Wikipedia

Ranga P. Dias

(Redirected from Ranga Dias (scientist))

Ranga P. Dias is a researcher and academic who specializes in condensed matter physics. He is an assistant professor in the departments of Mechanical Engineering and Physics and Astronomy at the University of Rochester (UR), and a scientist at the UR Laboratory for Laser Energetics.

Ranga P. Dias
Born
Sri Lanka
Alma materWashington State University
University of Colombo
Scientific career
FieldsSuperconductivity
InstitutionsUniversity of Rochester
Harvard University
ThesisPhase Transitions, Metallization, Superconductivity and Magnetic Ordering in Dense Carbon Disulfide and Chemical Analogs (2013)
Doctoral advisorChoong-shik Yoo
Websitelabsites.rochester.edu/dias

In 2020 and in 2023, his group published two papers claiming to have achieved room-temperature superconductivity, the first using carbonaceous sulfur hydride at extremely high pressure, and the second using nitrogen-doped lutetium hydride at near-ambient pressure. Both papers were later retracted after accusations of scientific misconduct, including data fabrication and manipulation.[1][2] Dias denied these charges, with an initial investigation by University of Rochester in 2020 reporting no evidence of misconduct.[3][4] However a later independent investigation performed by the American Physical Society did find such evidence,[5][6][7][8] and a March 2024 investigation by the University reported that Dias "engaged in research misconduct."[9]

As of 2024, Dias and his collaborator Ashkan Salamat at University of Nevada, Las Vegas have had five of their research papers retracted.[10][11]

Dias founded a company, Unearthly Materials, related to his research work, which was found to make misleading claims made about its funding and investors.[12]

Early life and education

edit

Ranga Prabashwara Dias was born into a middle-class family in Kottawa, Sri Lanka.[13][14][15][16] He is the eldest of three children, and has a younger brother and sister. He completed elementary school at the St. Joseph's Boys' College, Nugegoda, middle school at the President's College, Maharagama, and high school studies at the Royal College, Colombo.[16]

He received his B.S. in physics from the University of Colombo in 2006.[17] In 2013, he obtained his Ph.D. in physics from Washington State University, where he studied under Professor Choong-shik Yoo.[18] After his Ph.D., he was hired by Professor Isaac Silvera at the Department of Physics, Harvard University, to research metallic hydrogen.[19][13]

In January 2017, together with Silvera, Dias (then a postdoctoral fellow at Harvard University) reported the creation of solid metallic hydrogen using a diamond anvil cell.[20][21] This state of hydrogen was originally predicted by Eugene Wigner and Hillard Bell Huntington in 1935,[22] since which scientists have been trying make the substance. However, several physicists expressed skepticism about the result.[23]

Career

edit

In 2017, Dias became an assistant professor in both the Department of Mechanical Engineering and the Department of Physics and Astronomy at the University of Rochester.[24]

Dias's research focuses on properties of materials at extreme pressure and temperature conditions. These materials exhibit fundamental changes in their properties, potentially leading to the discovery of novel phenomena and exotic states of matter that do not exist under normal conditions. He is particularly interested in high-temperature superconductivity and quantum phase transitions of hydrogen and hydride materials.[25][26][27][28][29] His research utilizes a diamond anvil cell and lasers to achieve extreme pressure and temperatures in materials.[30]

In 2021, he was named as an innovation leader in the Time 100 Next list.[31][32]

Scientific misconduct investigations

edit

As of 2024, five of Dias's papers have been retracted, all with a small cohort of coauthors.[11]

Published peer-reviewed works

edit

Dias's research into room temperature superconductivity and metallic hydrogen has been the subject of controversy and scrutiny due to concerns regarding data availability, data analysis methods, and lack of reproducibility.[33][34][35][36][37]

In 2020, Dias published a paper in Nature describing room-temperature superconductivity in a carbonaceous sulfur hydride.[26][4] When asked about a potential Nobel Prize for this discovery, Dias said: "Yes, this has a potential for such high recognition, but I do not believe this will happen in the near future."[16] It was retracted by Nature in 2022. Condensed matter theorist Jorge E. Hirsch was the first to question peculiarities in the published data.[38][39] Marvin L. Cohen, National Medal of Science recipient and former president of the American Physical Society, was also an early voice pointing out problems with the carbonaceous sulfur hydride paper.[40]

After the paper was retracted, Dias and co-author Ashkan Salamat denied accusations of misconduct. Initial investigations by the University of Rochester found no evidence to support the accusations,[3][4] but in 2024 they found Dias had engaged in research misconduct.[9]

