Tourist tax

(Redirected from Bed tax)

A tourist tax is any form of tax aimed at generating revenue from tourists or the tourism industry.

Tourist taxes are generally a way for governments to generate revenue for the consolidated fund but can also be a hypothecated levy used to address the impacts of tourism.[1]

The tax can be used to mitigate the increased demand on infrastructure and public services, to address the environmental and sustainable impact of tourism and to ensure an the tax burden is split equitably.[1][2]

Tourist taxes are also used as a tool to regulate the flow and behaviour of tourists, to provide funds for specific events or projects, used to promote and market the destination or used to diversify the economy of areas reliant on tourism.[1][3]

The process for paying tourist taxes can either be in advance as part of the visa process or through an online portal, directly on arrival or upon hotel check-in, or included as part of a bill or airline ticket.[4]

Types

edit

Hotel tax

edit

The most common type of tourist tax in Europe and the United States is to levy a tax on accommodation known as a hotel tax, occupancy tax, lodging tax or bed tax.[5] The tax is levied against individuals when they rent accommodation (a room, rooms, entire home, or other living space) in a hotel, inn, tourist home or house, motel, or other type of lodging.[6]

In most countries the tax is levied by municipal, regional or national governments and is usually collected at the point of check-in or, in some cases, as part of the booking process.[6] Hotel tax is paid in addition to VAT and other taxes.[7]

The implementation of the tax varies from city to city. Reykjavík, for example, charges a flat rate per night, per room whereas Amsterdam charges a fixed percentage of the total accommodation cost. In Paris a fixed fee for the duration of the stay is charges which varies depending of the star rating of the accommodation.[8] Iceland and Romania charge a fixed taxed national-wide whereas in Spain and France hotel taxes vary by municipality.

As of 2024, the highest hotel tax in the U.S is in Houston, Texas which is levied at 17% and the highest rate in Europe is Amsterdam where a tax of 12.5% is due.[3][8][9]

Arrival tax

edit

Arrival taxes are paid by incoming visitors to a country and are collected either on entry or pre-arrival as part of the visa application process. The tax can either be a fixed fee, for example, NZ$100 for the duration of a stay in New Zealand , or US$200 per day for visitors to Bhutan (thought to be highest form of tourist tax of any kind).[10][11]

In contrast to hotel taxes, which are usually charged per room, arrival taxes are levied against the individual.

Some arrival taxes are not strictly tourist taxes as they can be applied to all types of passengers.

Arrival taxes can vary depending on the port of entry, mode of travel, reason for travel, travel class, nationality or age.[12]

Departure tax

edit

Simular to arrival taxes, departure taxes are levied at the boarder against visitors to the country upon departure.

In 2019 Japan introduced a "Sayonara Tax" of ¥1,000 to visitors leaving the country and Indonesia charges a tourist departure tax, that differs depending on the airport.[3]

Departure taxes can have many variable meaning passengers on the same flight can be required to pay a different level of tax depending on the travel class, final destination, type of travel, nationality or age.[12]

Although departure taxes are usually charged to foreign tourist leaving their destination country, the Turkish Government have a departure tax only payable by Turkish citizens leaving the country for tourism or business.[13]

Not all departure taxes are strictly tourist taxes as they can be applied to passengers irrespective of type of travel.

Cruise tax

edit

In some jurisdictions, cruise passengers are sometimes subject to different taxes than other types of visitors.

The Netherlands has a specific cruising tax is charged for people staying onboard cruise ships docked in the country.[3] Where as Greece has imposed a Cruise Ship Passenger Levy for cruise passengers visiting certain islands in peak periods.[14]

However, cruise ships receive preferable tax arrangements in other ways, such as onboard restaurant and catering services not being subject to VAT in most tax jurisdictions. [15]

Indirect and other forms of tourist tax

edit

Tourists are subject to other taxes when visiting a country that non-tourists also have to pay. Tourists are expected to pay VAT on goods and services (although some country incentives tourist spending through Tax-free shopping) as well as other forms of non-tourist specific taxes such as the universal departure taxes as is the case with the Air Passenger Duty levied against all air passengers outbound from the UK, The Air Travel Tax in Ireland and the German air passenger taxes.

There are also other instances where tourists are expected to pay a higher tax rate than non-tourists. Tourist attractions can often be priced differently for citizens than for visitors as is the case in much of Asia.[3] Similarly, in Europe cultural sites can sometimes be cheaper or free for EU citizens and full priced for non-EU citizens.[16]

Some countries provide a reduction in tax for tourist related services which can some times be passed on to tourists including lower level of sales tax and VAT for accommodation services, passenger transportation, restaurant and catering services with admission tickets for sporting events and some cultural services being entirely exempt.[15][17]

Some activities are specifically targeted by some governments for higher rates of tourist taxes as is the case in France where skiing lifts and access to off piste skiing carries a levy.[15] Similarly, in Korea an additional bath tax [ko] is levied against users of hot springs.

