Judges 21 is the twenty-first (and final) chapter of the Book of Judges in the Old Testament or the Hebrew Bible.[1] According to Jewish tradition the book was attributed to the prophet Samuel,[2][3] but modern scholars view it as part of the Deuteronomistic History, which spans in the books of Deuteronomy to 2 Kings, attributed to nationalistic and devotedly Yahwistic writers during the time of the reformer Judean king Josiah in the 7th century BCE.[3][4] This chapter records the war between the tribe of Benjamin and the other eleven tribes of Israel,[5] belonging to a section comprising Judges 17 to 21.[6]

Judges 21
Ruth 1 →
The pages containing the Book of Judges in Leningrad Codex (1008 CE).
BookBook of Judges
Hebrew Bible partNevi'im
Order in the Hebrew part2
CategoryFormer Prophets
Christian Bible partOld Testament (Heptateuch)
Order in the Christian part7

Text

edit

This chapter was originally written in the Hebrew language. It is divided into 25 verses.

Textual witnesses

edit

Some early manuscripts containing the text of this chapter in Hebrew are of the Masoretic Text tradition, which includes the Codex Cairensis (895), Aleppo Codex (10th century), and Codex Leningradensis (1008).[7] Fragments containing parts of this chapter in Hebrew were found among the Dead Sea Scrolls including 4Q50 (4QJudgb; 30 BCE–68 CE) with extant verses 12–25.[8][9][10] [11]

Extant ancient manuscripts of a translation into Koine Greek known as the Septuagint (originally was made in the last few centuries BCE) include Codex Vaticanus (B;  B; 4th century) and Codex Alexandrinus (A;  A; 5th century).[12][a]

Analysis

edit

Double Introduction and Double Conclusion

edit

Chapters 17 to 21 contain the "Double Conclusion" of the Book of Judges and form a type of inclusio together with their counterpart, the "Double Introduction", in chapters 1 to 3:6 as in the following structure of the whole book:[6]

A. Foreign wars of subjugation with the ḥērem being applied (1:1–2:5)
B. Difficulties with foreign religious idols (2:6–3:6)
Main part: the "cycles" section (3:7–16:31)
B'. Difficulties with domestic religious idols (17:1–18:31)
A'. Domestic wars with the ḥērem being applied (19:1–21:25)

There are similar parallels between the double introduction and the double conclusion as the following:[14]

Introduction 1 (1:1–2:5) Conclusion 2 (19:1–21:25)
The Israelites asked the LORD, saying,
"Who will be the first to go up and fight for us against the Canaanites?"
The LORD answered, "Judah is to go…." (1:1–2)
The Israelites ... inquired of God ...
"Who of us shall go first to fight against the Benjaminites?"
The LORD replied, "Judah…." (20:18)
The story of how Othniel got his wife (1:11–15) The story of how the remainder of the Benjaminites got their wives (21:1–25)
The Benjaminites fail to drive out the Jebusites from Jebus (1:21) A Levite carefully avoiding the Jebusites in Jebus suffers terrible outrage in Gibeah of Benjamin (19:1–30)
Bochim: God's covenant; Israel's unlawful covenants with the Canaanites; Israel weeping before the angel (messenger) of YHWH (1:1–2) Bethel: the ark of the covenant of God; Israel weeps and fasts before the LORD (20:26–29)
Introduction 2 (2:6–3:6) Conclusion 1 (17:1–18:31)
The degeneration of the generations after the death of Joshua (2:6–19); God leaves certain nations "to test the Israelites to see whether they would obey the LORD's commands, which he had given… through Moses" (2:20–3:4) A mother dedicates silver to the Lord for her son to make an idol; That son makes one of his own sons a priest in his idolatrous shrine, then replaces him with a Levite. That Levite is Moses' grandson. He and his sons become priests at Dan's shrine

The entire double conclusion is connected by the four-time repetition of a unique statement: twice in full at the beginning and the end of the double conclusion and twice in the center of the section as follows:[15][16]

A. In those days there was no king…
Every man did what right in his own eyes (17:6)
B. In those days there was no king… (18:1)
B'. In those days there was no king… (19:1)
A'. In those days there was no king…
Every man did what right in his own eyes (21:25)

It also contains internal links:[17]

Conclusion 1 (17:1–18:31): A Levite in Judah moving to the hill country of Ephraim and then on to Dan.
Conclusion 2 (19:1–21:25): A Levite in Ephraim looking for his concubine in Bethlehem in Judah.

