Wikipedia

Salient (magazine)

(Redirected from Critical Critic)

Salient is the weekly students' magazine of the Victoria University of Wellington Students' Association (VUWSA) at Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand. Salient was established in 1938[2] and originally published in newspaper format, but is now published as a magazine. Salient's style and editorial position can change from year to year due to changes in editors. However, the magazine has generally taken a left-wing stance.

Salient
The cover of Salient magazine 11 April 2005, designed by Dave Batt
The cover of Salient magazine 11 April 2005
Current EditorsPhoebe Robertson
Current News TeamWill Irvine and Ethan Rogacion (News Editors) Dan Moskovitz (Chief Reporter)
Current Designer/IllustratorKate Seager
Current Writing StaffHenry Broadbent (Sub-Editor)

Te Huihui Tran and Ashleigh Putt-fallows (Te Ao Māori Co-Editors) Jia Sharma and Mauatua Fa'ara-Reynolds (Staff Writers)

Jamie Clumpas and Guy van Egmond (Contributing Writers)
Current Digital TeamTyrone O'Neill (Speaker of the House)
FrequencyWeekly (during non-summer trimesters), resulting in 25 issues annually.
Circulation16,000[1]
Founded1938
CompanyVictoria University of Wellington Students' Association
Based inWellington, New Zealand
LanguageEnglish and Te Reo Māori
Websitesalient.org.nz
OCLC227003028

Organisation

edit

Origins

edit

The student magazine of Victoria University of Wellington has been published under a number of different titles since the early twentieth century: Spike (1902–1964), Smad (1930–1937), and finally Salient (1938–present).[3]

Salient was originally published in newspaper format, but is now published as a print magazine and online

Editor

edit

The Salient editor-in-chief is an employee of VUWSA operating under a charter that grants editorial independence. The editor is appointed and employed under a fixed term contract that covers roughly the beginning to end of the academic year. Previous involvement with the magazine is not a prerequisite for applicants, although most have had some role at Salient prior to their editorship. At various times in Salient's history, and consistently since 2011, the editorship has been shared between two people.

Notable past editors include former Prime Minister Geoffrey Palmer, editor of Metro magazine Simon Wilson, independent publisher Roger Steele (NZOM),[4] Queen's Counsel Hugh Rennie, independent investigative writers such as David Harcourt[5] and New Zealand Listener writer Toby Manhire.[6]