Impact

edit

Tourist taxes are primarily a way of increase revenue for governments as with all other taxes. However, tourist taxes can be used as an effective way of addressing the impact that tourism can have on the city or region and is increasingly being employed to manage the impacts of overtourism and the climate crisis in the areas in which tourist taxes are instituted.[18]

New Zealand's NZ$35 Visitor Conservation and Tourism Levy, Bhutan's Sustainable Development Fee, Greece's Resilience Fee for the Climate Crisis and Bali's tourist tax are all examples of tourist taxes that are ring-fenced for sustainability initiatives. [19][20] Although not ring fenced in all areas, the revenue of tourist tax is often still used for sustainable purposes. For example, Lake Como used €350,000 from it's hotel tax income for fund the city’s organic waste collection and improve their lakeshore maintenance programme.[21][3] The Balaeric Islands in Spain have a separate Tax for Sustainable Tourism which differs from the rest of Spain's tasa turistica. The Tax for Sustainable Tourism is specifically hypothecated managed by a special government commission for water infrastructure, cultural restoration and environmental preservation.[15] They also took the decision in 2024 to use a portion of their tourist tax income to diversify their economy and reduce their dependency on tourism industry.[22]

In 2002 the Balearic Islands introduced an eco-tax on tourists in the form of a bed tax, levying everyone above the age of 16 with a €1-€2 per night tax. The tax was repealed after 2 years after tourist numbers dropped by 25%.[15]

Venice and Civita di Bagnoregio are both using entry fees in an attempt to limit tourist numbers by charges a €5 entry. In it's first year the fee has had little impact of visitor numbers and has been seen a failure by some. However, the fee made €1 million in the first 11 days which has been used to improve services for Venice residents.[3][23][24][25]

Implementation

edit

The tourism industry is susceptible to high Price elasticity meaning that small changes to tourist tax have a large impact on the demand for a particular destination when considered independently.[15] However, the pass-through rate of tourist taxes to tourist can greatly impact the efficacy of their intended purpose when used to encourage or deter certain consumer behaviours.[15] When tourist taxes have been reduced to incentive tourism the impact was minimal in Portugal, where vendors only passed-through 25% of the intended saving, compared to Finland which saw a large boost to their tourism industry when 100% of the VAT savings were passed through to consumers.[26] It has also been shown that visitors to different types of destinations are more reactive to certain tax changes. Tourists to cities show more elasticity than tourists visiting beaches, for example.[15]

 
2019 graffiti in Barcelona, saying "tourist go home" followed by an anarchist A

Reactions to direct tourist taxes can sometimes be received negatively by tourist and the tourism industry both in the destination and in the countries from where tourists come.[15] The public perceptions of these taxes has been shown to have a direct impact on tourist numbers. When the Balearic Islands introduced a bed tax without consultation they experienced a 25% fall in tourist which has been partially attributed not to the tax directly but to the reaction of travel agents moving their business elsewhere.[15]

Various approaches can be used to target taxes more specifically such as not charging business travellers, only charging foreign nationals, varying the fee depending on the duration of the stay, differing the rates depending on mode of arrival or port of entry, or only charging a tax at peak periods.[3][27]

In March 2023, in response to concerns over National Park funding cuts in the UK,[28][29] ethical travel company Responsible Travel conducted a survey of 670 UK travellers to see if they would be willing to pay a levy to support nature conservation when visiting a National Park or Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty. Ninety percent of respondents confirmed they would be happy to pay between £2 and £10 per night if proceeds were ringfenced to support local conservation projects.[30] An approach adopted by the US National Parks.[31]

Tourist taxes can be perceived negatively by residents of tourist locations when they do not see the tourist taxes being reinvested in the affected communities. This was the reason behind some of the protests in Barcelona and Majorca as part of the wider Spanish anti-tourism protests.[32][33] Protests also arise when there is a lack of tourist taxes in some cases, for example, in the Canary Islands.[34] A report by UN Tourism found that, when not implemented correctly, tourist taxes can have negative and unintended consequences. [2][35]

UN Tourism has laid out seven principles that should be considered when designing tax policy for tourism tax. They recommend that tourist tax should be[35]:

  • Ring-fenced for general tourism promotion or for regenerative purpose.
  • Locally administered to build-in political support and ensure funds are allocated where needed.
  • Transparent with tourists and consumers about the purposes and uses of tourist taxes
  • Designed to engage communities to get the buy-in of residents, local businesses.
  • Implemented with support to help local businesses comply with changes in the tax regulations and with their administrative burden.
  • Monitored and evaluated to ensure the taxes are having the intended impact.
  • Mindful of the burden and benefits of tourism. Understanding the economic benefits of tourism while addressing the burden tourism places on the environment and local community.