Both sections end with a reference to Shiloh.[17]

The Bethlehem Trilogy

edit

Three sections of the Hebrew Bible (Old Testament) — Judges 1718, Judges 19–21, Ruth 14 — form a trilogy with a link to the city Bethlehem of Judah and characterized by the repetitive unique statement:[18]

"In those days there was no king in Israel; everyone did what was right in his own eyes"
(Judges 17:6; 18:1; 19:1; 21:25; cf. Ruth 1:1)

as in the following chart:[19]

Judges 17–18 Judges 19–20 Ruth 1–4
A Levite of Bethlehem (17:7) A Levite of Ephraim who took as his maiden a concubine from Bethlehem A movement from a Moabite to David in Bethlehem (4:17-22)
Left to seek employment (17:7, 9) Received his concubine from Bethlehem to which she had fled A man left Bethlehem, but unlike the other two stories does not ultimately deface the town, but enhances its name
Came to a young man of Ephraim (Micah) (17:1-5, 8) Returned to Ephraim by way of Gibeah of Benjamin Bethlehem became the subtle setting for the birthplace of King David
Served as a private chaplain in Micah's illicit chapel (17:10-13) Set upon by evil men who brutalized her and left her for dead
Hired by the tribe of Dan as a priest and relocated in Laish (N. Galilee) Her husband related the event to all of Israel (cut up)
Established a cult center which continually caused God's people to stumble They attacked the tribe of Benjamin almost annihilating it
The Levite was Jonathan the son of Gershom and the grandson of Moses (18:30) Repopulated Benjamin with women from Shiloh and Jabesh Gilead for the 600 surviving men of Benjamin
Jabesh-Gilead was (probably) the home of Saul's ancestors [thus his interest in it]
Reflects badly on Benjamin and by implication Saul—Saul's ancestors humiliated and disgraced a Bethlehemite
Bethlehem suffered at the hands of Benjaminites

Chapters 19 to 21

edit

The section comprising Judges 19:1-21:25 has a chiastic structure of five episodes as follows:[20][21]

A. The Rape of the Concubine (19:1–30)
B. ḥērem ("holy war") of Benjamin (20:1–48)
C. Problem: The Oaths-Benjamin Threatened with Extinction (21:1–5)
B'. ḥērem ("holy war") of Jabesh Gilead (21:6–14)
A'. The Rape of the Daughters of Shiloh (21:15–25)

In particular, chapter 21 records how the Benjaminites were reintegrated into the pan-Israelite community, after they were nearly wiped out in the civil war except for the 600 men who hid in the Rock of Rimmon (last chapter). Paradoxically, the process requires another massacre against fellow Israelites and another violence of women.[22] The rape of the daughters of Shiloh is the ironic counterpoint to the rape of the Levite's concubine, with the "daughter" motif linking the two stories (Judges 19:24 and Judges 21:21),[21] and the women becoming 'doorways leading into and out of war, sources of contention and reconciliation'.[5]

The structure of chapter 21 is as follows:[23]

  • The problem (21:1–4)
  • An apparent solution (21:5–12)
  • A further problem (21:13–18)
  • The outcome (21:19–24)
  • Closing refrain (21:25)

A new problem and an apparent solution (21:1–14)

edit

The war had just ended when a fresh complication appeared because the Israelites made an ill-considered oath in Mizpah (21:1; cf. 20:1) that they would not voluntarily give their daughter to the Benjaminites.[23] During the war all the Benjaminite women have been slaughtered (20:47-48; 21:16) and because of the oath the six hundred male survivors must die childless, raising an obstacle to restore the brotherhood (21:6; cf. 20:23, 28).[23] When the people's call to YHWH went unanswered (after they tried to put the blame on YHWH;21:3), they took actions that led to an added excessive slaughter.[23] A search indicates that the inhabitants of Jabesh-gilead did not join the Israelites at Mizpah and the war, so hērem (holy war or "ban") was applied to that city, but with a purpose to capture their virgin women while killing the rest of the people (cf. Numbers 31), to supply brides for the surviving Benjaminites.[24][25] However, only 400 virgins were available, thus not enough for the 600 men of Benjamin (verses 12, 14).[24][25]

