User:Awilley/Sanction log

List of articles under sanctions

Copy-pasted from Excel Methodology: check talkpage for recent discussions/disagreements, check article history for general editing volume and instances of content disputes or edit wars. Used the above to assign an activity level. (inactive, less active, semi-active, active). Noted BLPs and mostly gave them preference for keeping sanctions. Also noted which articles were about one-time past events and gave them preference to remove sanctions. Articles about ongoing events were more likely to keep sanctions.

Page	Admin	Activity level	Status
Jared Kushner	Ad Orientem
Milo Yiannopoulos	Ad Orientem
2020 Democratic Party presidential primaries	Awilley
List of concentration and internment camps	Beeblebrox
2016 Democratic National Committee email leak	Coffee	Semi-active
2016 Democratic Party presidential primaries	Coffee	Semi-active
2016 Republican Party presidential primaries	Coffee	Less active, but keep to be consistent with Democratic primaries
2016 United States presidential election	Coffee	Active	BRD only
2017 United States Senate special election in Alabama	Coffee	Semi-active
Andrew McCabe	Coffee	Less active, BLP
Bashar al-Assad	Coffee	BLP, under 1RR from Syrian	BRD Required
Bernie Sanders	Coffee	High profile BLP	BRD only
Betsy DeVos	Coffee	Semi-active BLP
CNN	Coffee	Active, BLP
Debbie Wasserman Schultz	Coffee	Semi-active BLP
Deep state in the United States	Coffee	Semi-active
Devin Nunes	Coffee	Active, BLP
Donald Trump	Coffee	Active, BLP	BRD only
Donald Trump 2016 presidential campaign	Coffee	Semi-active?	BRD only
Donald Trump 2020 presidential campaign	Coffee	Semi-active	BRD only
Donald Trump on social media now Social media use by Donald Trump	Coffee	Semi-active	BRD only
Doug Jones (politician)	Coffee	Less active, BLP
Economic policy of Donald Trump	Coffee	Semi-active, little reverting
Environmental policy of the Donald Trump administration	Coffee	Semi-active
Executive Order 13769	Coffee	Semi-active
Executive Order 13780	Coffee	Less-active, but keep consistent with 13769
Family of Donald Trump	Coffee	Less active, BLP
Foreign policy of the Donald Trump administration	Coffee	Semi-active
Fox News	Coffee	Less active, but keep same as CNN	BRD only
Freedom Caucus	Coffee	Semi-active	BRD only
Hillary Clinton	Coffee	Active, BLP	BRD only
Hillary Clinton 2016 presidential campaign	Coffee	Semi-active
Ivana Trump	Coffee	Semi-active, BLP
Ivanka Trump	Coffee	Active, BLP
Jeff Sessions	Coffee	Less-active, BLP
Kellyanne Conway	Coffee	BLP	BRD only
Legal affairs of Donald Trump	Coffee	Semi-active, controversial
Links between Trump associates and Russian officials	Coffee	Semi-active, controversial
List of federal judges appointed by Donald Trump	Coffee	Semi-active, ongoing development
Melania Trump	Coffee	Semi-active, BLP
Mick Mulvaney	Coffee	Active, BLP
Neil Gorsuch	Coffee	Semi-active, BLP
Peter Strzok	Coffee	BLP
Political appointments by Donald Trump	Coffee	Active
Presidency of Donald Trump	Coffee	Active	BRD only
Protests against Donald Trump	Coffee	Semi-active
Racial views of Donald Trump	Coffee	Semi-active, BLP, controversial	BRD only
Rex Tillerson	Coffee	Semi-active, BLP
Robert Mueller	Coffee	Active, BLP
Roger Stone	Coffee	BLP	BRD only
Roy Moore sexual misconduct allegations	Coffee	Active, BLP
Special Counsel investigation (2017–present)	Coffee	Active
Stephen Miller (political advisor)	Coffee	Semi-active, BLP, controversial
Ted Cruz	Coffee	Active, BLP	BRD only
Tiffany Trump	Coffee	Less active, but BLP
Trump–Russia dossier (Steele dossier)	Coffee	Active, controversial
Tulsi Gabbard	Coffee	Semi-active, BLP	BRD only
Van Jones	Coffee	Less active, BLP
2017 dismissal of U.S. attorneys	Coffee	Inactive	All sanctions removed
2017 Shayrat missile strike	Coffee	Less active, covered by Syrrian 1RR	All sanctions removed
2018 State of the Union Address	Coffee	Inactive	All sanctions removed
2018 Women's March	Coffee	Less-active	All sanctions removed
Blue Lives Matter	Coffee	Less active except for IP	All sanctions removed
Business projects of Donald Trump in Russia	Coffee	Less active	All sanctions removed
Cabinet of Donald Trump	Coffee	Less active	All sanctions removed
Clinton Foundation	Coffee	Less active	All sanctions removed
Donald Trump's disclosures of classified information	Coffee	Less active	All sanctions removed
Erik Prince	Coffee	Less-active	All sanctions removed
Fake News Awards	Coffee	Less active	All sanctions removed
Fake news websites in the United States	Coffee	Less active	All sanctions removed
Fire and Fury	Coffee	Less active	All sanctions removed
First 100 days of Donald Trump's presidency	Coffee	Less active	All sanctions removed
Foreign policy of Donald Trump (2015-2016)	Coffee	Less active	All sanctions removed
Results of the 2016 Democratic Party presidential primaries	Coffee	Inactive	All sanctions removed
Russian–Syrian hospital bombing campaign	Coffee	Less active	All sanctions removed
State of the Union	Coffee	Semi-active, little reverting	All sanctions removed
Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017	Coffee	Semi-active, last ew last year	All sanctions removed
Timeline of the presidency of Donald Trump	Coffee	inactive	All sanctions removed
Timeline of the Trump presidency, 2017 Q2	Coffee	less active	All sanctions removed
Timeline of the Trump presidency, 2017 Q3	Coffee	less active	All sanctions removed
Timeline of the Trump presidency, 2017 Q4	Coffee	less active	All sanctions removed
Timeline of the Trump presidency, 2018 Q1	Coffee	less active	All sanctions removed
Trump Tower wiretapping allegations	Coffee	Inactive	All sanctions removed
United States federal government shutdowns of 2018	Coffee	Less active	All sanctions removed
Trump Tower meeting	Coffee/Awilley		CR; Change to BRD
David Malpass	Doug Weller
Executive Order 13768	Doug Weller
Myron Ebell	Doug Weller
National Policy Institute	Doug Weller
Steve Bannon	Doug Weller
Victims of Immigration Crime Engagement	Doug Weller
Donald Trump sexual misconduct allegations	Drmies
Russian interference in the 2016 United States elections	EdJohnston
Efforts to impeach Donald Trump	El C
Immigration policy of Donald Trump	El C
List of executive actions by Donald Trump	El C
Michael Flynn	El C
Social policy of Donald Trump	El C
Stop Trump movement	El C
George Soros	GeneralizationsAreBad
Unite the Right rally	GeneralizationsAreBad
Judicial Watch	JzG
Kirsten Gillibrand	JzG
Brett Kavanaugh	KnightLago
2020 United States presidential election	Ks0stm, NeilN
Breitbart News	Ks0stm, NeilN
Political positions of Donald Trump	Laser brain
/r/The Donald	Lord Roem
Sean Spicer	Slakr, Coffee
Kelli Ward	TonyBallioni
Roy Moore	TonyBallioni
2016 Democratic National Convention	Zzyzx11
2016 Republican National Convention	Zzyzx11
Mike Pence	Zzyzx11
Results of the 2016 Republican Party presidential primaries	Zzyzx11
Tim Kaine	Zzyzx11