References

edit
  1. ^ a b c Beswick, Emma (6 April 2018). "Are you a young EU citizen? Here's what you can get for free". euronews. Retrieved 6 November 2024.
  2. ^ a b "Funding for a regenerative future – could tourism taxes be part of the answer?". UN Tourism. 16 December 2020. Retrieved 8 November 2024.
  3. ^ a b c d e f g h Christine, Theresa (27 February 2019). "41 countries around the world that charge a tourist tax". Insider. Retrieved 23 April 2020.
  4. ^ Leahy, Kate (7 July 2024). "What is tourist tax and why do you have to pay it?". Travel. Retrieved 6 November 2024.
  5. ^ "Tourist tax and its effect on the travel industry". AltexSoft. 15 May 2024. Retrieved 6 November 2024.
  6. ^ a b "What Is A Hotel Tax". FasterCapital. Retrieved 7 November 2024.
  7. ^ Elphick, Dean (19 July 2024). "What is hotel tax? Room occupancy and lodging tax guide". Little Hotelier. Retrieved 7 November 2024.
  8. ^ a b Canepa, Jessica Benavides (11 July 2024). "Tourism Taxes Are Spreading Worldwide—But Will They Actually Stop Overcrowding?". Robb Report. Retrieved 6 November 2024.
  9. ^ Novack, Janet (1 October 2012). "Travelers Alert: The 10 U.S. Cities That Tax Tourists The Most". Forbes. Retrieved 25 April 2020.
  10. ^ "Understanding Bhutan's Sustainability Development Fee". Selective Asia. Retrieved 6 November 2024.
  11. ^ "How to pay the International Visitor Levy". New Zealand Government. 19 September 2024. Retrieved 6 November 2024.
  12. ^ a b "What is Departure Tax?". Alternative Airlines. 3 October 2023. Retrieved 7 November 2024.
  13. ^ Minute, Turkish (20 June 2024). "Turks to pay one of the highest departure fees in the world with planned 19-fold hike". Turkish Minute. Retrieved 6 November 2024.
  14. ^ Khandelwal, Manish (9 September 2024). "Greece Introduces New Taxes and Fees for Tourists and Cruise Passengers in 2024". travelobiz. Retrieved 6 November 2024.
  15. ^ a b c d e f g h i j PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP (PwC) (October 2017). "The Impact of Taxes on the Competitiveness of European Tourism" (PDF). European Commission.
  16. ^ Beswick, Emma (6 April 2018). "Are you a young EU citizen? Here's what you can get for free". euronews. Retrieved 6 November 2024.
  17. ^ Dwyer, L. (2007). International Handbook on the Economics of Tourism. Edward Elgar Publishing. p. 252. ISBN 978-1-84720-163-8.
  18. ^ "Tourist tax. How do tourist taxes work and are they a good thing". Responsible Travel. 23 January 2024. Retrieved 23 January 2024.
  19. ^ "Bali introduces IDR150,000 tourism levy from February 14, 2024". welcomebacktobali.com. 23 January 2024.
  20. ^ Cheng, Derek (7 January 2019). "New foreign tourist tax – vital funds for industry or unnecessary tax grab?". NZ Herald. Retrieved 23 April 2020.
  21. ^ Wong, Kathleen (7 October 2024). "What are tourist taxes? Why travelers are expected to pay up". USA TODAY. Retrieved 6 November 2024.
  22. ^ Wilson, Natalie (31 October 2024). "Mallorcans demand tourist accommodation cuts by 40 per cent on Spanish island". The Independent. Retrieved 6 November 2024.
  23. ^ Ltd, Jacobs Media Group. "Controversial €5 Venice tourist tax finally approved". Travel Weekly. Retrieved 23 January 2024.
  24. ^ "All the countries where you have to pay a 'tourist tax' in 2024". euronews. 5 January 2024. Retrieved 23 January 2024.
  25. ^ Hughes, Rebecca Ann (21 May 2024). "Venice earns €1 million in first 11 days of daytripper entrance fee". euronews. Retrieved 6 November 2024.
  26. ^ "vat rates reform 2017" (PDF). Retrieved 7 November 2024.
  27. ^ "Bettensteuer Deutschland – Alle Formulare zur Befreiung". www.bettensteuer.de. Retrieved 23 April 2020.
  28. ^ Francis, Justin (23 January 2024). "UK National Parks". Responsible Travel. Retrieved 23 January 2024.
  29. ^ Wall, Tom (8 November 2022). "Funding cuts leave England's national parks facing 'existential crisis'". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 23 January 2024.
  30. ^ "The cost of travel: can tourism taxes work?". ROADBOOK. Retrieved 23 January 2024.
  31. ^ Bink, Addy (14 October 2023). "Why do some national parks charge an entrance fee?". The Hill. Retrieved 8 November 2024.
  32. ^ Biino, Marta (30 August 2024). "Italy weighs steep tourist tax as European backlash against visitors grows". Semafor. Retrieved 8 November 2024.
  33. ^ Osti, Linda (28 October 2024). "Barcelona protests: holiday hotspots need fairer tourism for local communities". The Conversation. Retrieved 8 November 2024.
  34. ^ "Thousands protest against over-tourism in Canary Islands". euronews. 20 October 2024. Retrieved 8 November 2024.
  35. ^ a b "TOURISM TAXES BY DESIGN" (PDF). Retrieved 8 November 2024.