
Sword of the Valiant: The Legend of Sir Gawain and the Green KnightStart
Tristan & Isolde (film)Start
Arthur: The Quest for ExcaliburStart
Chronicles of the SwordStub
Conquests of Camelot: The Search for the GrailStart
Dark Age of CamelotB
Excalibur (computer game)Stub
Galahad and the Holy GrailStub
Grailquestnot yet classified
King Arthur (video game)Stub
King Arthur's WorldStart
Knights of the Round (video game)Stub
Legend of GalahadStub
Pendragon (role-playing game)not yet classified
Shadows Over Camelotnot yet classified
Spirit of ExcaliburStart
Vengeance of ExcaliburStart
Young MerlinStub
List of books about King Arthurnot yet classified
The Acts of King Arthur and His Noble Knightsnot yet classified
Alliterative Morte Arthurenot yet classified
Amadis de GaulaStart
Antiocheis (Joseph of Exeter)not yet classified
Avalon HighStub
Avalon Seriesnot yet classified
BéroulStub
Bewnans KeStub
The Birth of MerlinStart
The Book of MerlynStub
Marion Zimmer BradleyStart
Gillian Bradshawnot yet classified
Brut (Layamon)Stub
Brut y TywysogionStub
C. Scott Littletonnot yet classified
Camelot 3000Stub
Thomas ChestreStub
Chrétien de Troyesnot yet classified
Cligèsnot yet classified
Corpus Christi Carolnot yet classified
The Crystal CaveStub
Culhwch and Olwennot yet classified
Diu Crônenot yet classified
The Dream of Rhonabwynot yet classified
The Eagle (novel)Stub
Eilhart von ObergeStart
Erec and Enidenot yet classified
Excalibur (novel)Stub
The Faerie QueeneStub
The Fionavar TapestryStart
The Forest HouseB
Hal Fosternot yet classified
From Ritual to Romancenot yet classified
Geoffrey of MonmouthStart
Geraint and Enidnot yet classified
Gerbert de MontreuilStub
A Glastonbury RomanceStart
Godefroi de Leigninot yet classified
Gottfried von Straßburgnot yet classified
Guenevere, Queen of the Summer CountryStart
Lady Charlotte GuestStart
Hartmann von Auenot yet classified
Historia Regum Britanniaenot yet classified
The Hollow HillsStub
HuchounStart
Idylls of the Kingnot yet classified
The Ill-Made KnightStub
JaufréStub
Debra A. Kempnot yet classified
The Knight of the Sacred LakeStub
Knight of the Swannot yet classified
Lady of AvalonStub
The Lais of Marie de FranceStub
Lancelot, the Knight of the Cartnot yet classified
Lancelot-Grailnot yet classified
The Lantern Bearers (Sutcliff novel)Stub
Lanvalnot yet classified
Lanzeletnot yet classified
The Last EnchantmentStub
Sanders Anne LaubenthalStub
LayamonStart
Libeaus Desconusnot yet classified
Linda A. Malcornot yet classified
Lost Years of Merlin seriesStub
The Lost Years of MerlinStub
Thomas Malorynot yet classified
Marie de Francenot yet classified
The Marriage of Sir GawainStub
The Mists of AvalonStart
Moriennot yet classified
Le Morte d'Arthurnot yet classified
The Once and Future KingStart
Owain, or the Lady of the FountainStub
Parzivalnot yet classified
Diana L. PaxsonStub
Pendragon (fiction series)not yet classified
Pendragon CycleStart
Perceforestnot yet classified
Perceval, the Story of the Grailnot yet classified
Peredur son of Efrawgnot yet classified
Perlesvausnot yet classified
Post-Vulgate Cyclenot yet classified
Preiddeu Annwfnnot yet classified
Prince Valiantnot yet classified
Prose Tristannot yet classified
The Return of Merlinnot yet classified
Robert de Boronnot yet classified
Roman de BrutStub
Roman de FergusB
Roman van FerguutStub
Romance of Palamedesnot yet classified
Rustichello da Pisanot yet classified
The Singing SwordStub
Sir Gawain and the Green Knightnot yet classified
Sir Launfalnot yet classified
Mary StewartStub
StrickerStub
Rosemary Sutcliffnot yet classified
Sword at SunsetStub
The Sword in the StoneStub
Taliesinnot yet classified
That Hideous StrengthStart
The Dark is Rising Sequencenot yet classified
The Greene KnightStub
Thomas of BritainStub
Tristan and Iseultnot yet classified
Tristrantnot yet classified
Ulrich von Türheimnot yet classified
Ulrich von Zatzikhovennot yet classified
Jacob van Maerlantnot yet classified
WaceStub
The Warlord ChroniclesStub
Kenneth G. T. Websternot yet classified
The Wedding of Sir Gawain and Dame Ragnellenot yet classified
Welsh RomancesStub
T. H. Whitenot yet classified
The Wicked DayStub
Wolfram von EschenbachStart
Yvain, the Knight of the Lionnot yet classified
Camelot (musical)not yet classified
Gawain (opera)not yet classified
King Arthur (opera)not yet classified
Lohengrin (opera)not yet classified
The Misfortunes of Arthurnot yet classified
ParsifalA
Tom Thumbnot yet classified
Tristan und Isoldenot yet classified
Albanactusnot yet classified
AllectusB
AndragiusStub
ArchgalloStart
ArchmailStub
Arvirargusnot yet classified
AsclepiodotusB
Aurelius ConanusStub