Former editors

edit
  • 2024 — Phoebe Robertson
  • 2023 — Francesca Pietkiewicz and Maia Ingoe
  • 2022 — Janhavi Gosavi
  • 2021 — Sally Ward and Matthew Casey
  • 2020 — Kirsty Frame and Rachel Trow
  • 2019 — Kii Small and Taylor Galmiche
  • 2018 — Louise Lin
  • 2017 — Tuioleloto Laura Toailoa and Tim Manktelow
  • 2016 — Emma Hurley and Jayne Mulligan
  • 2015 — Sam McChesney
  • 2014 — Cam Price and Duncan McLachlan[7]
  • 2013 — Molly McCarthy and Stella Blake-Kelly
  • 2012 — Ollie Neas and Asher Emanuel
  • 2011 — Uther Dean and Elle Hunt
  • 2010 — Sarah Robson
  • 2009 — Jackson James Wood
  • 2008 — Tristan Egarr
  • 2007 — Steve Nicoll
  • 2006 — James Robinson
  • 2005 — Emily Braunstein
  • 2004 — Sarah Barnett
  • 2003 — Michael Appleton
  • 2002 — Max Rashbrooke
  • 2001 — Nikki Burrows
  • 2000 — Nikki Burrows
  • 1999 — Mike Beggs
  • 1998 — Jonathan Hill
  • 1997 — Toby Manhire
  • 1996 — James Palmer
  • 1995 — Vic Waghorn
  • 1994 — Andrew Chick
  • 1993 — Tony Smith
  • 1992 — Cathie Sheat
  • 1991 — Carl Dawson
  • 1990 — Barbara Duke
  • 1989 — Belinda Howard
  • 1988 — Bernie Steeds
  • 1987 — Grant O'Neill
  • 1986 — Richard Adams
  • 1985 — Jane Hurley
  • 1984 — Sally Zwartz
  • 1983 — Mark Cubey
  • 1982 — Mark Wilson
  • 1981 — Stephen A'Court
  • 1980 — Stephen A'Court
  • 1979 — Peter Beach
  • 1978 — Simon Wilson
  • 1977 — David Murray
  • 1976 — John Ryall
  • 1975 — Antony Ward, Mark Derby, Bruce Robinson
  • 1974 — Roger Steele
  • 1973 — Peter Franks, Roger Steele
  • 1972 — Gil Peterson
  • 1971 — Roger Cruickshank, George Rosenberg
  • 1970 — David Harcourt
  • 1969 — Roger Wilde
  • 1968 — Bill Logan
  • 1967 — Gerard Curry, Barrie Saunders
  • 1966 — Hugh Rennie
  • 1965 — Hugh Rennie, John Llewellyn
  • 1964 — Bill Alexander, David Wright, Anthony Haas
  • 1963 — Geoffrey Palmer, Ian Grant, Robin Bromby
  • 1962 — Murray White
  • 1961 — Baldwin March
  • 1960 — Ian Grant
  • 1959 — Colin Bickler
  • 1958 — Terry Kelliher
  • 1957 — Conrad Bollinger, Antony Wood
  • 1956 — Nick Turner
  • 1955 — Brian Shaw
  • 1954 — Dan Donovan
  • 1953 — Trevor Hill
  • 1952 — Trevor Hill
  • 1951 — Bill Cameron, Maurice McIntyre
  • 1950 — Denny Garrett
  • 1949 — Peter Jenkins, Denny Garrett
  • 1948 — Bill Cameron, Jean Melling, Alec McLeod
  • 1947 — Alec McLeod
  • 1946 — Bruce Milburn, Lyster Paul, Bill Cameron
  • 1945 — W.K.T. (Kemp) Fowler
  • 1944 — W.K.T. (Kemp) Fowler
  • 1943 — Cecil Crompton
  • 1942 — George Turner, Cecil Crompton
  • 1941 — Shirley Grinlinton
  • 1940 — Maurice Boyd
  • 1939 — Derek Freeman
  • 1938 — A.H. (Bonk) Scotney

News

edit

Salient news is predominately focused on student issues, the students' association, and the university itself. However, Salient has also reported on national and international items outside of "student" issues. For instance there was significant coverage of the Iraq invasion in 2003.

Previous news editors

  • Will Irvine and Ethan Rogacion (2024)
  • Zoë Mills and Ethan Manera (2023)
  • Beth Mountford and Azaria Howell (2022)
  • Sophie Boot (2014)
  • Chris McIntyre (2013)
  • Stella Blake-Kelly and Hugo McKinnon (2011)
  • Molly McCarthy (2010)
  • Michael Oliver (2009)
  • Seonah Choi (2008)
  • Laura McQuillan (2007)
  • Nicola Kean (2006)
  • Keith Ng (2004–2005)

Salient is a member of the Aotearoa Student Press Association (ASPA), which has intermittently had a press gallery journalist in the New Zealand House of Representatives. The current press gallery representative is Annabel McCarthy.[8][non-primary source needed]

Design

edit
 
Salient's retired 2013 logo

Salient employs a full-time designer who is responsible for the look of the magazine. Because the designer is typically employed for only a one-year term, the visual aesthetic of the magazine can change significantly from year to year.

Former designers

edit
  • 2023 — Bella Maresca
  • 2022 — Alice Brown
  • 2021 — Padraig Simpson
  • 2020 — Rowena Chow
  • 2019 — Rachel Salazar
  • 2018 — Ruby Ash
  • 2017 — Eun Sun Jeong and Ellyse Randrup
  • 2016 — Ella Bates-Hermans
  • 2015 — Sam McChesney
  • 2014 — Imogen Temm
  • 2013 — Laura Burns
  • 2009 — Rory Harnden
  • 2008 — Tony Barnao
  • 2007 — Grant Buist
  • 2006 — Dave Batt