In 2022, James Hamlin, a physicist at the University of Florida, alleged that Dias may have copied data in a 2021 paper from an experiment on a different material in his 2013 Ph.D. thesis.[41] Coauthor Ashkan Salamat denied accusations of wrongdoing in an interview.[4] However, the journal Physical Review Letters subsequently added an 'expression of concern' to the paper, and is conducting an investigation.[37] Hamlin discovered the similarity between the figures while following up on his discovery that Dias had plagiarized part of that thesis from Hamlin's own Ph.D. thesis.[42]

In April 2023, a comment on another of Dias's papers in the journal ChemComm (which was said to be a partial replication of his CSH superconductivity results) was published.[43] The comment says that:

"with probability larger than 1–10−338 some of those data were not measured in a laboratory, contrary to what the papers claim. This finding undermines confidence in the claim that any of the experimental evidence reported in those papers reflects the properties of real physical samples of CSH."

On July 25, 2023, it was announced that a 2021 paper in Physical Review Letters (PRL) on which Dias was a co-author would be retracted due to suspected data fabrication. The journal commissioned an investigation by four independent referees and concluded that "The findings back up the allegations of data fabrication/falsification convincingly". Two of the referees reported on "a very disturbing picture of apparent data fabrication followed by an attempt to hide or coverup [sic] the fact. We urge immediate retraction of the paper".[5][6][7][8] The PRL retraction said that "Dias stands by the data in Fig. 1(b) and does not agree to retract the Letter".[44] He was the only author to do so, and all other authors agreed to the retraction. He responded that some errors in charts were unintentionally introduced in Adobe Illustrator by his colleagues. One of the reviewers hired by PRL to conduct an independent review said Dias's response was "both inadequate and disappointing", adding that Adobe Illustrator was never mentioned in the discussions among the authors, Hamlin, and PRL's editors that were provided to the reviewers. The University of Rochester spokesperson said the university "has a comprehensive investigation underway into the questions raised about the integrity of all data at issue in this and other studies".[45]

On September 26, 2023, The Wall Street Journal reported that the coauthors of the N-doped lutetium hydride Nature paper[29] were requesting a retraction, alleging Dias of misrepresenting data. He denied the allegation and said he did not agree to retract.[46] On November 7, 2023 Nature formally retracted the paper in question,[29][47] with the statement indicating that "... request of the authors Nathan Dasenbrock-Gammon, Elliot Snider, Raymond McBride, Hiranya Pasan, Dylan Durkee, Sachith E. Dissanayake, Keith V. Lawler and Ashkan Salamat." The retraction note states that the remaining authors "Nugzari Khalvashi-Sutter, Sasanka Munasinghe and Ranga P. Dias have not stated whether they agree or disagree with this retraction."[47]

Commenting in Physics World about Dias and the controversy surrounding his superconductivity work, physicist Lilia Boeri said his "inconsiderate behaviour has harmed the reputation of the field". James Hamlin said, "I do think the whole saga is damaging to science in general, and superconductivity research more so, and more broadly it's fuel for anti-science types."[48]

In 2024, a news report in Nature noted that " Dias is now infamous for the scandal that surrounds his work," that "many other research groups have tried and failed to replicate Dias’s superconductivity results," revealed that the University of Rochester had "launched a fourth investigation, led by experts external to the university [following which] Dias was stripped of his students and laboratories," and "the evidence raises questions about why the problems in Dias’s lab did not prompt stronger action, and sooner, by his collaborators, by Nature’s journal team and by his university."[49]

Unearthly Materials

edit

In 2020, Dias and Salamat formed a start up company called Unearthly Materials, intended to commercially exploit patents held by Dias and the University of Rochester related to Dias' alleged discoveries of high temperature superconductivity.[50]

In March 2023, a reporter for Quanta Magazine found a 2021 YouTube talk in which Dias claimed that Unearthly Materials had raised $20 million and listed investors that included the CEOs of OpenAI and Spotify. A representative for Dias then retracted the claims of both the funding and the investors, saying they were "aspirational".[3][51]

2013, Washington State University, Ph.D. thesis

edit

In April 2023, the journal Science reported at least 21% of Dias's 2013 doctoral thesis, supervised at Washington State University, had been identified as copied from uncredited sources, including the 2007 doctoral thesis of James Hamlin, at Washington University in St. Louis, in addition to parts of a 1999 paper of his PhD adviser, Choong-Shik Yoo.[52][6] Analysis of Dias's thesis by Lisa Rasmussen, a research ethicist at the University of North Carolina, Charlotte, also indicated plagiarism.[42]