BeldgabredStub
BelinusStart
BladudStart
BledudoStub
Brenniusnot yet classified
Brutus GreenshieldStub
Brutus of Troynot yet classified
CalchfyneddStub
Cap of BritainStub
CapoirStub
CaradocusStub
CarausiusStart
Cassivellaunusnot yet classified
CatellusStub
CeredigStub
CherinStub
CledaucusStub
ClotenusStub
CoilusStub
Old King Colenot yet classified
Constantius ChlorusB
Queen CordeliaStart
CorineusStub
Crocea MorsStub
CunedagiusStub
Cuneddanot yet classified
CunobelinusB
DaniusStub
DigueillusStub
DionotusStub
Dunvallo MolmutiusStart
EbraucusStub
EdadusStub
Einion Yrth ap CuneddaStub
EldolStub
ElidurusStart
EliudStub
EnniaunusStub
Ferrexnot yet classified
FulgeniusStub
GerennusStub
Publius Septimius GetaStart
Goídel Glasnot yet classified
GorboducStub
GorbonianusStub
Gracianus Municepsnot yet classified
Gratian (usurper)not yet classified
Guideriusnot yet classified
GuithelinStub
GurgintiusStub
Gurguit BarbtrucStub
GurgustiusStub
Queen GwendolenStart
Heli, King of BritainStub
IdvalloStub
Ingenius (British king)Stub
Jagonot yet classified
Jago of BritainStub
Kambernot yet classified
Keredicnot yet classified
KimarcusStub
KinariusStub
LeilStub
Leir of BritainStart
Llyr LlediaithStub
LocrinusStub
Lucius of BritainStub
Lud son of Helinot yet classified
MaddanStub
MalgoStub
MandubraciusB
Queen MarciaStub
Marganusnot yet classified
Marganus IIStub
Marius of Britainnot yet classified
MempriciusStub
MerianusStub
MillusStub
Molmutine Lawsnot yet classified
MorvidusStart
Nennius of BritainStub
Octaviusnot yet classified
OenusStub
PeredurusStub
Pir of the BritonsStub
Porrex Inot yet classified
Porrex IIStub
RedechiusStub
Redon (king)Stub
RivalloStub
Idwal RoebuckStub
Roman departure from Britainnot yet classified
Rud Hud HudibrasStub
RunoStub
Sisilliusnot yet classified
Sisillius IStub
Sisillius IIStub
Sisillius IIIStub
Son of GorbonianusStub
Sons of Mordrednot yet classified
Sub-Roman Britainnot yet classified
Tasciovanusnot yet classified
Trahernnot yet classified
Trinovantumnot yet classified
UrianusStub
Uther Pendragonnot yet classified
Venissanot yet classified
Vortigernnot yet classified
Vortimernot yet classified
VortiporiusStub
Welsh Triadsnot yet classified
The Da Vinci CodeB
The Da Vinci Code (film)Stub
Grail (Babylon 5)not yet classified
Grail (DC Comics)Stub
Grail Movementnot yet classified
The Holy Blood and the Holy Grailnot yet classified
Holy Chalicenot yet classified
Indiana Jones and the Last CrusadeB
Masonic ManuscriptsB
Nanteos Cupnot yet classified
The Silver ChaliceStart
Wasteland (mythology)not yet classified
Sir Robinnot yet classified
Safirnot yet classified
Sagramorenot yet classified
SegwaridesStub
Sir Tornot yet classified
Tristannot yet classified
Uriennot yet classified
Ywainnot yet classified
Ywain the BastardStub
Amaethonnot yet classified
Arawnnot yet classified
Branwennot yet classified
The Children of LlyrStub
Cigfanot yet classified
Four Branches of the Mabinoginot yet classified
GwawlStub
Gwernnot yet classified
HafganStub
HefeyddStub
The Island of the MightyStub
Llwyd ap Cil Coednot yet classified
Llŷrnot yet classified
Manawydannot yet classified
Prince of AnnwnStub
Pryderinot yet classified
PwyllStart
Red Book of Hergestnot yet classified
RhiannonStart
The Song of RhiannonStub
Teyrnonnot yet classified
White Book of Rhydderchnot yet classified
Castle Anthraxnot yet classified
Black Beast of AaaaarrrrrrggghhhStub
Black Knight (Monty Python)Stub
Brother Maynardnot yet classified
Castle Stalkernot yet classified
Cave of CaerbannogStub
Concorde (Monty Python)not yet classified
Doune Castlenot yet classified
Gorge of Eternal PerilStub
Holy Hand Grenade of Antiochnot yet classified
Knights of the Round Table (Monty Python song)not yet classified
Knights who say Ninot yet classified
Not Dead Frednot yet classified
Patsy (Monty Python)not yet classified
Prince Herbert (Monty Python)not yet classified
Rabbit of Caerbannognot yet classified
Spamalotnot yet classified
Tim the EnchanterStart
Trojan Rabbitnot yet classified
Caesar's invasions of BritainStub
Ancalitesnot yet classified
Quintus Atriusnot yet classified
Bibrocinot yet classified
Carviliusnot yet classified
Cassinot yet classified
Quintus Tullius CiceroStart
Cingetorix (Briton)not yet classified
Commiusnot yet classified
DubrisStart
Iceninot yet classified
Imanuentiusnot yet classified
Itius PortusStub
Quintus Laberius Durusnot yet classified
Legio VII ClaudiaStub
Legio X GeminaB
Lugotorixnot yet classified
Mamurranot yet classified
Segontiacinot yet classified
Segovaxnot yet classified
Taximagulusnot yet classified
TreboniusStart
Trinovantesnot yet classified
Walmernot yet classified