Comics

edit

Salient has been a home to a number of comics and cartoons, and they traditionally have their place on the last page of the magazine. Past comics such as ASCII and Grant Buist's Brunswick have won critical awards, with ASCII winning an Aotearoa Student Press Association (ASPA) award in 2005.[9][10] Previous comics have included Being Blind,[11] Man, ASCII (originally published in Waikato University's Nexus' magazine'),[9] Newtown Ghetto Anger,[12] The Chronicle, Drunk Duck,[13] Uni Life, Super Academic Friends,[14] The Academic Idol Comic, and G33K by Sparx.[15]

Website

edit

As well as publishing in print, Salient operates a frequently updated website. In 2013, the Salient website was redeveloped, and won the award for best website at the ASPAs.[16] Salient publishes an email newsletter called 'Sincerely Salient', including news round-ups, local events, and feature highlights.[17]

In late 2019, Salient's archives were controversially removed from public view after a website upgrade, resulting in the creation of an independent 'Salient Archive' website, which restored public access to 9,879 of the hidden articles.[18]

Video

edit

Salient had a video production arm called 'Salient TV', the only department dedicated to video content from any student media publication in New Zealand. Salient TV videos include interviews, comedy sketches, and other miscellaneous content that focuses on student interests.[19] Salient TV videos were primarily found on the magazine's Facebook page. Salient TV disbanded in 2019, to widespread disappointment.

Radio station

edit

Salient FM
Frequency88.3 FM
Programming
FormatStudent radio
History
First air date
2007

Salient FM, known as VBC until 2015, was a non-profit station which operated at Victoria University of Wellington from 2007 to 2019.[20] It took the place of Radio Active as the university's campus-based and student-oriented radio station. It was funded by the university and VUWSA through the budget allocated for Salient, and also had advertisers and sponsors.[21]

In October 2013, VUWSA held a referendum asking whether it should cease funding the station from 2014 after a student moved a motion requesting a referendum at VUWSA's AGM.[22] Out of the 2,105 votes cast on the question, 61 percent favoured continuing to fund the VBC.[23]

As of May 2014, VUWSA President Sonya Clark had been made a trustee of the defunct VBC Trust in order to wind it down, so that VUWSA could take control of the station. The Trust owed IRD about $3,000 in unpaid tax, which Clark said VUWSA intended to pay. The 2014 Salient editors expressed an interest in transforming the VBC into "Salient Radio".[24] In 2015, the station was rebranded Salient FM.

Salient FM had a diverse programme targeted at Victoria University of Wellington students. Genres of alternative, electronic, and hip-hop music were most commonly broadcast. The station also heavily encouraged Wellingtonian and New Zealand musical acts. The station also hosted a number of politics and current affairs focused shows, notably the Young Matt Show and Bandwagon Radio. These programmes discussed important political issues and policies, particularly those most relevant to VUW students.

In December 2019, Salient FM was shut down following a decision from the VUWSA CEO Matthew Tucker. Full reasoning behind the Salient FMs discontinuation was not made public. In response to this, an Official Investigation Act request was filed to investigate if cutting the station was unconstitutional. Salient FM's two editors Jazz Kane and Nav Nair commented "We're pretty confident that it is entirely unconstitutional".[25]

Podcasts

edit

After the cessation of Salient FM, Salient created Salient Podcasts.

ASPA Awards

edit

Salient has participated in the ASPA Student Media Awards since their inception in 2003. The magazine dominated the first two years of the awards winning amongst other categories Best Publication in 2003 and 2004. Otago's Critic is generally seen as Salient's strongest competition and in 2005 turned the tables, sweeping a number of categories including Best Publication with Salient coming second. Critic won Best Publication again in 2006 and Salient came second.

In 2009, Salient won the award for Best Publication. Salient dominated these awards with five first places and eight other placings.[26] In 2011, Salient also won best publication. However, in 2010, 2012 and 2013 Salient was runner-up in best publication to Critic.

In 2022, Salient won awards for Best Cover, Best Sports Writing, Best Personal Essay, Best Online Presence, Best Centrefold, Best Student Politics Coverage (tied) and Best Editorial (tied).

