Talk:Fayzulla Xoʻjayev

(Redirected from Talk:Fayzulla Khodzhayev)
Latest comment: 12 years ago by Farvartish in topic Nationality

Article Title

edit

It really would have been better had this article been left at Faizullah Khojaev. The previous transliteration Fayzulla Khodzhayev was both cumbersome and inaccurate. "y" transliterates "ы" from cyrillic, not "й" (and even then only in Russian). There is no reason to reproduce the Russian 'dzh' construction for "ج", when the latin alphabet contains a perfectly decent "j". Sikandarji 23:27, 23 April 2006 (UTC)Reply

The title would be Fayzulla Xo'jayev, as in Uzbek, and there's no reason to transliterate it from Russian (?; WTF is russian doing here?). As we do not transliterate Turkish or Finnish names from Russian or Ukrainian, instead of writing them as they're written in Turkish or Finnish.--Abdullais4u 06:46, 19 February 2007 (UTC)Reply
It isn't transliterated from Russian - if it were it would be "Faizulla Khodzhayev". It's a simple latinised version which will be easily comprehensible to English-speakers, which is what we should always aim for in Wikipedia. The New Uzbek latin transcription is much too unfamiliar - no-one would realise what the apostrophe was supposed to indicate, or that "X" in Uzbek is pronounced "Kh" - it has a different sound in English. Sikandarji 08:47, 19 February 2007 (UTC)Reply

Nationality

edit

Although Faizullah Khojaev was founder of Uzbekistan but he was Tajik not Ozbek .National-Administrative Divisions: Establishment of the Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic of Tajikistan within Uzbekistan Farvartish (talk) 19:26, 3 June 2012 (UTC)Reply