Edit by PockBot (on behalf of Warlordjohncarter)

Category overkill

edit

I agree entirely with the assessment by User:Cuchullain above, dated 1 February 2008. Four years later, nothing has improved. The number of categories "Arthurian legend" is supposed to belong to is simply ridiculous.


[[Category:Anglo-Norman folklore]] [[Category:Anglo-Norman literature]] [[Category:Breton mythology and folklore]] [[Category:British folklore]] [[Category:British literature]] [[Category:British traditional history]] [[Category:Celtic Britain]] [[Category:Celtic mythology]] [[Category:Cornish culture]] [[Category:Cornish folklore]] [[Category:English folklore]] [[Category:English literature]] [[Category:French folklore]] [[Category:Middle English literature]] [[Category:Mythological kings]] [[Category:Scottish folklore]] [[Category:Sub-Roman Britain]] [[Category:Welsh folklore]] [[Category:Welsh mythology]] [[Category:England in fiction]] [[Category:Scotland in fiction]] [[Category:Wales in fiction]]


It would suffice to put it in "British traditional history". This is exactly what it is, but no, it must also be made explicit that this is, among other things, not just a topic of Cornish folklore, no, but also of Cornish culture, and not just of Welsh flolklore and of Welsh mythology, but also of Wales in fiction. And let's not forget Scotland in fiction, I don't know where that comes in, but in 300 years of chivalric romances, I am sure some character at some points sets foot in Scotland, so there you are, put it in the category (never mind that historically, there wasn't even a "Scotland" in the Arthurian period any more than there was an "England", these tales being set before the migration of either the Anglo-Saxons or the Gaels to Great Britain).

If all topics on Wikipedia would be treated as redundantly as this, our categorization system would break down completely into an unusable mess. --dab (𒁳) 14:46, 13 April 2012 (UTC)Reply