References

edit
  1. ^ Garisto, Dan (March 9, 2023). "Allegations of Scientific Misconduct Mount as Physicist Makes His Biggest Claim Yet". Physics. 16: 40. Bibcode:2023PhyOJ..16...40G. doi:10.1103/Physics.16.40. S2CID 257615348. Retrieved March 24, 2023.
  2. ^ "Superconductor Now a Reality at Room Temperature -- But Not Room Pressure". Inside Science. October 14, 2020. Retrieved March 24, 2023.
  3. ^ a b c Magazine, Undark (March 27, 2023). "A Potential Triumph in Physics, Dogged by Accusation and Doubt". Undark Magazine. Retrieved April 3, 2023.
  4. ^ a b c d Bushwick, Sophie. "Controversy Surrounds Blockbuster Superconductivity Claim". Scientific American. Retrieved April 3, 2023.
  5. ^ a b Garisto, Dan (2023). "'A very disturbing picture': another retraction imminent for controversial physicist". Nature. 620 (7972): 14–16. Bibcode:2023Natur.620...14G. doi:10.1038/d41586-023-02401-2. PMID 37491414. S2CID 260162594. Retrieved July 26, 2023.
  6. ^ a b c Staff, CT (July 23, 2023). "University professor sees second paper retracted under accusations of data fabrication". Campus Times. Retrieved July 26, 2023.
  7. ^ a b Garisto, Dan. "Controversial Physicist Faces Mounting Accusations of Scientific Misconduct". Scientific American. Retrieved July 29, 2023.
  8. ^ a b Chang, Kenneth (July 26, 2023). "A Looming Retraction Casts a Shadow Over a Field of Physics". The New York Times. Retrieved July 29, 2023.
  9. ^ a b Subbaraman, Nidhi (March 20, 2024). "Superconductor Scientist Engaged in Research Misconduct, Probe Finds". Wall Street Journal.
  10. ^ Castelvecchi, Davide (November 7, 2023). "Nature retracts controversial superconductivity paper by embattled physicist". Nature. doi:10.1038/d41586-023-03398-4. ISSN 0028-0836. PMID 37935863.
  11. ^ a b "Retraction Watch Database". Retraction Watch. Crossref. Retrieved March 12, 2024.
  12. ^ Chant, Tim De (March 17, 2023). "Unearthly Materials claimed to have big-name investors, but they weren't all on board". TechCrunch. Retrieved March 24, 2023.
  13. ^ a b Bresnick, Sam. "Brain behind Metallic Hydrogen: Pressing on Pressure". Daily News. Retrieved April 3, 2023.
  14. ^ "Bio". scholar.harvard.edu. Retrieved April 3, 2023.
  15. ^ Subba, Sanghamitra (March 8, 2021). "UR Professor Ranga Dias has brought the world one step closer to hoverboards and magnetic levitation trains". Campus Times. Retrieved April 3, 2023.
  16. ^ a b c Kariyawasam, Dilshani (December 8, 2020). "Sri Lankan-lead team discovers world's first room-temperature superconductor". Colombo Gazette. Retrieved April 3, 2023.
  17. ^ "ORCID". orcid.org. Retrieved March 24, 2023.
  18. ^ Wolcott, R.J. (March 12, 2021). "WSU graduate recognized as Time100 Next innovator". WSU Insider. WSU News. Retrieved March 24, 2023.
  19. ^ "Harvard Scholar Bio". scholar.harvard.edu. Retrieved March 24, 2023.
  20. ^ "Advance in high-pressure physics". Harvard Gazette. January 26, 2017. Retrieved January 4, 2018.
  21. ^ Amos, Jonathan (2017). "Hydrogen 'wonder material' claim made". BBC News. Retrieved January 4, 2018.
  22. ^ Flores, Felipe. "The Discovery of Metallic Hydrogen – Harvard Science Review". harvardsciencereview.com. Retrieved March 4, 2019.
  23. ^ Castelvecchi, Davide (February 2, 2017). "Physicists doubt bold report of metallic hydrogen". Nature. 542 (7639): 17. Bibcode:2017Natur.542...17C. doi:10.1038/nature.2017.21379. PMID 28150796.
  24. ^ "New Faculty 2017–2018". www.rochester.edu. Retrieved April 3, 2023.