Proposal to replace "Consensus Required" on American Politics articles

Since its conception in 2016 the "Consensus Required" rule has been applied to at least 123 pages in the American Politics topic area using the template {{American politics AE}}. The rule was originally meant to be (and is still) applied as a companion to a regular 1RR restriction. In its current form the rule reads:

Consensus required: All editors must obtain consensus on the talk page of this article before reinstating any edits that have been challenged (via reversion). This includes making edits similar to the ones that have been challenged. If in doubt, don't make the edit.

I propose that it be replaced with a less restrictive rule:

Enforced BRD: If an edit you make is challenged by reversion you must discuss the issue on the article talk page and wait 24 hours (from the time of the original edit) before reinstating your edit.

Rationale: The Consensus Required rule prevents some negative behaviors, but at the expense of blocking legitimate dispute resolution techniques like making new "bold" edits that address the concerns of the reverting editor. (See the "cycle" portion of Wikipedia:BOLD, revert, discuss cycle and the paragraph titled "However, don't get stuck on the discussion".) Freezing all reinstatements of similar material and requiring a clear talkpage consensus bogs down dispute resolution and article development, and it can even reward poor behaviors like being intransigent and refusing to compromise on talk pages (paraphrasing User:Aquillion [1]).

The bad behavior prevented by Consensus Required (slow or tag-team edit warring) is some of the easiest behavior for admins to identify and sanction, requiring only a glance at an article's history; the tendentious talkpage behaviors rewarded by it are much harder to identify and sanction. I think the Consensus Required rule would be better used as an alternative to topic bans or blocks, to sanction individual editors who regularly engage in 1RR gaming or tag-team edit warring.

Option 2: Another option is to simply remove Consensus-Required and leave just regular 1RR. If you prefer that please indicate so in your !vote. In any case I hope to make "Enforced BRD" an optional parameter in the {{American politics AE}} template.

~Awilley (talk) 20:05, 11 December 2018 (UTC)

Testing template parameters

{{American politics AE|Consensus required=no}}
{{American politics AE|BRD=yes}}
{{American politics AE|BRD=yes|Consensus required=no}}

editnotice

{{American politics AE/Edit notice|Consensus required = no}}
{{American politics AE/Edit notice|Consensus required = no|BRD=yes}}
{{American politics AE/Edit notice}}