Template:Arbitration case implementation notes/Proposal/testcases

Implementation notes

edit

Clerks and Arbitrators should use this section to clarify their understanding of the final decision—at a minimum, a list of items that have passed. Additionally, a list of which remedies are conditional on others (for instance a ban that should only be implemented if a mentorship should fail), and so on. Arbitrators should not pass the motion to close the case until they are satisfied with the implementation notes.

These notes were last updated by Wug·a·po·des 18:50, 28 July 2022 (UTC); the last edit to this page was on 00:31, 19 September 2024 (UTC) by SilverLocust.

Proposed Principles
Number Proposal Name Support Oppose Abstain Status Support needed Notes
1 Purpose of Wikipedia 13 0 0 PASSING ·
2 Healthy and unhealthy conflict 12 0 0 PASSING ·
3 Consensus 0 13 0 NOT PASSING Cannot pass
4 Proposed deletion 13 0 0 PASSING ·
5 Bludgeoning 4 4 1 NOT PASSING Cannot pass 2 equal first choice; One first choice to 5.1; one second choice to 5.1. As 5.1 is passing so 1 is subtracted and also because 5.1 is passing and 5 is failing, votes marked as equal but only for one lead an extra two to be subtracted
5.1 Bludgeoning 9 2 0 PASSING · 2 equal first choice with 5; One second choice to 5; One first choice to 5.
6 Battleground conduct 13 0 0 PASSING ·
7 Repeated behavior 13 0 0 PASSING ·
Proposed Findings of Fact
Number Proposal Name Support Oppose Abstain Status Support needed Notes
1 Locus of dispute: Mass creation of articles 11 0 0 PASSING ·
2 Locus of dispute: Conduct at Articles for Deletion 11 0 0 PASSING ·
3 7&6=thirteen 11 0 0 PASSING ·
4 Johnpacklambert sanction history 11 0 0 PASSING ·
5 Johnpacklambert deletion conduct 11 0 0 PASSING ·
6 Lugnuts 11 0 0 PASSING ·
7 TenPoundHammer 11 0 1 PASSING ·
8 Mass nominations at Articles for Deletion 12 0 1 PASSING ·
9 Low quality participation at Articles for Deletion 7 0 1 PASSING ·
10 Battleground behavior at Articles for Deletion 9 0 1 PASSING ·
11 No evidence for larger issues at Articles for Deletion 0 9 1 PASSING ·
Proposed Remedies
Number Proposal Name Support Oppose Abstain Status Support needed Notes
1 7&6=thirteen warned 5 2 1 PASSING ·
2 7&6=thirteen topic banned 8 1 0 PASSING ·
3 7&6=thirteen banned 1 5 1 PASSING ·
4 Johnpacklambert topic banned 9 0 0 PASSING · 1 second choice to Johnpacklambert banned
5 Johnpacklambert banned 3 5 0 PASSING ·
6 Lugnuts warned 7 0 0 PASSING ·
7 Lugnuts banned 4 3 0 PASSING ·
8 TenPoundHammer warned 3 3 2 PASSING ·
9.1 TenPoundHammer topic banned (1) 7 1 1 PASSING ·
9.2 TenPoundHammer topic banned (2) 3 5 0 PASSING ·
10 TenPoundHammer banned 2 5 1 PASSING ·
11 Request for Comment 7 2 0 PASSING ·
12 Community encouraged 2 5 2 PASSING ·
Proposed Enforcement
Number Proposal Name Support Oppose Abstain Status Support needed Notes
0 Enforcement of restrictions 0 0 0 PASSING Cannot pass Passes by default
0 Appeals and modifications 0 0 0 PASSING Cannot pass Passes by default
Notes