Verse 3

edit
And they said,
"O LORD, the God of Israel,
why has this happened in Israel,
that today there should be one tribe lacking in Israel?"[26]

The threefold reference to "Israel" after calling YHWH ("LORD") indicates an 'oblique form of protest' to imply that this situation was God's responsibility, but God would not be drawn into it, so God remained silent.[27]

The rape of the daughters of Shiloh (21:15–25)

edit
 
Presumed location and remains of the Tabernacle in ancient Shiloh, viewed from the Seer's Tower, Tel Shiloh. 2019

When the earlier solution did not adequately solve the problem (200 Benjaminite men were still without brides), another morally questionable plan was hatched. Still affected with the curse of the oath they have placed for whoever willingly help Benjamin as a tribe to survive (verse 18), the Israelites provided the Benjaminites an opportunity to 'engage in wife-stealing' of the young Israel virgins during their annual pilgrimage to Shiloh, linked to the story of Jephthah's daughter (Judges 11).[24]

Verse 21

edit
and watch; and just when the daughters of Shiloh come out to perform their dances, then come out from the vineyards, and every man catch a wife for himself from the daughters of Shiloh; then go to the land of Benjamin.[28]

Verse 25

edit
In those days there was no king in Israel: every man did that which was right in his own eyes.[30]

This final occurrence of the refrain links the two parts of the coda (chapters 1718 and 19–21) together.[23] It could be seen as the final verdict of the book that the institution of judges is politically unsatisfactory, thus points forward to the Books of Samuel in which Samuel, as the last judge, anoints Saul to become the first king of Israel.[31]

See also

edit
  • Related Bible parts: Judges 3, Judges 19, Judges 20
  • Notes

    edit
    1. ^ The whole book of Judges is missing from the extant Codex Sinaiticus.[13]

    References

    edit
    1. ^ Halley 1965, p. 173.
    2. ^ Talmud, Baba Bathra 14b-15a)
    3. ^ a b Gilad, Elon. Who Really Wrote the Biblical Books of Kings and the Prophets? Haaretz, June 25, 2015. Summary: The paean to King Josiah and exalted descriptions of the ancient Israelite empires beg the thought that he and his scribes lie behind the Deuteronomistic History.
    4. ^ Niditch 2007, p. 177.
    5. ^ a b Niditch 2007, p. 189.
    6. ^ a b Younger 2002, pp. 30–31.
    7. ^ Würthwein 1995, pp. 35–37.
    8. ^ Ulrich 2010, pp. 257–258.
    9. ^ Dead sea scrolls - Judges
    10. ^ Fitzmyer 2008, p. 35.
    11. ^ 4Q50 at the Leon Levy Dead Sea Scrolls Digital Library
    12. ^ Würthwein 1995, pp. 73–74.
    13. ^   This article incorporates text from a publication now in the public domainHerbermann, Charles, ed. (1913). "Codex Sinaiticus". Catholic Encyclopedia. New York: Robert Appleton Company.
    14. ^ Gooding, D. W., "The Composition of the Book of Judges," in Orlinsky, H. M., Memorial Volume (Eretz Israel 16; Jerusalem: Israel Exploration Society, 1982), pp. 70–79, especially pp. 76–78; apud Younger 2002, pp. 32–33
    15. ^ Younger 2002, p. 31.
    16. ^ Webb 2012, p. 419.
    17. ^ a b Younger 2002, p. 33.
    18. ^ "Introduction to the Book of Judges". Bible.org
    19. ^ Merrill, Eugene H. (1985) "The Book of Ruth: Narration and Shared Themes", Bibliotheca Sacra 142:130-141.
    20. ^ Webb, "The Book of the Judges", p. 196; apud Younger 2002, p. 147.
    21. ^ a b Webb 2012, p. 507.
    22. ^ Niditch 2007, p. 190.
    23. ^ a b c d e Webb 2012, p. 495.
    24. ^ a b c Niditch 2007, p. 191.
    25. ^ a b Coogan 2007, p. 389 Hebrew Bible.
    26. ^ Judges 21:3 ESV
    27. ^ Webb 2012, p. 496.
    28. ^ Judges 21:21 NKJV
    29. ^ Judges 21:21 Hebrew Text Analysis. Biblehub
    30. ^ Judges 21:25 KJV
    31. ^ Coogan 2007, p. 390 Hebrew Bible.

    Sources

    edit
    edit