Views

edit

Due to Salient's changing editorial position (each editor typically holding the position for a one-year period), views expressed in the magazine have been varying throughout history. In general, Salient has taken a left-wing approach to politics.

Maoism (1964-1981)

edit

In this period, many of the editors and contributors to Salient were members of the Wellington Marxist-Leninist Organisation (MILO), a Maoist-aligned group with substantial student membership at the time. Consequently, much of the content published in this period was politically charged and Maoist-leaning.[27][28]

Te Ao Mārama (1973-1974, and 1997-present)

edit

Te Ao Mārama is an issue of Salient focused on Māori issues. Young political groups Ngā Tamatoa and the Te Reo Māori Society influenced the first publication of Te Ao Mārama in 1973 during Māori Language Week, under editor Roger Steele in 1973, in an attempt to support te reo Māori on campus. According to Max Nichol, "Steele credits the Te Reo Māori Society with the idea, and Ngā Tamatoa with putting the issue of revitalising te reo on the agenda in the first place."[28] Unfortunately, Steele’s editing successors did not continue this mahi to the same degree; "it was not until 1997 that Te Ao Mārama was enshrined in VUWSA’s constitution, obliging Salient to produce a Māori language issue annually."[28]

Presently, Te Ao Mārama is a cherished tradition that allows a voice to Māori voices and issues within the university community. In 2022, Te Ao Mārama was published for the first time entirely in both English and te reo. This was under editor Janhavi Gosavi, and the issue was guest edited by Areta Pakinga.[29]

Women's rights

edit

In the 1980s, Salient began to gave more space to issues of women's rights. Notably in this time, Sally Zwartz became the second women editor in 1984, the only women to edit previously being Shirley Grinlington in 1941, of who it is speculated to "perhaps [have] gained her position due to the dip in the number of male students during World War Two."[28]

Gay and lesbian liberation

edit

Notable History

edit

1985 Defamement allegations and sexual harassment policy

edit

1985 editor Jane Hurley faced a legal threat from the university's History Department after she had co-edited the VUWSA Student Handbook, which "provided course critiques so that students could assess for themselves which courses and programmes of study might appeal to them."[28] The handbook noted that a professor in the department was known for “sexual harassment," causing the department to threaten a defamation suit against the editors and demand retraction. In the first issue of Salient in 1985, Hurley attempted to appease the department by writing that the claims of "sexual harassment" may have suggested a higher level of severity, and clarified the misconduct to be "milder" forms of harassment such as "unwanted comments, the innuendo, the disparagement of women simply because they are women."[28]

Hurley's reporting was partly responsible for pushing Victoria University to enforce a sexual harassment policy in 1986, and work to give students support around the issue.[28]

1995 Waghorn affair

edit

In 1995, there was controversy surrounding the editor Vic Waghorn, such that a Special General Meeting of VUWSA was called in June to dismiss her from the role. The motion to dismiss Waghorn at the meeting was soundly defeated 250 to 3, but it was not the end of the matter. Personal grievances and accusations she had misappropriated funds led to her being suspended in September by the VUWSA Executive. In response, Waghorn managed to change the cover of the final issue of Salient "to a cartoon depiction of cunnilingus captioned 'suck it hard'". Most of the covers were removed before release however.[30]

The affair led to a change to the VUWSA constitution so that it would be harder to dismiss a Salient editor in the future.[30]

2005 Fee rise leak and court injunction

edit

In September 2005, the Vice-Chancellor of Victoria University obtained a court injunction to prevent an issue of Salient from being distributed[31][32] – thought to be the first time in the magazine's history this has happened. The issue of Salient contained information obtained from leaked University Council documents with details about possible university fee increases of 5 to 10 percent. The controversy made national media, with several items on the television news. The university failed to realise that information was put on to the ASPA newswire, hence the information was published in several other student magazines and on the internet. Distribution of Salient was eventually allowed, four days late after Salient and the university reached an out-of-court settlement. The documents were returned to the university, reportedly with pictures of male genitalia drawn over them.[33]