  25. ^ Silvera, Isaac F.; Dias, Ranga (January 1, 2021). "Phases of the hydrogen isotopes under pressure: metallic hydrogen". Advances in Physics: X. 6 (1): 1961607. Bibcode:2021AdPhX...661607S. doi:10.1080/23746149.2021.1961607. S2CID 238638324.
  26. ^ a b Snider, Elliot; Dasenbrock-Gammon, Nathan; McBride, Raymond; Debessai, Mathew; Vindana, Hiranya; Vencatasamy, Kevin; Lawler, Keith V.; Salamat, Ashkan; Dias, Ranga P. (October 15, 2020). "Room-temperature superconductivity in a carbonaceous sulfur hydride". Nature. 586 (7829): 373–377. Bibcode:2020Natur.586..373S. doi:10.1038/s41586-020-2801-z. OSTI 1673473. PMID 33057222. S2CID 222823227. (Retracted, see doi:10.1038/s41586-022-05294-9, PMID 36163290)
  27. ^ Dias, Ranga P.; Silvera, Isaac F. (February 17, 2017). "Observation of the Wigner-Huntington transition to metallic hydrogen". Science. 355 (6326): 715–718. arXiv:1610.01634. Bibcode:2017Sci...355..715D. doi:10.1126/science.aal1579. ISSN 0036-8075. PMID 28126728. S2CID 52851498.
  28. ^ Dias, Ranga P.; Noked, Ori; Silvera, Isaac F. (April 8, 2016). "New Phases and Dissociation-Recombination of Hydrogen Deuteride to 3.4 Mbar". Physical Review Letters. 116 (14): 145501. arXiv:1510.05686. Bibcode:2016PhRvL.116n5501D. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.116.145501. PMID 27104717. S2CID 115503.
  29. ^ a b c Dasenbrock-Gammon, Nathan; Snider, Elliot; McBride, Raymond; Pasan, Hiranya; Durkee, Dylan; Khalvashi-Sutter, Nugzari; Munasinghe, Sasanka; Dissanayake, Sachith E.; Lawler, Keith V.; Salamat, Ashkan; Dias, Ranga P. (March 1, 2023). "Evidence of near-ambient superconductivity in a N-doped lutetium hydride". Nature. 615 (7951): 244–250. Bibcode:2023Natur.615..244D. doi:10.1038/s41586-023-05742-0. ISSN 1476-4687. PMID 36890373. S2CID 257407449. (Retracted, see doi:10.1038/s41586-023-06774-2, PMID 37935926)
  30. ^ Dasenbrock-Gammon, Nathan; McBride, Raymond; Yoo, Gyeongjae; Dissanayake, Sachith; Dias, Ranga (September 1, 2022). "Second harmonic AC calorimetry technique within a diamond anvil cell". Review of Scientific Instruments. 93 (9): 093901. arXiv:2206.10072. Bibcode:2022RScI...93i3901D. doi:10.1063/5.0104705. ISSN 0034-6748. PMID 36182513. S2CID 249889303.
  31. ^ Wolcott, R. J. "WSU graduate recognized as Time100 Next innovator". WSU Insider. Retrieved April 3, 2023.
  32. ^ "2021 TIME100 Next: Ranga Dias". Time. February 17, 2021. Retrieved April 3, 2023.
  33. ^ van der Marel, Dirk; Hirsch, Jorge E. (January 19, 2022). "Comment on Nature 586, 373 (2020) by E. Snider et al". International Journal of Modern Physics B. 37 (4): 2375001. arXiv:2201.07686. doi:10.1142/S0217979223750012. ISSN 0217-9792. S2CID 252324362.
  34. ^ Bushwick, Sophie. "Controversy Surrounds Blockbuster Superconductivity Claim". Scientific American. Retrieved March 24, 2023.
  35. ^ "'Revolutionary' blue crystal resurrects hope of room temperature superconductivity". www.science.org. Retrieved March 24, 2023.
  36. ^ Wood, Charlie. "Room-Temperature Superconductor Discovery Meets With Resistance". Quanta Magazine. Retrieved November 10, 2023.
  37. ^ a b Garisto, Dan (March 9, 2023). "Allegations of Scientific Misconduct Mount as Physicist Makes His Biggest Claim Yet". Physics. 16: 40. Bibcode:2023PhyOJ..16...40G. doi:10.1103/Physics.16.40. S2CID 257615348.
  38. ^ Hirsch, Jorge E. (September 26, 2021). "On the ac magnetic susceptibility of a room temperature superconductor: anatomy of a probable scientific fraud". Physica C: Superconductivity and Its Applications. 613: 1354228. arXiv:2110.12854v1. doi:10.1016/j.physc.2023.1354228.
  39. ^ "Preprint server removes 'inflammatory' papers in superconductor controversy". www.science.org. Retrieved March 14, 2022.
  40. ^ Dogan, Mehmet; Cohen, Marvin (2021). "Anomalous behavior in high-pressure carbonaceous sulfur hydride". Physica C. 583 (15): 1353851. arXiv:2012.10771. Bibcode:2021PhyC..58353851D. doi:10.1016/j.physc.2021.1353851. S2CID 229340504.
  41. ^ Garisto, Dan (July 25, 2023). "'A very disturbing picture': another retraction imminent for controversial physicist". Nature. 620 (7972): 14–16. Bibcode:2023Natur.620...14G. doi:10.1038/d41586-023-02401-2. PMID 37491414. S2CID 260162594. Retrieved July 26, 2023.
  42. ^ a b "Plagiarism allegations pursue physicist behind stunning superconductivity claims". www.science.org. Retrieved April 13, 2023.
  43. ^ Hirsch, Jorge (April 21, 2023). "Comment on "Carbon content drives high temperature superconductivity in a carbonaceous sulfur hydride below 100 GPa" by G. A. Smith, I. E. Collings, E. Snider, D. Smith, S. Petitgirard, J. S. Smith, M. White, E. Jones, P. Ellison, K. V. Lawler, R. P. Dias and A. Salamat, Chem. Commun., 2022, 59, 5765–5770". Chemical Communications. 59 (38): 5765–5770. doi:10.1039/D2CC05277F. PMID 37083704.
  44. ^ Durkee, Dylan; Dasenbrock-Gammon, Nathan; Smith, G. Alexander; Snider, Elliot; Smith, Dean; Childs, Christian; Kimber, Simon A. J.; Lawler, Keith V.; Salamat, Ashkan (August 15, 2023). "Retraction: Colossal Density-Driven Resistance Response in the Negative Charge Transfer Insulator   [Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 016401 (2021)]". Physical Review Letters. 131 (7): 079902. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.131.079902. PMID 37656869.
  45. ^ Chang, Kenneth (August 15, 2023). "Superconductor Scientist Faces Investigation as a Paper Is Retracted". The New York Times. Retrieved November 10, 2023.
  46. ^ Subbaraman, Nidhi. "WSJ News Exclusive | Co-Authors Seek to Retract Paper Claiming Superconductor Breakthrough". WSJ. Retrieved September 27, 2023.
  47. ^ a b Dasenbrock-Gammon, Nathan; Snider, Elliot; McBride, Raymond; Pasan, Hiranya; Durkee, Dylan; Khalvashi-Sutter, Nugzari; Munasinghe, Sasanka; Dissanayake, Sachith E.; Lawler, Keith V.; Salamat, Ashkan; Dias, Ranga P. (November 7, 2023). "Retraction Note: Evidence of near-ambient superconductivity in a N-doped lutetium hydride". Nature. 624 (7991): 460. Bibcode:2023Natur.624..460D. doi:10.1038/s41586-023-06774-2. ISSN 1476-4687. PMID 37935926.
  48. ^ Banks, Michael (October 20, 2023). "Superconductivity 'damaged' as researchers look to move on from retractions". Physics World. IOP Publishing. Retrieved October 25, 2023.
  49. ^ Garisto, Dan (March 8, 2024). "Superconductivity scandal: the inside story of deception in a rising star's physics lab". Nature. doi:10.1038/d41586-024-00716-2. Retrieved March 18, 2024.
  50. ^ Marcotte, Bob. "Room temperature superconductor? Rochester lab sets new record toward long-sought goal". The University of Rochester. Retrieved August 4, 2023.
  51. ^ Staff, C. T. (July 23, 2023). "Professor faces second paper retraction due to alleged data manipulation". Campus Times. Retrieved October 4, 2023.
  52. ^ GARISTO, Daniel (April 13, 2023). "Plagiarism allegations pursue physicist behind stunning superconductivity claims - Evidence suggests much of Ranga Dias's thesis was copied from other sources". Science. Retrieved November 10, 2023.

See also

edit
edit
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Ranga_P._Dias&oldid=1247453080"