2006 Listing of Chinese people as a species to be wary of

edit

In April 2006, Salient published a short piece which put Han Chinese people, along with animals like poisonous snakes and penguins, in a list of "top five species we should be wary of". The supposed "joke" upset the Chinese community and caused huge protests from both Chinese students and the Chinese Embassy. Accused of being blatantly racist, editor James Robinson apologised, saying "It was a ridiculous jab that was honestly so stupid I didn't even think twice about it." However, he argued people who were offended had misinterpreted it: "We put 'the Chinese' between 'penguins' and 'very poisonous snakes' on the list, and people somehow took it seriously." He also defended his right to publish it, saying "It's not hate speech or inciting violence against the Chinese race. It would be a dangerous precedent to come out and say, 'Sorry, we were totally out of our minds to print such a thing'."[34] Many questioned Robinson's credentials in defining what is and is not an appropriate reaction to racism. Nick Kelly, 2006 Students' Association President, posted an apology calling the article "xenophobic and inappropriate ... in poor taste".[35]

2008 Naked Hu Jintao cover

edit

In May 2008, Salient published a feature article concerning the rise of China as a new world superpower. To promote this article the cover that week depicted a naked, yet to be identified, Salient staffer draped in a Chinese flag, with Hu Jintao's face photoshopped onto their own. The cover invoked a strong reaction from the Wellington Chinese community, with students removing the magazine from distribution at the university's Karori Campus. Following this disruption, the Chinese Students' Association of Victoria University presented a petition of 133 signatures calling for an apology. To date, Salient has not apologised.[36]

2009 Lundy 500

edit
See also: Lundy murders

In July 2009, Salient editor Jackson Wood courted controversy by announcing the "Lundy 500", an event whereby "teams of vehicles ... [would] travel from Petone to Palmerston North as convicted double murderer Mark Lundy did in 2000, before murdering wife Christine and daughter Amber, according to the prosecution at his 2002 trial." Participants were tasked with doing the trip in 68 minutes or less, the same time Lundy is argued to have driven the distance. Wood argued that the "event was designed to draw attention to some of the inconsistencies in the New Zealand legal system", and emphasised that he wasn't encouraging anyone to break the law.[37] However, the proposed event was harshly criticised in the media,[38][39] and on 2 August, it was announced that the event was to be cancelled. Wood apologised to the Lundy family and wrote that: "He acknowledged that their viewpoints were not adequately taken into account before the event was announced on Friday, and that there were other ways for this point to be communicated".[40]

A similar re-enactment of the travel involved in the Lundy case, dubbed the "Lundy Three Hundy" was proposed in 2013 by Nic Miller. It was likewise criticised in the media, with Mathew Grocott writing that "this event should not go ahead and if those involved have any human decency then it won't go ahead."[41]

See also

edit

References

edit
  1. ^ "Advertising". Salient.org.nz. Retrieved 5 October 2013.
  2. ^ "History of VUWSA". Victoria University of Wellington Students' Association. Archived from the original on 11 March 2008.
  3. ^ Hamilton, Stephen (2002). A Radical Tradition: A History of the Victoria University of Wellington Students' Association. Wellington: Steele Roberts Publishers and VUWSA. p. 225. ISBN 1-877228-72-9.
  4. ^ NZ Order of Merit for Roger Steele https://www.nzherald.co.nz/kapiti-news/news/new-year-honours-publisher-roger-steele-becomes-officer-of-new-zealand-order-of-merit/7B4OYLIXC776HITH7LYZPZSZUY/
  5. ^ Everyone wants to be Fuhrer
  6. ^ Du Fresne, Karl (11 February 2012). "Salient magazine breeds ruling elite". The Dominion Post. Retrieved 26 February 2014.
  7. ^ Stella Blake-Kelly; Molly McCarthy (23 September 2013). "Editorial – Victoria University". Salient.org.nz. Retrieved 7 October 2013.
  8. ^ "Annabel McCarthy (@annabelrmc) | Twitter". twitter.com. Retrieved 4 December 2019.
  9. ^ a b ASCII
  10. ^ Brunswick
  11. ^ Being Blind Archived 15 July 2011 at the Wayback Machine
  12. ^ Newtown Ghetto Anger
  13. ^ Tip Of The Iceberg Archived 15 October 2007 at the Wayback Machine
  14. ^ Super Academic Friends Archived 25 April 2012 at the Wayback Machine
  15. ^ G33K Archived 24 October 2010 at the Wayback Machine
  16. ^ "Excellence in student media recognised". Voxy.co.nz. 6 October 2013. Retrieved 7 October 2013.
  17. ^ @salientmagazine (18 November 2019). "hi hello you can help the Sincerely Salient Newsletter: Super Summer Sizzler Edition fly straight into the media-empire sun Icarus-style by signing up at the link below http://eepurl.com/gwuzez https://twitter.com/lillydancyger/status/1195885251203141632 …" (Tweet) – via Twitter.
  18. ^ Barratt, Robert. "wtf happened?". salientarchive.com. Retrieved 28 July 2021.
  19. ^ "Salient TV — Salient". Retrieved 4 December 2019.
  20. ^ Wellington City Council, Community Directory, The VBC 88.3FM Archived 20 October 2014 at the Wayback Machine
  21. ^ "History of VUWSA". VUWSA. 2014. Archived from the original on 19 August 2014. Retrieved 14 October 2014.
  22. ^ "VUWSA Referendum 2013". Salient. 23 September 2013. Retrieved 3 December 2013.
  23. ^ Boot, Sophie (7 October 2013). "VUWSA Suffers Electile Dysfunction". Salient Magazine. Retrieved 3 December 2013.
  24. ^ Hurley, Emma (May 2014). "For VBC TBC". Salient magazine. Wellington. Retrieved 15 April 2015.
  25. ^ Blackwell, Finn (2019). "Salient FM still fighting". Salient Magazine. Retrieved 23 April 2020.
  26. ^ "Salient wins best publication", Salient Magazine 2009. Retrieved 14 September 2008.
  27. ^ "Shades of Red: Maoism and Radical Politics in 1970s Salient". Salient Magazine. Retrieved 20 March 2023.
  28. ^ a b c d e f g Max Nichol (2019). An ‘Organ of Student Opinion’? Alternative Print, Protest, and the Politics of Education in Salient, 1973-1989 (Master's thesis). Victoria University of Wellington. doi:10.26686/wgtn.17141930.v1.
  29. ^ "Issue 20 - Te Ao Mārama by Salient - Issuu". issuu.com. Retrieved 20 March 2023.
  30. ^ a b Fowler, Nina (23 March 2009). "Salient Loves VUWSA". Salient magazine. Wellington. Retrieved 19 August 2014.
  31. ^ Ng, Keith (3 October 2005). "We interrupt your regular programming..." Public Address. Retrieved 8 October 2013.
  32. ^ "University wins court bid to stop student magazine publishing". New Zealand Herald. NZPA. 3 October 2005. Retrieved 26 February 2014.
  33. ^ McCarthy, Molly (18 March 2013). "A Salient Birthday". Salient.org.nz. Retrieved 8 October 2013.
  34. ^ Cheng, Derek (13 May 2006). "Joke about Chinese backfires on university". The New Zealand Herald. Retrieved 8 October 2013.
  35. ^ Cheng, Derek. "Joke about Chinese backfires on university". NZ Herald.
  36. ^ Choi, Seonah (7 July 2008). "Chinese students angry about naked president". Salient. Retrieved 8 October 2013.
  37. ^ "Something big has arrived: Salient announces Lundy 500". Salient.org.nz. 31 July 2009. Retrieved 7 October 2013.
  38. ^ "Students call off Lundy 500". NZherald.co.nz. 2 August 2009. Retrieved 7 October 2013.
  39. ^ "'Lundy 500' not welcome here – Mayor". Manawatu Standard. Fairfax media. 1 August 2009. Retrieved 7 October 2013.
  40. ^ "Lundy 500 cancelled". Salient.org.nz. 2 August 2009. Retrieved 7 October 2013.
  41. ^ Grocott, Mathew (21 October 2013). "Grow up Nic Miller – if you can". Manawatu Standard. Retrieved 22 August 2014.
edit
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Salient_(magazine)&oldid=1235797082"